QUESTION, you need a QB for the next 5 years........where do you rank JOSH FREEMAN?

[Fishhead]

Had this discussion last evening at watering hole......one regular(remember this is in Tampa) had no qualms with putting him in his top five and possibly top three.

I like Freeman, but he doesn't make my top five for the next five years, probably someplace 6th-10th.


Interested where most here would rank him.


Again, what QB would you choose to guide your team over the next FIVE YEARS?

[Fishhead]

Would take these TOP SIX below for sure.........then it becomes very difficult in my opinion.





1. BRADY
2. MANNING
3. BREES
4. ROGERS
5. RIVERS
6. SCHAUB



7T. VICK
7T. CASSEL
7T. FREEMAN
7T. RYAN
7T. BRADFORD

[Arsenal]

I agree with your assessment of Freeman in 6-10 position.

Brady is easy #1 pick for me.

[Fishhead]

Brady #1 pick for me.

The purpose of the thread is to find out where everyone would rank JOSH FREEMAN.

[Mikail]

I'm not to familiar with Freeman. He is young and that is always a plus in the NFL. Based on the few times I actually watched him on the field he does seem to have what it takes to be a starting QB in the NFL. Honestly I think it's too early to really tell. I would like to see how he does next season. If I had to take a guess now I'd say he has a bright future ahead. Not sure about putting him in a top ten of active QB's in the NFL though. Oh and I would take Brady to guide my team over the next five years.

[Arsenal]

The purpose of the thread is to find out where everyone would rank JOSH FREEMAN.

I did answer. It did not show up originally so I edited my post. No reason to get your panties in a bunch.

[dfberger23]

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Manning
4. Brees
5. Bradford
6. Ryan
7. Rivers
8. Roethlisberger
9. Vick
T10. Schaub
T10. Freeman
T10. McCoy
11. Sanchez
12. Flacco
13. Cassel

Freeman wins games.

[Metalhead]

No way you can put him in the top 10 yet. The top 6 you have is better, plus M. Ryan, M. Vick, E. Manning, T. Romo, Roethlisberger.

Give him another year or two and see if he's still winning games.

[rm18]

Freeman could be as high as 4 with the age of some of those guys

1. Roethlisberger
2. Rivers
3. Rodgers
4. Brees
5. Freeman

[Mikail]

I am suprised. A few of you don't even have Tom Brady in your top five.

[donnyguru]

Cumulative of the five years, I might take Rodgers and Brady, but this cat will be #1 by 2014. Mike Williams and Arrelius Benn are two young monster receivers. He seems to have the intangibles to be great also, but one never knows until we see him play for higher stakes with greater expectations.

[Fishhead]

Cumulative of the five years, I might take Rodgers and Brady, but this cat will be #1 by 2014. Mike Williams and Arrelius Benn are two young monster receivers. He seems to have the intangibles to be great also, but one never knows until we see him play for higher stakes with greater expectations.

Strong prediction!

[alling]

Freeman most likely will be another flash in the pan. His team couldn't close the deal after getting off to such a great start.

[jjgold]

Tampa was a tough team this year and Freeman did look pretty good

Lets wait and see what he does next year

[dngf]

Right now top 12 to 15 for sure, but compared to the opening list, I would say Big Ben would be in there and Matt Ryan would not be tied for 7, nor would Mike Vick. so maybe in the top 10. It is not that his numbers are not worthy, it's he needs to lead the team to the playoffs beat division rivals when it means TB goes to the playoffs not as their playoff game, take the next step

[Fishhead]

Freeman most likely will be another flash in the pan. His team couldn't close the deal after getting off to such a great start.

The home loss to the LIONS doomed them.............

[ngates815]

Brady
Manning
Vick
Schaubb
Rodgers
Rivers
Big Ben
Bradford
Flacco
Matt Ryan
Luck/Mallet
Cutler
Eli Manning
Maybe then Freeman, but possibly a couple waterboys in front of him.

[Fishhead]

Brady
Manning
Vick
Schaubb
Rodgers
Rivers
Big Ben
Bradford
Flacco
Matt Ryan
Luck/Mallet
Cutler
Eli Manning
Maybe then Freeman, but possibly a couple waterboys in front of him.

