If You Don't Think Tony Romo is a Top 3 NFL QB.......

[freakydave]

romo took a terrible sack on that drive... regardless, the team shoulda never been in that spot... brees woulda had 25+ points scored on that d

There it is------------ classic underacheiving Blomo.The game should never have been close to begin with.

[freakydave]

I think talent wise, they are about even. Romo does things Brees cant (See all of his 4thQ escape from the defender and complete huge 3rd down these past few weeks) Brees does some things better then Romo. i think Brees sees the field better. That being said, i think Romo is a better fit for Dallas because of his escapability. Brees did lose to the Rams. It wasnt all his fault though. You can not put all the blame on a QB. Brees definitely has a better offense around him. He throws to guys who are wide opened. He has better receivers and a better coach. Its not fair to compare they two by what their teams are doing.

Hey homer---------- you are embarrassing yourself & cowboy fans everywhere.

[titanup]

If You Think Tony Romo is a Top 3 NFL QB.......

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

....then you simply don't know much about football.


There, I fixed it for you...

Romo is fringe top 10... period

[freakydave]

FAIL, same tired played-out B.S. 1. I don't consider him top 3, probably 5 or 6 2. He didn't play badly in any of the Cowboys playoff games, 80 QB rating is above average anyway 3. I would go and cherry pick some stats from Brees, Manning, and Brady (yes, in playoff games, LOSSES to be more specific) but it's not worth the effort Keep the hate alive!

Yeah lets pretend those are not his stats because it doesn't suit your argument.Those are his stats it's not cherry picking.
look at this list of actual winners & see where BLOMO fits in
Who is best in the big games?
10. Roger Staubach, Cowboys (18 games, 12-6 record)
9. Joe Theismann, Redskins (8 games, 6-2 record)
8. Brett Favre, Packers (19 games, 11-8 record)
7. Steve Young, 49ers (14 starts, 8-6 record)
6. Jim Plunkett, Raiders (10 games, 8-2 record)
5. John Elway, Broncos (22 games, 14-8 record)
4. Troy Aikman, Cowboys (16 games, 11-5 record)
3. Terry Bradshaw, Steelers (19 games, 14-5 record)
2. Bart Starr, Packers (10 games, 9-1 record)
1. Joe Montana, 49ers and Chiefs (23 games, 16-7 record)
0.Tony Romo, Cowboys (4 games, 1-3 record)
There are 20 QB's who are still on the active list with better playoff winning %

[PAULYPOKER]

Jesus Christ stick this fukkin thread up your ass already.......................

It is the most lame argument I ever heard............

There is no contest,, Romo is mediocre at best.................................... .............................

[DennisGreen]

Romo is top 10 but not close to top 5. Rodgers, Brees and Brady are obv top 3.

[dlunc3]

if you wanna say romo is 6 thats fair... but to put him ahead of rodgers brady brees peyton roth is absurd

[darkhat]

1 Brady


2 Brees
3 Rodgers



27 Eli Manning

[dlunc3]

Hate to, but gotta say it....

1. Lebron




7. Kobe

[SportsPedagogy]

Yeah lets pretend those are not his stats because it doesn't suit your argument.Those are his stats it's not cherry picking.
look at this list of actual winners & see where BLOMO fits in
Who is best in the big games?
10. Roger Staubach, Cowboys (18 games, 12-6 record)
9. Joe Theismann, Redskins (8 games, 6-2 record)
8. Brett Favre, Packers (19 games, 11-8 record)
7. Steve Young, 49ers (14 starts, 8-6 record)
6. Jim Plunkett, Raiders (10 games, 8-2 record)
5. John Elway, Broncos (22 games, 14-8 record)
4. Troy Aikman, Cowboys (16 games, 11-5 record)
3. Terry Bradshaw, Steelers (19 games, 14-5 record)
2. Bart Starr, Packers (10 games, 9-1 record)
1. Joe Montana, 49ers and Chiefs (23 games, 16-7 record)
0.Tony Romo, Cowboys (4 games, 1-3 record)
There are 20 QB's who are still on the active list with better playoff winning %

You do not judge a player off of a team accomplishment. Romo has played good in all those playoff games. You obviously dont comprehend that though.

[Deuce]

....

[dlunc3]

You do not judge a player off of a team accomplishment. Romo has played good in all those playoff games. You obviously dont comprehend that though.

Can you judge a qb off theses stats?

