Whos the most overrated player in the NFL

[Jerm3462]

Has to be revis. He gets safety help on 75 percent of the plays and people compare him to deion

I agree. (Most overrated is Revis)

Yea, hes a Top 5 corner in the league today, but everyone acts like he's Deion and a Hall Of Famer.

I forget the year, but Ted Ginn Jr smoked him for like a 60 yard touchdown. (You didnt do that to Deion Sanders)

[tcpugh5]

Freeman for sure

[dlunc3]

looked like welker could beat revis every play if he wanted to

[YOUNGBUCK]

I don't understand how anybody could say Vick is 'overrated' after the year he put up last year when healthy. And when healthy he has looked great. Last week vs. Buffalo he had a few bad decesions and a few act of gods. But the week before the 400 yards passing 70 yards rushing. Not many if any QBs can do what he can do.

Everyone in the world now says he is too small, blah this blah that. Eagles will still be fine it will take 9 wins to win that division. they are what 2.5 back? Facing the Red-skins next. Anybody really believe a team lead by Grossman is a good team. I think this whole ting with vick being over-rated comes from more of a personal bias then anything.

Everything that is said about the guy is true. He is the most electrifying player in the NFL. I would pay good money to see him play.
Don't really understand it.

And I don't get this mention of Wes Weslker here. Over-rated is praise that is not deserved. Welker still has to work his offense for him to work in that offense.
mark sanchez? Who in the world has said that he is even an above average qb? Who? Not one person by the media has said that.

The answer is Tebow. Teboow. and Tebow. The guy is loved by the media and fans. The fans are so blind, denver ****** themselves in the ass drafting him, they knew the fans would be chanting his name as soon as the starter sucks, and they would be ced to start him even though he his back up to the back up quality qb.

Def agree w. Tebow but how could u say no one has crowned Sanchez everytime he does anything its amazing greatest thing ever he has more NFL commercials than anyone for wat? Hes the hispanic Matt Ryan glorified game manager

[dlunc3]

sanchez should not be starting in the nfl... and mostly likely will not be 3 years from now

[ebbearsfb1]

yea and those three teams you named would be just great without those three guys peyton is not overrated... but neither is romo or vick... or eli, bc everyone already knows he is garbage

am i not allowed an opinion of who i think is overrated?

all 3 are turnover machines , and for how hyped they are i think they are overrated... that is MY opinion..... add to that all 3 have cost their teams atleast a few games this year


what have romo and vick done to deserve all the hype they get?


eli won a super bowl, but without that he wouldnt be anything special



in regards to tebow lets see how he does first... just caues the denver fans are yelling about him, i dont see how the media loves him, when i hear alot of them saying he should a moved to te or another position

[Harry N. Lloyd]

Ray LEwis, king of jumping on the pile

He's pretty good at finding the cameraman, then giving some rah-rah speech to the rookies. He's had a great career.....but his best days are behind him.

Vick has been amongst the most over-rated since the first game he played. He's the type that a Mel Kiper would drool over at the combine, not so good on the 16 Sundays of the season. The most overpaid guy in the league.

Ladanian Tomlinson, another one at the end of his career. He put up great stats in his day......if your a fantasy geek. When playoffs came around he would sit on the sidelines with a sore hammy. A pillow biter.

Carson Palmer. Puh-leeze. He sucked before he hurt his knee. Since then, forgetaboutit!

The Ryan boys--Buddy, Rex, and Rob. The dad won one Super Bowl with the '85 Bears. You would've thought they'd won six in a row with all the smoke that was blown up their ass. The boys have mouths much bigger than their brains.

The Philly cornerback they got from Oakland. Nobody threw in his direction for five years. Now they are throwing at him and you gotta wonder what all the hype was about.

[YOUNGBUCK]

Cant wait for tebow to start so everyone can see all the throws on the field he cant make

[beerman2619]

Mike Vick hands down.

[YOUNGBUCK]

Asomugha is made to cover in a zone by dumb ass Andy Reid hes not overrated at all corner is toughest position in NFL besides Offensive Tackle an QB... And Palmer was awesome until he got cheap shotted bengals woulda beat steelers that game

[TexansFan]

Vince Young

[TexansFan]

Reggie Bush

[wquine]

im sure eli has been mentioned here, but always worth mentioning again.

[SASH]

You guys cant be serious with that Mike Vick stuff. Absolutely ridiculos

[zsr]

I dont think vick is overrated because everyone realizes he's not going to win you games. First round exit last year, 1-4 this year. Bottom 10 qb, should be compared to flacco and sanchez. Philly got burned on that contract.

[zsr]

Wes Welker. Guy is a product of the system and his QB. You could take him off the Pats, plug in another midget slot receiver, and that offense wont skip a beat.

This used to be true, but he has turned into an elite reciever. He was beating revis constantly sunday. He catches everything near him. He just doesnt fit the prototype so people think he sucks

[ebbearsfb1]

I dont think vick is overrated because everyone but people at sbr realizes he's not going to win you games. First round exit last year, 1-4 this year. Bottom 10 qb, should be compared to flacco and sanchez. Philly got burned on that contract.

fixed it

lol... but for the contract he is overrated... good stuff zsr..

