Pete Alonso MVP Odds: How Top Free-Agent Signing Impacts Orioles' World Series Chances

The Pete Alonso signing caught everyone by surprise, but his betting prices don't need to - let's dive into some of the value we're seeing in his futures market.
First baseman Pete Alonso - who's featured in my Pete Alonso MVP odds - celebrates a solo home run.
Pictured: First baseman Pete Alonso - who's featured in my Pete Alonso MVP odds - celebrates a solo home run. Photo by: Jim Rassol-Imagn Images
Enjoying SBR content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

Check in on your Mets friends, because they just lost Pete Alonso to the Baltimore Orioles just a few days after Edwin Diaz signed with the Los Angeles Dodgers. As a result, we're checking in on the Pete Alonso MVP odds and deciding if he has a shot at winning the award at +1500, as well as Baltimore's World Series odds.

Pete Alonso MVP odds

All odds from DraftKings

Player MVP odds
Aaron Judge +300
Bobby Witt Jr. +500
Cal Raleigh +750
Nick Kurtz +900
Julio Rodríguez +1000
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. +1200
José Ramírez +1300
Yordan Álvarez +1500
Pete Alonso +1500
Gunnar Henderson +1600

Alonso was just shy of posting a career-best OPS+ last season, slashing .272/.347/.524 with 38 home runs and 126 RBI. It marked his strongest campaign since 2022, but he’ll still need to take another step forward with his new club to seriously challenge reigning MVP Aaron Judge. Judge outpaced him across the board - finishing with a higher batting average, more homers, superior OBP, SLG, and OPS, plus more stolen bases and fewer strikeouts.

Last year's numbers make Alonso’s MVP odds appealing on the surface, but excitement shouldn’t cloud the reality here. At best, Alonso for MVP is a small 0.25-unit flyer and nothing more.

Alonso is projected for a 33 home run season (.815 OPS) in 2026, and while that's a fantastic campaign in itself, it won't be enough for him to win the MVP. This bet hinges on whether or not you believe he'll have a massive jump with more protection hitting alongside Gunnar Henderson. Which may ultimately be the case, but tread lightly here.

💡 More MLB predictions

Want more MLB betting advice? Check out all of our MLB picks and expert predictions all offseason.


Baltimore Orioles World Series odds

Team Odds
LA Dodgers +370
NY Yankees +750
PHI Phillies +1100
HOU Astros +1300
SEA Mariners +1300
TOR Blue Jays +1500
ATL Braves +1600
NY Mets +1600
BOS Red Sox +1700
MIL Brewers +2000
SD Padres +2000
CHI Cubs +2200
BAL Orioles +2200

The Orioles received a bump in their World Series odds after signing the slugger, jumping from +3000 to win the Commissioner's Trophy to +2200 at DraftKings. While this is a pretty strong bounce based off one signing, the Orioles still have a ton of work to do after finishing last in the AL East with 75 wins, ultimately missing the playoffs.

While the lineup is formidable, the rotation consisting of Grayson Rodriguez, Zach Eflin, Charlie Morton, Tomoyuki Sugano, and Dean Kremer doesn't quite strike fear in the opposition. The bullpen also had the sixth-worst ERA (4.57) in all of baseball. Improvements on the defensive side of the ball are needed before dropping any kind of money on this team to make the playoffs, let alone win the World Series.

While the +2200 odds are nice to look at, I'm personally more inclined to bet on the Philadelphia Phillies at +1100 - this team is in win-now mode and is coming back with one of the best home run hitters in baseball in Kyle Schwarber.


Subscribe to our brand-new SBR newsletter!
Subscribe to our brand-new SBR newsletter!

📃 Affiliate disclosure

Sportsbook Review may receive a commission if you sign up through our links. Not intended for use in MA. Bonuses not applicable in Ontario. 21+ only. (Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)