BoS: Biggest Book Collapse Stole $22 Million from Bettors

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ritehook
    SBR MVP
    • 08-12-06
    • 2244

    #1
    BoS: Biggest Book Collapse Stole $22 Million from Bettors
    Another email from the liquidators of Bet on Sports indicate that their perusal of the financial ledgers indicate that when the large chain that operated under that name went down a few years ago, they owed, or had on account, players funds of over 22 million bucks.

    For those not familiar with the event, the downgoing of BoS (their flagship book, Millenium, was perhaps the best known) was probably precipitated by the US Govt, when they arrested the CEO when his plane stopped over in the US on its way to the Caribbean, where BoS's booking operation was located (mainly in wild and wooly - re any regulatory mechanisms -Costa Rica.)

    However, it's practices were so shady to begin with, some think it was only a matter of time before the book collapsed anyway, regardless of what GW Bush's anti-gambling vigiliantes did. A guy named Carruthers, still in jail in Missouri, I think, may have many millions of player money salted away somewhere.

    (I wasn't at SBR at the time, but I believe they may have had an alert out on that very large operation.)

    The liquidators are currently in the process of trying to contact those who had money in BoS at the time of the fall.
    While acknowledging that the bettors will receive, at most, a few cents on the dollar. They say that the great majority of stiffed former BoS clients cannot be reached by email.

    I had less than $600 in one of the BoS books at the time of the sinking. But, I may fill out the form, just out of a kind of journalistic curiousity of how it plays out. (At the time of the collapse the topic dominated various sports bet forums. Some players evidently lost tens of thousands in the debacle. They'll never see it again. Anyone who keeps that much in any offshore should see a shrink. (No, no, not THAT one!)
  • Shark79
    SBR Posting Legend
    • 11-19-07
    • 11211

    #2
    I remember this ... over a thousand employees from BOS were fired next day ... leaving them empty handed ... it was a big thing in CR ... even government had to attend the "crisis"
    Comment
    • MBENZ
      SBR Hall of Famer
      • 01-07-07
      • 5238

      #3
      Ritehook,if you have any luck,I had 7200 in millenium,I'll split whatever you can get,although I think we would be splitting nothing.
      Comment
      • ritehook
        SBR MVP
        • 08-12-06
        • 2244

        #4
        Originally posted by Shark79
        I remember this ... over a thousand employees from BOS were fired next day ... leaving them empty handed ... it was a big thing in CR ... even government had to attend the "crisis"
        Employees were also trying to get paid; they too are likely on a waiting list, and they will have a long wait. Like, forever.

        (Someone at BoS, some still free exec, most likely, had a skeleton crew keep working, for several months after the fall, answering phones from anxious account-holders, assuring them that they will receive their money eventually.

        It now seems that this was a stalling tactic, so that the computers and other hard assets could be removed from the BoS offices in CR, with no one coming by to destoy or seize. And possibly to extract monies or properties in various accounts in the Caribbean.

        There was also speculation, I think well-founded, that much of this hardware, and possibly a few former BoS execs -now in mufti - went to a book now rated A by SBR. But i won't mention any names.)

        There was another post on the topic a few weeks ago, indicating that David Carruthers likely has a fortune salted away. And the founder of BoS, a shady ex-New York bookie ( I forgot his name) is also under arrest somewhere, awaiting trial.

        Keeping large amounts of money in any offshore gaming property is super-stupid. Esp in second or third world nations.
        And I don't care if the property is run by a re-incarnation of Mother Teresa.
        Comment
        • Stacocakes
          SBR Hall of Famer
          • 04-10-08
          • 7126

          #5
          Geez I hate reading stuff like this. Wasn't really aware this happened because I never used that book but I am one of those stupid people that keeps alot of money in these offshore accounts and the thought of one of my books closing shop and stealing my money has always been in the back of my mind.Guess there is nothing that we can really do about it.If it does happen we are screwed
          Comment
          • MBENZ
            SBR Hall of Famer
            • 01-07-07
            • 5238

            #6
            Originally posted by ritehook
            Employees were also trying to get paid; they too are likely on a waiting list, and they will have a long wait. Like, forever.

            (Someone at BoS, some still free exec, most likely, had a skeleton crew keep working, for several months after the fall, answering phones from anxious account-holders, assuring them that they will receive their money eventually.

            It now seems that this was a stalling tactic, so that the computers and other hard assets could be removed from the BoS offices in CR, with no one coming by to destoy or seize. And possibly to extract monies or properties in various accounts in the Caribbean.

