Mark Ingram or Reggie Bush?

[daimoshokage]

Who would you choose? Should the Saints stick with Reggie or go to Mark Ingram path?

[Living The Dream]

Mark Ingram.. Reggie Bush is a novelty, a great punt returner and a 3rd and long back... he isn't a ball control punisher

[AMBlai01]

What do you mean which? I don't think this is an either/or question....

I want them both on my team if i am the Saints because they are such different backs. Bush is someone that the defense still has to think about where he is on the field...he can catch the ball, run the ball, and make things happen at the blink of an eye.

Ingram is a traditional back...he is going to run between the tackles and get you those hard yards.....

[markteal]

Both, Ingram as your main man though, let him wear the D down then Bush can come in and use his speed more effectively, the Saints O is gonna be a nightmare for the opposition if Ingram can step up to the NFL level.

[daimoshokage]

I think the Saints will cut Reggie or ask him to take a paycut.. They are idiots if they will pay Reggie $11.8 million this season..

[shaunovery]

Start with Ingram use bush as 3rd down or in the slot have both in the backfield defensive nightmare

[cant call it]

bush is injury prone. I would use him in passing situations and kick returns. Other than that he is not durable enough.

[Boscoe]

i don't get why nfl teams still draft running backs in the first round.

[VegasInsider]

Ingram all day long. Bush was a novelty back from the start and there is no way he deserves $11.8M this season. Get rid of him and jump on the horse's back, he can carry a running game.

[PLAYA-PLAYA]

BUSH IS WAY OVER PRICED-----It WOULD BE NICE TO HAVE BUSH AS AN OPTION---QUESTION IS WILL HE WORK FOR FOOD?----I DOUBT HE WILL TAKE MUCH OF A PAY CUT----THEREFORE "BUSH BE GONE"

[William Walters]

As a longtime USC season ticket holder..............I witnessed Bush do amazing things on the football field. He was the most dynamic COLLEGE football player I've ever seen. But, Reggie's skill set just didn't translate to the pro's like most thought it would ("the next Gale Sayers").

No way the Saints can keep him at 11.8 million. Pay cut or get cut.

[NYSportsGuy210]

Ingram was built to be an NFL bruiser back and already ran like one in college. Great pick up by the Saints. Reggie Bush will turn into nothing more than a slot receiver and a dump off option out of the backfield on select third down and short plays.

[iwantcougars]

Start with Ingram use bush as 3rd down or in the slot have both in the backfield defensive nightmare

this

[kickenchicken]

ingram gives much more of a pure running threat but can also catch the ball enough to keep the d honest... plus he is younger

[jjgold]

Ingram

Reggie was always a pussie and afraid to get hit

[mw00]

how can you guys even choose ingram without hiim even taking an nfl snap yet? we've seen college hype players come in and do shit in nfl.

[HoulihansTX]

Cut Reggie.

Him being on your team doesnt add or subtract from you chances of winning.

[William Walters]

Cut Reggie.

Him being on your team doesnt add or subtract from you chances of winning.

Guess you know more about winning/losing in the NFL than Super Bowl winning coach Sean Payton.

[jollyoscars]

ingram. but leshoure is better than him!

[jwbama23]

How the hell can this question even be asked. Ingram runs like the second coming of Emmit Smith. Id take Ingram all day. Oh yea I am a Bama fan

[marcoloco]

ingram

[romecloneout]

bush, ingram will be a bust

[will2survive]

Bush is a malcontent. He's was overrated in college. If Ingram disappoints, at least they're taking a chance. I would choose Ingram and get rid of Bush

[Glitch]

2-back system. smash and dash. dont have to choose...they both do some very important things that the other one does not.

[blanda]

Glitch has it right....good idea!

[freelee]

i say keep them both if possible

[gryfyn1]

Bush was a novelty back from the start and there is no way he deserves $11.8M this season.

There was never any intent to pay Bush 11.8m when the deal was signed. it was simply a funny money year added in to disperse the prorated signing bonus. Even with out Ingram the Saints were cutting or renegotiation the deal.

[Frostware]

I think Ingram all the way... Bush is good but IMO Ingram.

[Iced]

Reggie Bush won't be in New Orleans next season.

[William Walters]

Bush is a malcontent. He's was overrated in college. If Ingram disappoints, at least they're taking a chance. I would choose Ingram and get rid of Bush

Sometimes you write some good stuff...................I'll chalk this post up to serious drug usage.

[venice2222]

Bush is always getting hurt

[biggamer3]

how is this a question? Bush is a nice return man and flex back, Ingram can be an every down back

[darko3131]

I think Ingram is way overrated but then again so is Reggie....so neither?

[darren125]

Running backs just aren't worth that much money anymore since every team splits time and lots of backs don't last that long. I'd go with Ingram.

[the10man]

ingram, for obv reasons. sometimes i think bush should just wear an 80 number