[dlunc3]

I dont think vick is overrated because everyone realizes he's not going to win you games. First round exit last year, 1-4 this year. Bottom 10 qb, should be compared to flacco and sanchez. Philly got burned on that contract.

He lost to the world champs by what, 3? in round 1 bc of two easy missed fgs.... Not a great example

[ebbearsfb1]

You guys cant be serious with that Mike Vick stuff. Absolutely ridiculos

what has vick done that everyone wants to blow him?

[ebbearsfb1]

looks like a vick homer dlunc3


the dude cant stay healthy, turnover machine, not worth the 100 million dollars

[bobbyk1133]

Reggie Bush

I thought I was gonna be the 1st to say him Guy is a waste of space.

Agree with most others on the QBs..

Freeman
Sanchez
Romo
Eli
Flacco
Kolb

Whoever said Bradford was overrated isn't paying close enough attention. The kid has all the skills needed to be great, just needs a better surrounding cast including WRs who can hold onto a ball.

[dlunc3]

looks like a vick homer dlunc3


the dude cant stay healthy, turnover machine, not worth the 100 million dollars

You may be right... But bringing up his first round exit last yr is retarded... The guy played great last yr and has actually played very well this yr. If healthy, he is a top 10 qb and that really isn't debatable... The health issue does have to factor in tho

[bobbyk1133]

You may be right... But bringing up his first round exit last yr is retarded... The guy played great last yr and has actually played very well this yr. If healthy, he is a top 10 qb and that really isn't debatable... The health issue does have to factor in tho

I don't think Vick is overrated, but he is overhyped. I think there's a difference..

[zsr]

dlunc3, why do you always rush to every thread to defend vick? He has the best offensive skill position players surrounding him and he cant win games, if i was a philly homer id be pissed off. Who cares if somebody made a bad play here or there, they should be scoring every drive with those wideouts and mccoy.

[ebbearsfb1]

You may be right... But bringing up his first round exit last yr is retarded... The guy played great last yr and has actually played very well this yr. If healthy, he is a top 10 qb and that really isn't debatable... The health issue does have to factor in tho

agreed... i like vick, think he is a hell of a player, but the hype train that follows him isnt always warranted ... and the fact that he cant stay healthy, and has only played a full 16 game season once is a big red flag. and the contact is just stupid large

[zsr]

Dlunc, did you really just say he hasnt played bad this year?? Arguing with a homer gets annoying..

[SASH]

what has vick done that everyone wants to blow him?

Lets be honest, Vicks not the reason that team is losing right now....we all know that. If you wanna say Vick is slightly overatted, fine I'm cool with that (although I dont neccessarily think he is, I could see how someone could say/think that). But the question the thread is asking is "who is the MOST overrated player in football". The answer cannot be some of the responses I am hearing ie: Vick and Ray Lewis. No way

[zsr]

Lets be honest, Vicks not the reason that team is losing right now....we all know that. If you wanna say Vick is slightly overatted, fine I'm cool with that (although I dont neccessarily think he is, I could see how someone could say/think that). But the question the thread is asking is "who is the MOST overrated player in football". The answer cannot be some of the responses I am hearing ie: Vick and Ray Lewis. No way

Sash vick has been a turnover machine, people just ignore that because he isnt the one making the turnover in the clutch moment. Without his turnovers there probably 5-0. 7 fumbles and 7 picks, and he hasnt even played every snap! Unreal. and no way in hell ray lewis is overrated

[dlunc3]

He hasn't played bad this yr... If he had not missed two 4th quarters due to injury, they are 3-2... Did you forget he had the eagles up 10 in atl when he went out? The next loss he threw for 400 and rushed for 70... So yes, he has played well this season.... Arguing with someone that doesn't actually watch the games gets annoying..

[ebbearsfb1]

for the amount of money, vick is paid ... he can be in the running.. and for all the injuries

am i mean 7 picks, and i believe 7 fumbles

doesnt help

[Stealinhome]

Ron Mexico

[bobbyk1133]

Sash vick has been a turnover machine, people just ignore that because he isnt the one making the turnover in the clutch moment. Without his turnovers there probably 5-0. 7 fumbles and 7 picks, and he hasnt even played every snap! Unreal. and no way in hell ray lewis is overrated

Are you just in the mood to bash Vick or do you really believe he's responsible for their 1-4 record? Last time I checked he doesn't receive and hold onto his own passes nor play defense...

[zsr]

dlunc, vick is turning the football over at an alarming rate. I watch the games and i can see this, maybe the philly announcers are telling you its not him, but you cant argue with 7 picks and 7 fumbles..without even playing all of the quarters..

[ebbearsfb1]

Are you just in the mood to bash Vick or do you really believe he's responsible for their 1-4 record? Last time I checked he doesn't receive and hold onto his own passes nor play defense...

7 picks, 7 fumbles could be an issue though

[zsr]

Are you just in the mood to bash Vick or do you really believe he's responsible for their 1-4 record? Last time I checked he doesn't receive and hold onto his own passes nor play defense...

Feels like im talking to brick walls. Without vick 7 picks and 7 fumbles, there 5-0. Pass blame to everyone else because that whole team has played like shit, but vick has played just as poorly. I dont know how you can argue with that