            There was also speculation, I think well-founded, that much of this hardware, and possibly a few former BoS execs -now in mufti - went to a book now rated A by SBR. But i won't mention any names.)

            There was another post on the topic a few weeks ago, indicating that David Carruthers likely has a fortune salted away. And the founder of BoS, a shady ex-New York bookie ( I forgot his name) is also under arrest somewhere, awaiting trial.

            Keeping large amounts of money in any offshore gaming property is super-stupid. Esp in second or third world nations.
            And I don't care if the property is run by a re-incarnation of Mother Teresa.
            Carruthers was just a figurehead,the real thief is Kaplan and he spent the lions share on real estate through his family and other shells.The players are last on the list and have no shot at recovering.
            Comment
            • ChuteBoxe
              SBR Hall of Famer
              • 11-21-07
              • 6885

              #7
              Well aware of the BoS fiasco. Luckily, I withdrew a week and a half before they went under. I started getting suspicious that things changed, and the ** and Wire locations were in a different country every 3 days. Soon enough, there it went.
              Comment
              • Stacocakes
                SBR Hall of Famer
                • 04-10-08
                • 7126

                #8
                Was there anything on sbr before the company went under that was giving the players a heads up to get money out?You guys have me all paranoid now haha. Eventhough I play at the "A" books you never know..
                Comment
                • Shark79
                  SBR Posting Legend
                  • 11-19-07
                  • 11211

                  #9
                  Originally posted by ritehook
                  Employees were also trying to get paid; they too are likely on a waiting list, and they will have a long wait. Like, forever.

                  (Someone at BoS, some still free exec, most likely, had a skeleton crew keep working, for several months after the fall, answering phones from anxious account-holders, assuring them that they will receive their money eventually.

                  It now seems that this was a stalling tactic, so that the computers and other hard assets could be removed from the BoS offices in CR, with no one coming by to destoy or seize. And possibly to extract monies or properties in various accounts in the Caribbean.

                  There was also speculation, I think well-founded, that much of this hardware, and possibly a few former BoS execs -now in mufti - went to a book now rated A by SBR. But i won't mention any names.)

                  There was another post on the topic a few weeks ago, indicating that David Carruthers likely has a fortune salted away. And the founder of BoS, a shady ex-New York bookie ( I forgot his name) is also under arrest somewhere, awaiting trial.

                  Keeping large amounts of money in any offshore gaming property is super-stupid. Esp in second or third world nations.
                  And I don't care if the property is run by a re-incarnation of Mother Teresa.

                  That was very true ... they wanted to make sure no crazy a-ss customer would come and create more chaos for them, so they kept about 50 employees + executives to calm and literally lie
                  Comment
                  • ritehook
                    SBR MVP
                    • 08-12-06
                    • 2244

                    #10
                    Originally posted by MBENZ
                    Ritehook,if you have any luck,I had 7200 in millenium,I'll split whatever you can get,although I think we would be splitting nothing.
                    Naw, I may put in the claim, just to see how it all plays. There isn't going to be any money, and if read it right the liquidators are going to take $20 per account off the top, for their labors. (So, I may end up owing them money after all is said and done. I'll tell 'em to get if from Carruthers.)

                    Let's see, if I got two cents on the dollar I could order fries from the Mickey D dollar menu. You on the other hand could get enough for a couple of Value Meals there - take your wife or gf out to celebrate your unexpected windfall.

                    (But later I'll put up the email address of the liquidators who are trying so hard to contact us, to give us our just desserts. In case anyone else wants to buy a Big Mac and a few cookies, for the ton of cabbage they got juiced out of by BoS.)
                    Comment
                    • ritehook
                      SBR MVP
                      • 08-12-06
                      • 2244

                      #11
                      Just out of curiosity, does anyone recall how SBR had the BoS rated at the time of The Debacle?
                      Comment
                      • Shark79
                        SBR Posting Legend
                        • 11-19-07
                        • 11211

                        #12
                        Majority of equipment was bought by a company called Datasencion ... it is now located on the same surface BOS was.
                        Comment
                        • Shark79
                          SBR Posting Legend
                          • 11-19-07
                          • 11211

                          #13
                          Originally posted by ritehook
                          Just out of curiosity, does anyone recall how SBR has the BoS rated at the time of The Debacle?
                          wasnt here at the time ... no ideas
                          Comment
                          • ritehook
                            SBR MVP
                            • 08-12-06
                            • 2244

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Stacocakes
                            Was there anything on sbr before the company went under that was giving the players a heads up to get money out?You guys have me all paranoid now haha. Eventhough I play at the "A" books you never know..
                            I didn't see you post when i asked my own question re this. I wasn't a member of SBR at the time. Or, if I was, I rarely stopped by.
                            Comment
                            • durito
                              SBR Posting Legend
                              • 07-03-06
                              • 13173

                              #15
                              BetonSports was rated D by SBR when they went under.

