There's a thread going right now in the
Handicapper Think Tank that I found interesting - and revealing.
As most here know, the denizens on the "tank" are a little different. Few of them cap on fundamentals or gut feel for a matchup - but rather on pure mathematical "black box" models. The one thing you can say about them, however, is that as a group they generally really know their math. And that's what makes the thread I refer to intersting and revealing.
On the question of what constitiutes a "sharp" play - someone offered that a "sharp" play is simply a play that
wins and that, get this, "it doesn't matter what price or what spread you bet into as long as you won the play." Wow! And if that concept isn't surprising enough - some people there quicky jumped in to
agree with the guy.
The thread I refer to is:
http://www.sportsbookreview.com/forum/handicappe...line-move.html
Since those here on 5's thread bet baseball (where price is paramount) and are largely contrarians to boot - the referenced thread might be worth a look - if for nothing else but to see the level of cluelessness re gambling, sports betting and book making that can exist even among a group of supposedly sophisticated players who apparently put real American dollars in action on a dally basis.
Of course, I am not complaining about them being in the pool. Quite to the "contrary." We should be thankful.