Romo: Yards per 16 games:3364
Tds per 16 games: 24

Brees: Yards per 16 games: 4192
Tds per 16 games: 29

[dlunc3]

Arent they the most important qb stats?

[SportsPedagogy]

Arent they the most important qb stats?

Those are good stats, Romo has the highest yards per attempt though ....
I will acknowledge that from the beginning of their careers, and presently, Drew Brees is a better QB then Romo.

[dlunc3]

So if you acknowledge that, how do you figure Romo top three? ahead of Rodgers, Brady, or Peyton? Honestly, do you put him ahead of any of those 4 guys, or Big Ben?

[opie1988]

Deuce......let me give you fair warning here, pal.

Stay the fukk out of this thread.

[Muscles]

Romo isn't much of a winner when it matters. It's easy to name 5 QB's better than him. Manning, Brady, Brees, Big Ben & even Cam Newton already.

[The Seer]

if you wanna say romo is 6 thats fair... but to put him ahead of rodgers brady brees peyton roth is absurd

I would say 6th or 7th is really fair. Brees, Manning, Brady, Rogers are in a different class, then there is Roethlisberger at 5th and then probably Eli and Romo.

[opie1988]

Romo isn't much of a winner when it matters. It's easy to name 5 QB's better than him. Manning, Brady, Brees, Big Ben & even Cam Newton already.

Yes.....Cam Newton.

Cam fukkin' Newton.

Never let me catch you near this thread again, pal.

[SportsPedagogy]

I would say 6th or 7th is really fair. Brees, Manning, Brady, Rogers are in a different class, then there is Roethlisberger at 5th and then probably Eli and Romo.

Eli gets alot of hype ... but he threw the superbowl losing pick ... it was just dropped.
Funny how you can go from choker to clucth it a matter of a few plays.

[SportsPedagogy]

Romo isn't much of a winner when it matters. It's easy to name 5 QB's better than him. Manning, Brady, Brees, Big Ben & even Cam Newton already.

Cam Newton isnt a top 20 QB in the league.....

[Westcoast0]

Eli gets alot of hype ... but he threw the superbowl losing pick ... it was just dropped.
Funny how you can go from choker to clucth it a matter of a few plays.

romo wouldnt know how that transition works

[SportsPedagogy]

romo wouldnt know how that transition works

Cause Romo doesnt have a few game winning drives this season.

[Westcoast0]

Cause Romo doesnt have a few game winning drives this season.

a few chokes as well

he sure can hum it in the regular season

[dlunc3]

why are we not talking about rivers in this thread as well? bc he has had a rough yr thus far? dallas wouldnt be able to accept the trade fast enough if offered rivers for romo

[SportsPedagogy]

Cause Rivers has had the most stacked team and not won anything.

[SportsPedagogy]

LOL Rivers needs one more touchdown to even his TD/INT at 17 ....

[dlunc3]

you wanna talk stacked teams when talking romo??? witten, TO, roy will, barber, jones, miles... Rivers has won 3 playoff games, but has lost to dynasties NE and pitt... romo has had the same talent, but lesser opponents, yet still doesnt have the postseason wins

[dlunc3]

you really think jerry jones would turn down a straight up trade, rivers for romo? he would cream his pants so fast

[freakydave]

You do not judge a player off of a team accomplishment. Romo has played good in all those playoff games. You obviously dont comprehend that though.

"On January 6, 2007, the Dallas Cowboys traveled to Qwest Field to play the Seattle Seahawks in the NFC wild card playoff round. With the Cowboys down 21-20 and 1:19 left on the clock, Dallas attempted a 19-yard field goal. Romo botched the hold for the kicker by dropping the snap as he attempted to set it down. Romo then tried to run into the end zone for an impromptu touchdown, but was tackled at the one-yard line by Seattle defensive back Jordan Babineaux."
CLUTCH
Tony Romo our playoff HERO?