                              They had stolen players funds many times prior. The same thing will happen with the sportsbook.com criminals one day.
                              Comment
                              • ChuteBoxe
                                SBR Hall of Famer
                                • 11-21-07
                                • 6885

                                #16
                                Originally posted by ritehook
                                Just out of curiosity, does anyone recall how SBR had the BoS rated at the time of The Debacle?
                                Their highest rating ever was a C+
                                Their rating at the time of the debacle was a D

                                BetOnSports
                                Comment
                                • Stacocakes
                                  SBR Hall of Famer
                                  • 04-10-08
                                  • 7126

                                  #17
                                  Well at least you could see something like this coming if it wasn't rated that well. If it was an A+ book and then this happened it would have been more out of the blue
                                  Guess that provides some relief regarding this ever happening again
                                  Comment
                                  • Bill Dozer
                                    www.twitter.com/BillDozer
                                    • 07-12-05
                                    • 10894

                                    #18
                                    BOS pretended to turn over a new leaf a few times over the years but were thieves at the core. They knew the funds weren't there and would take from a player they didn't care for. Millennium, MVP and the rest of the V-wager group were not considered a cheating book until they were bought by BOS.
                                    Comment
                                    • ritehook
                                      SBR MVP
                                      • 08-12-06
                                      • 2244

                                      #19
                                      Originally posted by MBENZ
                                      Carruthers was just a figurehead,the real thief is Kaplan and he spent the lions share on real estate through his family and other shells.The players are last on the list and have no shot at recovering.
                                      Agree that the players have no chance of recovery. I'm a little queasy even about sending the liquidators my info, but the journalist in me will probably overcome my reticence.

                                      I absolutely do not expect to get paid, not even two cents on the dollar.

                                      Kaplan, yes, that's it. David Kaplan, and his sister. Super New York shysters. Now under arrest, I think in the Dominican Republic.

                                      However, Carruthers was an active player. He was hardly a Johnny Appleseed of integrity and rightiousness.

                                      I believe he was the one mainly responsible for getting BoS listed on the London Exchange, thereby giving the scam outfit an aura of respectability. (Wonder if the shareholders ever got any money out of what was left of BoS? Not that I personally care. But the whole episode, if a researcher could ever get the whole truth, would make an interesting book, re international intrigue, skulduggery, massive fraud, super shadies like the Kaplans, etc)
                                      Comment
                                      • ritehook
                                        SBR MVP
                                        • 08-12-06
                                        • 2244

                                        #20
                                        Originally posted by Bill Dozer
                                        BOS pretended to turn over a new leaf a few times over the years but were thieves at the core. They knew the funds weren't there and would take from a player they didn't care for. Millennium, MVP and the rest of the V-wager group were not considered a cheating book until they were bought by BOS.
                                        Do you recall, Bill, when it was that BoS acquired the books you mentioned?

                                        I was with MVP, and seem to recall that I got a 50 or 100% bonus when I joined them, ponying up $250. And since i never could get much above $500 or $600 with them,and never went below around $250, I just left the money in, year after year, which I seldom do. Tho I hardly used them.

                                        I did not know at the time that they had been bought by BoS. Or i would have likely closed the account the summer before The Fall. I do know, as you say, that they were NOT owned at t he time I joined by BoS, as I once asked BoS about it (BoS had a similarly-named book before buying MVP)

                                        I'd also had an acccount with Wagermall, a BoS book that I liked, and always ended my two favorite seasons in the black with them. As usual, the summer before The Fall, I wihdraw a four-figure balance, even tho they tried to convince me to leave it in.

                                        Also, how did SBR have the BoS books rated at the time of The Fall? I'm pretty sure you were nowhere near as sanguine about them as the jokers at some of the other forums.
                                        Comment
                                        • MBENZ
                                          SBR Hall of Famer
                                          • 01-07-07
                                          • 5238

                                          #21
                                          I wouldn't send them anything since it is sold to other corrupt books and your phone will be ringing off the hook.Just consider it a lesson and move on.
                                          Comment
                                          • ritehook
                                            SBR MVP
                                            • 08-12-06
                                            • 2244

                                            #22
                                            Originally posted by durito
                                            BetonSports was rated D by SBR when they went under.

