NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Predictions Tonight: Best Bets for Thursday
My best NHL anytime goal scorer predictions tonight target three of the league's most talented offensive players, including the world's top forward and defenseman.
Connor McDavid is due for his first goal of the 2025-26 season, and that's why the three-time Hart Trophy winner is among my best NHL picks for Thursday's slate of games.
🏒 Best NHL goal scorer predictions tonight
NHL player prop odds subject to change.
- Connor McDavid to score anytime goal (+135 via FanDuel) ⭐⭐⭐⭐
- Cale Makar to score anytime goal (+350 via BetMGM) ⭐⭐⭐
- Mark Scheifele to score anytime goal (+175 via FanDuel) ⭐⭐⭐⭐
💵 NHL Play of the Day
My play of the day is Connor McDavid to score against the New York Islanders, with a winning $10 bet returning a profit of $13.50.
💰 Anytime goal scorer predictions for Oct. 16
Our NHL player prop odds tool shows the best odds for every market across legal sportsbooks in your area.
🔥 Connor McDavid, C, Oilers (+135) ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Oilers captain Connor McDavid is overdue to score, and I like his chances against a New York Islanders team allowing the third-most goals against per game (4.33) this season.
The Hart Trophy odds front-runner ranks second on Edmonton in shots on goal (10) despite the goose egg on the score sheet. The Islanders have the fifth-most high-danger shots against - look for McDavid to make good on one of those opportunities tonight.
I love the +135 odds we're getting at FanDuel among the best sports betting sites. The implied probability of McDavid scoring are 42.55%, with a $10 bet profiting $13.50 if the best player in the world delivers for us.
🔥 Cale Makar, D, Avalanche (+350) ⭐⭐⭐
Cale Makar is one of the few defensemen you can feel good about taking a flier on to score a goal.
Though the Columbus Blue Jackets have had a solid start to the season defensively - allowing an average of three goals per game - they are due for massive regression with 5.33 expected goals against below expected.
Who better to take advantage of that than the Norris Trophy odds favorite and two-time best defenseman award winner?
Makar ranks second on Colorado in shots on goal and is dangerous with the puck on his stick on the man advantage. Our Gary Pearson likes Nathan MacKinnon to find twine in this matchup in his NHL player props today.
Makar's +350 odds at BetMGM translate to an implied probability of 22.22%, with a successful $10 wager bringing home $35.
👇️ See more SBR!
Want to make sure SBR shows up often in your Google search results and Discover feed? Simply click here and add Sportsbook Review as one of your "source preferences".
🔥 Mark Scheifele, C, Jets (+175) ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Mark Scheifele has been his usual dangerous self with three goals and three assists in three games to start 2025-26. He is making the most of his opportunities as well, with an impressive 37.5% shooting percentage.
I like the matchup against Philadelphia, who he scored against in both head-to-head matchups last season. An overmatched Samuel Ersson gets the call tonight for the Flyers against a powerful Jets attack.
FanDuel is offering +175 odds (36.36% implied probability), with a $10 bet winning $17.50 if Scheifele scores.
💡 NHL expert picks tonight
- NHL anytime goal scorer predictions tonight
- NHL player props tonight
- Rangers vs. Maple Leafs player props
- Bruins vs. Golden Knights player props
📃 Affiliate disclosure
Each betting site featured on SBR has been meticulously researched and selected by our team of experts. If you sign up through our links, we may get a commission.
Not intended for use in MA. Bonuses not applicable in Ontario.
(21+. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)
Related Articles