"In the Cowboys' January 13, 2008 Division playoff game against the New York Giants, Romo was unable to lead his team to a come-from-behind victory. On 4th down with less than half a minute and no timeouts left, Romo threw the ball into the endzone, but it was intercepted by Giants cornerback R. W. McQuarters, ensuring that the Cowboys were eliminated from the playoffs with a 21–17 loss."
ANOTHER CLUTCH performance???
"In what became a de facto third playoff game for Romo shortly prior to its start, on December 28, 2008, Romo and the Cowboys failed to compete against the Philadelphia Eagles in a 44–6 loss. Romo committed three turnovers in the game and went 21/39 for 183 yards and no touchdowns. The loss dropped Romo's combined record in December to 5–8 and again raised questions concerning Romo's performance in games of consequence"
CLUTCH
"The Dallas Cowboys became the NFC East division champions with their season finale shutout of the Philadelphia Eagles, the second division title in Romo's three full seasons as the starting quarterback.
Romo had a 104.9 passer rating in a 34-14 win of the Philadelphia Eagles in the first round of the playoffs, earning the first play-off win in 13 years for the Dallas Cowboys, and his own first career post-season win.
However the following week in the NFC divisional rounds against the number two seed Minnesota Vikings, Romo had three fumbles (losing two), an interception and was sacked six times in the 34-3 loss."
Wow he won one & then reverted to old self.

[dlunc3]

"On January 6, 2007, the Dallas Cowboys traveled to Qwest Field to play the Seattle Seahawks in the NFC wild card playoff round. With the Cowboys down 21-20 and 1:19 left on the clock, Dallas attempted a 19-yard field goal. Romo botched the hold for the kicker by dropping the snap as he attempted to set it down. Romo then tried to run into the end zone for an impromptu touchdown, but was tackled at the one-yard line by Seattle defensive back Jordan Babineaux."
CLUTCH
Tony Romo our playoff HERO?

"In the Cowboys' January 13, 2008 Division playoff game against the New York Giants, Romo was unable to lead his team to a come-from-behind victory. On 4th down with less than half a minute and no timeouts left, Romo threw the ball into the endzone, but it was intercepted by Giants cornerback R. W. McQuarters, ensuring that the Cowboys were eliminated from the playoffs with a 21–17 loss."
ANOTHER CLUTCH performance???
"In what became a de facto third playoff game for Romo shortly prior to its start, on December 28, 2008, Romo and the Cowboys failed to compete against the Philadelphia Eagles in a 44–6 loss. Romo committed three turnovers in the game and went 21/39 for 183 yards and no touchdowns. The loss dropped Romo's combined record in December to 5–8 and again raised questions concerning Romo's performance in games of consequence"
CLUTCH
"The Dallas Cowboys became the NFC East division champions with their season finale shutout of the Philadelphia Eagles, the second division title in Romo's three full seasons as the starting quarterback.
Romo had a 104.9 passer rating in a 34-14 win of the Philadelphia Eagles in the first round of the playoffs, earning the first play-off win in 13 years for the Dallas Cowboys, and his own first career post-season win.
However the following week in the NFC divisional rounds against the number two seed Minnesota Vikings, Romo had three fumbles (losing two), an interception and was sacked six times in the 34-3 loss."
Wow he won one & then reverted to old self.

Hey dont hate on Tony! It was his team's fault!!

[KKoz9]

Yeah lets pretend those are not his stats because it doesn't suit your argument.Those are his stats it's not cherry picking.
look at this list of actual winners & see where BLOMO fits in
Who is best in the big games?
10. Roger Staubach, Cowboys (18 games, 12-6 record)
9. Joe Theismann, Redskins (8 games, 6-2 record)
8. Brett Favre, Packers (19 games, 11-8 record)
7. Steve Young, 49ers (14 starts, 8-6 record)
6. Jim Plunkett, Raiders (10 games, 8-2 record)
5. John Elway, Broncos (22 games, 14-8 record)
4. Troy Aikman, Cowboys (16 games, 11-5 record)
3. Terry Bradshaw, Steelers (19 games, 14-5 record)
2. Bart Starr, Packers (10 games, 9-1 record)
1. Joe Montana, 49ers and Chiefs (23 games, 16-7 record)
0.Tony Romo, Cowboys (4 games, 1-3 record)
There are 20 QB's who are still on the active list with better playoff winning %

blah blah, you got a big bag a nothin, just a typical hater hater with the same tiresome, ignorant arguments:

1. He hasn't won a Superbowl

2. He has "no heart" lol

3. re-posting his 4 game playoff record in which he didn't even play badly


carry on

[opie1988]

Check out ESPN's latest NFL QB Rankings....

Romo comes in at #4.

I was off on my assessment by 1 spot.

My bad.

[dlunc3]

they also have the niners at #3 in their power rankings

where is peyton on their list? Im assuming not on there? espn's rankings have always been god awful

[jimmyeatworld]

romo cant even hold a field goal under crunch time, hell most teams have guys who make 300K doing that

shows how clutch tony homo is