                                            They had stolen players funds many times prior. The same thing will happen with the sportsbook.com criminals one day.
                                            OK, thanks durito.

                                            I knew that SBR was not assuring players that everything was fine at BoS. As were some of the other forums, and one of the main reasons I relocated here.

                                            Yeah, "D". Too bad the players who lost huge amounts at BoS were not here at the time, they could have taken their money and ran, before The Fall.

                                            It's the biggest asset that SBR has, the rep for integrity. While all may disagree with a rating or two, or fault them for not downgrading a cheating or collapsing book fast enough, as long as we can feel assured that they are not taking money under the table from the Kaplans' and Carruthers' it's an essential part of the offshore bettors bookmarked sites. Even if one never reads the rants, insults, and general bs that I and other sometimes post on the main board.
                                            Comment
                                            • ritehook
                                              SBR MVP
                                              • 08-12-06
                                              • 2244

                                              #23
                                              Originally posted by MBENZ
                                              I wouldn't send them anything since it is sold to other corrupt books and your phone will be ringing off the hook.Just consider it a lesson and move on.
                                              No, this is some kind of govt-regulated liqidators, located I think in - uh, what's their name - same little Caribbean nation where Matchbook is.

                                              Not associated with any books. Anyway, I never give books my main phone number, only -sometimes - my seldon used cellphone number (see my post on Cellphones!) or a $3 a month Voice Mail that I can switch around the country.

                                              Like ol' Satchel Paige once said, you never know who's gaining on you!
                                              Comment
                                              • ritehook
                                                SBR MVP
                                                • 08-12-06
                                                • 2244

                                                #24
                                                Originally posted by Stacocakes
                                                Well at least you could see something like this coming if it wasn't rated that well. If it was an A+ book and then this happened it would have been more out of the blue
                                                Guess that provides some relief regarding this ever happening again
                                                Some of the sports betting sites were singing the praises BoS right up until the The Fall.

                                                In fact, even after The Fall. One site owner promised that anyone who joined a BoS book through his site, he would re-imburse them out of his own pocket if they lost money with The Fall, as he (the site owner) was certain that everything would soon be put as right as rain.

                                                I don't know if he ever kept to his promise.
                                                Comment
                                                • MBENZ
                                                  SBR Hall of Famer
                                                  • 01-07-07
                                                  • 5238

                                                  #25
                                                  There is another one here that is going to fall right before everybodys eyes if they don't listen carefully.
                                                  Comment
                                                  • ChuteBoxe
                                                    SBR Hall of Famer
                                                    • 11-21-07
                                                    • 6885

                                                    #26
                                                    Originally posted by ritehook
                                                    Do you recall, Bill, when it was that BoS acquired the books you mentioned?
                                                    BoS acquired MVP and V-Wager at the end of 2005. Millenium, however, I'm not sure of.

                                                    Originally posted by ritehook
                                                    I knew that SBR was not assuring players that everything was fine at BoS. As were some of the other forums, and one of the main reasons I relocated here.

                                                    Yeah, "D". Too bad the players who lost huge amounts at BoS were not here at the time, they could have taken their money and ran, before The Fall.
                                                    BoS dropped from a C+ to a D- in a matter of 1 month. I'm sure everyone here saw it coming.

                                                    7/18/2006 06:09 AM
                                                    BetOnSports downgraded from D to D-
                                                    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                    6/13/2006 10:13 AM
                                                    BetOnSports Group downgraded from C- to D
                                                    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                    6/10/2006 08:35 AM
                                                    BetOnSports downgraded from C to C-
                                                    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                    6/8/2006 03:26 PM
                                                    BetOnSports Group downgraded from C+ to C
                                                    Comment
                                                    • JBC77
                                                      SBR MVP
                                                      • 03-23-07
                                                      • 3816

                                                      #27
                                                      When these gentlemen are released from federal prision. Does any one believe thier lives may be in danger?
                                                      Comment
                                                      • ritehook
                                                        SBR MVP
                                                        • 08-12-06
                                                        • 2244

                                                        #28
                                                        This is the email addy of the firm in Antigua that is liquidating the assets - such as they are - of BoS. (MISCOPIED -WILL POST IT LATER)

                                                        I believe you will have to come up with the email address, or maybe the house address if you were only a phone bettor, that you provided to BoS when you joined, or when they went down.

                                                        Doubt anyone will see a dime. I mean, a real world dime, with FDR's mug on it.

