Mark Ingram or Reggie Bush?

[JW Cash]

ya gotta like Reggie Bush.....................he is a total winner

[sportsfun]

ingram, less film.

[FrozenMAN]

both are bums and ingram will do nothing in the nfl other than get money to buy his daddy outta jail lol

[purecarnagge]

Ingram...Bush is higher maintance than Kim was...

[jollyoscars]

bush wont even be back. he talked his way out so its no contest

[Badgers13]

I think they are both very good but in very different ways. It would be ideal to keep both if at all possible.

[BadNina]

how can you guys even choose ingram without hiim even taking an nfl snap yet? we've seen college hype players come in and do shit in nfl.

Based solely on his coach's pro style offense and playing in the NCAA's most difficult league, I would say Ingram is a good choice. He also catches well out of the back field. He rarely fumbles the ball. And he still has his trophy.

[CaptainPrice]

Bush is better than advertised but Ingram could be swell

[slacker00]

Reggie needs to renegotiate his contract. If so, then both. It takes multiple backs to win in the NFL now days.

[jwbama23]

I would guess the Saints drafted him because they knew he was better than anyone they had

[jjgold]

Bush has always been a pussy and afraid of contact

I would try and trade him but I doubt anyone wants him

Ingram is young and a killer

[Pew Pew]

Bush come down to San Diego bro.

[Scottish]

Both, Bush is dynamic out of the backfield but not an every down back, Ingram is your classic 4 yards up the middle back, i don't think you can really compare these guys.

[GunShard]

Sean Payton is planning to use both.

[D3 Mighty Ducks]

If I was Saints fan it would be tough to let go of Reggie but i'd be excited to see what Ingram has to offer.

[raggman]

mark ingram if i had to pick one---bring bush back with a lower contract
would be good for the saints.

[JosephPavs]

Bush is such a flake

[knelson]

Well since the saints traded back into the first round to get Ingram, he's gotta be the guy. There's no way Bush stays in NO without renegotiating his current contract.

[MTek]

Ingram definitely, Reggie Bush is a p*ssy

[D3 Mighty Ducks]

Bush is such a flake

[pm4e]

Both (assuming Bush renegotiates).

[MoneylineExpress]

Ingram

[AlphaOmega]

Ingram will wear them down Bush will run away for a 30+ yard td. It seems like now a days most teams run multiple running back systems. Great addition for the saints now they will have a running game ...

[CaptainPrice]

saints already choose ingram in the draft... so there that answers you

[thezbar]

Ingram! Bush can't be trusted. Just ask the players at USC. He's also another injury waiting to happen.

[AlphaOmega]

Nonetheless a playmaker who can take it to the house on any play.

[Congruency]

Ingram

Pierre Thomas is also still in the fold

[dextermasuka]

INGRAM is the choice...

IVORY, INGRAM and PIERRE is good combination...
If BUSH accepts big cut why not.... also i dont think anybody else
is gonna pay him that much money...

[AlphaOmega]

Ivory is wack, Thomas is decent, Ingram is going to be the man, & Bush will be the wild card do it all rb/wr/punt & kick returner

[hitman09]

Certainly I go with Mark Ingram, Reg Bush is just over rated lately.

[Glitch]

panthers, giants, cowboys, tennessee before white thought it was a good idea to lose 40 pounds

they dont have to choose- a multi-back system can be very effective.

*slaps the guy that said bush was over-rated in college

[OnTheRise23]

ingram

[ryan2010]

Ingram. I can see a lot of potential he can offer to S and to football in common.

[the_situation]

Saints made a deal to grab Ingram...use your brain and think what path they have chosen

[slacker00]

Who would you choose? Should the Saints stick with Reggie or go to Mark Ingram path?

I'd go with Ingram. Young legs @ RB is always the better option. The Saints definitely need a spark at RB.

But the Saints should find a way to keep both. Bush still has some quality years left and is a perfect compliment.