FREEMAN is a better QB than ELI right now, or at least on par...........and I can't see anything in the next five years that will keep him from surpassing ELI as a better QB other than injury.

[brxbmbers42]

Brady
Manning
Vick
Schaubb
Rodgers
Rivers
Big Ben
Bradford
Flacco
Matt Ryan
Luck/Mallet
Cutler
Eli Manning
Maybe then Freeman, but possibly a couple waterboys in front of him.

matt schaub in front of rivers and rodgers

that post was awesome

[ngates815]

I'd say on par.

Eli had a terrible year. Freeman had a GREAT year, most likely playing way better than he should of. He'll drop back to reality next year.

Do you expect Eli to throw 25 balls to the other team next year? Do you expect the same or better stats from Freeman next year?

[brxbmbers42]

1.Brady
2.Rodgers
3.Manning
4.Brees
5.Rivers
6.Big Ben
7.Matt Ryan
8.Schaub
9.Vick
10.Flacco

[ngates815]

matt schaub in front of rivers and rodgers

that post was awesome

Other than Freeman, the list wasn't in order


It asked where would you rank Freeman, not where would you rank the rest of the players


you should take that 10 grand from the dog bite and put it to a 4th grade reading comprehension class. Now that would be AWESOME or

[Fishhead]

I'd say on par.

Eli had a terrible year. Freeman had a GREAT year, most likely playing way better than he should of. He'll drop back to reality next year.

Do you expect Eli to throw 25 balls to the other team next year? Do you expect the same or better stats from Freeman next year?

Again, the original quesion is.............WHO DO YOU TAKE as a QB for the NEXT FIVE YEARS, not next year, not for the ten years.


I go with FREEMAN over ELI personally.

[brxbmbers42]

Other than Freeman, the list wasn't in order


It asked where would you rank Freeman, not where would you rank the rest of the players


you should take that 10 grand from the dog bite and put it to a 4th grade reading comprehension class. Now that would be AWESOME or

You're business must be in the tank. Because for a guy that supposedly owns his own business you sure have a lot of time to spend on here. Oh thats right you dont own a business. You just pretend too.

[ngates815]

You're business must be in the tank. Because for a guy that supposedly owns his own business you sure have a lot of time to spend on here. Oh thats right you dont own a business. You just pretend too.

haha

[ngates815]

Is it in the tank, or did you not understand the first time when I said, I can have the machine run and read on the internet at the same time?

Wait....







Ohhh

[ngates815]

Again, the original quesion is.............WHO DO YOU TAKE as a QB for the NEXT FIVE YEARS, not next year, not for the ten years. I go with FREEMAN over ELI personally.

Ok.

Freeman had A good year. I do not think he will have another season of 25 and less than 10int season. He played out of his mind this year.

So yes for the next 5 years, I'd rather have a Super Bowl QB than a guy that had 1 good year.

[ngates815]

Brx you counting your money, or trying to think of a clever comeback? I was able to produce a picture within 5 minutes of you calling me out.

[nosniboR11]

calm down fish, you do not own a thread,

i chooose no qb since there will be no football next year

[Austin103]

Freeman had a very solid season, making some marvelous throws down field in tight spots that just "wow'ed" myself and many others.

Do I put him in the top 10? Not yet, is he borderline top 10? Yes.

12-14th.

[Pride>UFC]

Would take these TOP SIX below for sure.........then it becomes very difficult in my opinion. 1. BRADY 2. MANNING 3. BREES 4. ROGERS 5. RIVERS 6. SCHAUB 7T. VICK 7T. CASSEL 7T. FREEMAN 7T. RYAN 7T. BRADFORD

Schaub below Rivers? Wow the Jewish propaganda these days is out of control

[Fishhead]

Schaub below Rivers? Wow the Jewish propaganda these days is out of control

Was not aware of the fact that Freeman was Jewish, nor do I care.

[iifold]

Fishhead,

how is Big Ben NOT in your top ten??????????????

Pull it together fish....

[Gilly86]

#1. Brett Favre

[Herky]

He would not even be in the top 10 QBs.