                                                        On the other hand, if Carruthers or Kaplan, to avoid a long prison sentence, dig up the money and give it to the regulators . . .

                                                        Nah
                                                        Comment
                                                        • Shark79
                                                          SBR Posting Legend
                                                          • 11-19-07
                                                          • 11211

                                                          #29
                                                          Originally posted by ritehook
                                                          This is the email addy of the firm in Antigua that is liquidating the assets - such as they are - of BoS. (MISCOPIED -WILL POST IT LATER)

                                                          I believe you will have to come up with the email address, or maybe the house address if you were only a phone bettor, that you provided to BoS when you joined, or when they went down.

                                                          Doubt anyone will see a dime. I mean, a real world dime, with FDR's mug on it.

                                                          On the other hand, if Carruthers or Kaplan, to avoid a long prison sentence, dig up the money and give it to the regulators . . .

                                                          Nah

                                                          Comment
                                                          • Bill Dozer
                                                            www.twitter.com/BillDozer
                                                            • 07-12-05
                                                            • 10894

                                                            #30
                                                            Originally posted by ritehook
                                                            Do you recall, Bill, when it was that BoS acquired the books you mentioned?.
                                                            3/11/2006 12:37 PM
                                                            SBR Bill Dozer reports: The VO group including MVPsportsbook (SBR rating C) and V-Wager (SBR rating C) experiencing technical difficulties as it moves into the BetOnSports (SBR rating C) building. BetOnSports purchased the VO group at the close of 2005. Players report missing pending wagers from their account history as well as slight delays with withdrawals. The sportsbook tells SBR that players may call for a complete record of their active plays and states that the migration should be complete by the end of next week.

                                                            Looks like they bought in 05 and absorbed a year later

                                                            Originally posted by ritehook
                                                            Also, how did SBR have the BoS books rated at the time of The Fall? I'm pretty sure you were nowhere near as sanguine about them as the jokers at some of the other forums.
                                                            A lot of players benefitted by the BOS books selectively stealing from some of the larger account holders. There were confiscation reports in May which were debated on the boards. Almost all of the forum with the exception of Covers, were pushing BOS pretty hard. They had big multi-brand deals with the boards which included defending them against SBR reports.

                                                            BOS was at D when Carruthers was picked up in Dallas.
                                                            Comment
                                                            • intelsource
                                                              SBR Rookie
                                                              • 02-16-08
                                                              • 32

                                                              #31
                                                              Some fairly fresh news involving some of the characters in this drama.



                                                              BetonSports Executive Richard Creed Joins Leisure & Gaming

                                                              For anyone owed money from BetonSports looking to get paid, look no further than British betting firm, Leisure & Gaming, which this week hired one of the BoS executives, Richard Creed.
                                                              Creed, 52, was formerly finance director of BetonSports plc and a partner with Casson Beckman, now part of Baker Tilly. He is a qualified accountant who has extensive gaming industry and corporate finance experience, according to a presser from the company.
                                                              But BetonSports owes millions of dollars to customers. Close to a dozen executives from that firm were indicted by the US Government. Nobody seems to no where any of the money has gone. And being that Creed was finance director....well, you can all do the math.
                                                              The Online Wire reported last year that its sources allege Richard Edward Creed was the mastermind behind the alleged embezzlement of US $17,000,000 from World Health Network N.V., a corporation of the Netherland Antilles belonging to the WHN for which Creed worked as Director since 1997.

                                                              Sources provided evidence according to which Richard Edward Creed signed off on cash amounts he unlawfully received from WHN N.V.

                                                              Leisure & Gaming's main operations consist of online and retail sports betting service BetShop Italia, the pan-European online sports betting, casino and poker business BetShop.com, mobile and online football information service GoalsLive.com, and online casino Acropolis Casino.

                                                              The group’s focus is on emerging markets, particularly Italy and Central and Eastern Europe. Its operating subsidiaries have offices in the UK, Italy, Cyprus, Greece and Romania.


                                                              BetonSports founder, Gary Kaplan, and former CEO, David Carruthers, are currently being held in St. Louis awaiting trial on various charges including money laundering and tax evasion. Some of the charges against Mr. Kaplan have been dropped in recent weeks.
                                                              ----

                                                              Christopher Costigan, Gambling911.com Publisher CCostigan@CostiganMedia.com
                                                              Originally published May 14, 2008 10:09 am EST
                                                              Comment
                                                              Search
                                                              Collapse
                                                              SBR Contests
                                                              Collapse
                                                              Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                                                              Collapse
                                                              Working...