Did any of you read The Hunger Games? Thoughts? Your review?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Capybara
    SBR Posting Legend
    • 08-17-08
    • 11803

    #1
    Did any of you read The Hunger Games? Thoughts? Your review?
    I haven't read it, but apparently it's gonna be mass hysteria when the movie opens on Friday. I had never even heard of the books until recently.
  • Chi_archie
    SBR Aristocracy
    • 07-22-08
    • 63172

    #2
    bunch of my kids were reading it for schools, so it can't be too high level (5th/6th graders)

    they seemed to be into it, and they aren't into to reading ANYTHING if it isn't on facebook
    Comment
    • Iced
      SBR MVP
      • 01-04-11
      • 1614

      #3
      Yeah, I read all of The Hunger Games trilogy books. All the books were pretty good. The first was the best and I'd give it an 'A' grade and the second book and third books weren't quite as good, probably more in the B/B+ range.

      I'm looking forward to the movie but I'm not quite sure the movie will be as good as the book. FYI, I thought the Harry Potter books were far superior to the movies and I thought the Lord of the Rings movies were actually just as good as the books.

      I pretty much see The Hunger Games playing out similar to the Harry Potter series -- great books and good but not great movies. It's kinda funny that both book series were originally targeted at young adults/teens but they blew up into this huge pop culture phenomenon.
      Comment
      • Capybara
        SBR Posting Legend
        • 08-17-08
        • 11803

        #4
        Originally posted by Chi_archie
        bunch of my kids were reading it for schools, so it can't be too high level (5th/6th graders)

        they seemed to be into it, and they aren't into to reading ANYTHING if it isn't on facebook
        Yeah, I gotta say, I never quite understand why Young Adult books end up becoming HUGE books that EVERYONE reads and then goes apeshit over and stands in line for the movies on opening night and buys up all the merchandise and whatnot... Like Harry Potter, for instance. I mean I saw the first one, and I was like "Okay, well, it's fine for a kid's movie, that's about it." Next thing I knew, people of all ages were freaking out over all the books and movies and the franchise is the biggest thing since sliced bread. I'm like whoa, whoa, does anyone in this country read an adult fukking level?

        Can'tt speak to The Hunger Games yet, though, either film or book, because I have no personal experience.
        Comment
        • Capybara
          SBR Posting Legend
          • 08-17-08
          • 11803

          #5
          Oops, no offense, Iced! And I seem to have addressed your last comment with my post!
          Comment
          • Iced
            SBR MVP
            • 01-04-11
            • 1614

            #6
            No offense taken. I don't particularly care for the Harry Potter movies, I thought they were merely above-average and not nearly as good as the books. I read a lot of books and I usually read non-fiction, but when I do read fiction it's usually fantasy-type books. The Lord of the Rings and the A Song of Ice and Fire are my favorite fantasy series and far superior to The Hunger Games and Harry Potter, but each series is pretty good on its own merits. I don't really understand how Harry Potter and the Hunger Games blew up either, because I thought they were good but not fantastic books.. but they somehow gained a huge fan base.
            Comment
            • marcoloco
              SBR MVP
              • 07-05-10
              • 3986

              #7
              I never heard of the books until recently but over heard some teenagers talking about it today while eating lunch at subway and it sounds pretty interesting.
              Comment
              • Capybara
                SBR Posting Legend
                • 08-17-08
                • 11803

                #8
                Originally posted by Iced
                No offense taken. I don't particularly care for the Harry Potter movies, I thought they were merely above-average and not nearly as good as the books. I read a lot of books and I usually read non-fiction, but when I do read fiction it's usually fantasy-type books. The Lord of the Rings and the A Song of Ice and Fire are my favorite fantasy series and far superior to The Hunger Games and Harry Potter, but each series is pretty good on its own merits. I don't really understand how Harry Potter and the Hunger Games blew up either, because I thought they were good but not fantastic books.. but they somehow gained a huge fan base.
                I'm down with fantasy-type books, sci-fi, etc., as well, but are there are any hugely popular series that aren't "young adult" books?? It's crazy. If I'm not mistaken, even Tolkien intended Lord of the Rings for a young audience (not 100% sure on that one, though; it might have just been The Hobbitt)...

                Lemme think of cool fantasy or sci-fi adult stuff I've read... hmm... Clive Barker wrote some cool stuff -- The Great and Secret Show was very good. And Hellraiser certainly turned into a nice screenplay. Well, guess that would be horror, lol. People really like Neil Gaiman's stuff, I can take or leave it.... Paul Auster...eh. There's an awesome book called Lives of the Monster Dogs that is a great read if you can find it.... People are into The Passage by Justin Cronin. I got it but haven't started it yet.
                Comment
                • Iced
                  SBR MVP
                  • 01-04-11
                  • 1614

                  #9
                  A Song of Ice and Fire is generally agreed to be the best fantasy series (even greater than Lord of the Rings) and it is an adult series.

                  A few more fantasy series I like for adults..
                  - Malazan Book of the Fallen
                  - The Black Company
                  - The Wheel of Time
                  - The Farseer Trilogy
                  - The First Law
                  Comment
                  • crustyme
                    SBR Posting Legend
                    • 09-29-10
                    • 16896

                    #10
                    harry potter? what are you, 12?



                    ive read the synopsis of hunger games on wiki and it was confusing and stupid. i bet it bombs.
                    Comment
                    • King Mayan
                      SBR Posting Legend
                      • 09-22-10
                      • 21326

                      #11
                      Iced, im on A Storm of Swords right now...

                      Everybody should read A song of Ice and Fire series..
                      Comment
                      SBR Contests
                      Collapse
                      Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                      Collapse
                      Working...