Green Bay should shoot themselves for replacing Favre with Rodgers!

[bettilimbroke999]

Just for the record u guys saying how great Rodgers were back then were fukin idiots

GB was about a .500 team that year while the Vikings started 10-1 and shouldve been in the Super Bowl but lost in OT to the SB champion Saints after Favre didnt see a wide open receiver in regulation and the Vikings beat the shit out of the Packers in the regular season TWICE making Rodgers their bitch on both occasions

You smartasses go back over 2 years and pull out threads in hindsight without looking at how piss poor Rodgers was in 2009 compared to Favre was one play away from leading the shitbag Vikings to the SB, hell I guess I should go find a thread that says the Colts are great 2 years and tell them how wrong they were

[Sunde91]

haha Rodgers was supposed to be better than Favre in his first 20 games?

the night you posted this thread Rodgers went 26/37 for 384 yards, 2 TDs, 1 INT, 110 passer rating on the road in Minnesota vs. a Vikes D that was 6th Total on the season

so you're a fukin clown to call "der der hindsight" cause he played great

[freakydave]

Just for the record u guys saying how great Rodgers were back then were fukin idiots GB was about a .500 team that year while the Vikings started 10-1 and shouldve been in the Super Bowl but lost in OT to the SB champion Saints after Favre didnt see a wide open receiver in regulation and the Vikings beat the shit out of the Packers in the regular season TWICE making Rodgers their bitch on both occasions You smartasses go back over 2 years and pull out threads in hindsight without looking at how piss poor Rodgers was in 2009 compared to Favre was one play away from leading the shitbag Vikings to the SB, hell I guess I should go find a thread that says the Colts are great 2 years and tell them how wrong they were

Rodgers wasn't great or terrible back then-----the whole team struggled --but Rodgers & co developed together to become SB Champions.Favre as good as he was will always be remembered for his interception record than his playoff performances.As a life long Packer fan I wanted him gone after the Packer/Giants NFC championship game where he threw a trip to the SB away in similar fashion to the "SHITBAG" Vikings game you alluded to.The thing is Favre was just as likely to piss away a game with his tendancy to INT's as he was to win it.When Favre left it wasn't about Rodgers as much as it was he was passed it.

[yisman]

Just for the record u guys saying how great Rodgers were back then were fukin idiots

You were touting Favre

[Tech N9ne]

Rodgers is best QB in NFL right now.. Hands down.. If patriots could trade Brady and draft picks for Rodgers they would.

[bettilimbroke999]

That was one of the best posts I've ever read Blackrok well said

[eidolon]

Who the hell is Brooks?

[bettilimbroke999]

Who the hell is Brooks?

Aaron Rodgers black brother Aaron Brooks, the guy who he played like when I started this thread

[d2bets]

We'll probably be bumping Cam Newton and Tim Tebow threads in a few years.

[yisman]

We'll probably be bumping Cam Newton and Tim Tebow threads in a few years.

Why wait?

[TobiasFunke]

Rodgers is best QB in NFL right now.. Hands down.. If patriots could trade Brady and draft picks for Rodgers they would.

doubt it...

[poochiecollins]

Just for the record u guys saying how great Rodgers were back then were fukin idiots

Who said Rodgers was great (before I bumped the thread)?

GB was about a .500 team that year while the Vikings started 10-1 and shouldve been in the Super Bowl but lost in OT to the SB champion Saints after Favre didnt see a wide open receiver in regulation and the Vikings beat the shit out of the Packers in the regular season TWICE making Rodgers their bitch on both occasions You smartasses go back over 2 years and pull out threads in hindsight without looking at how piss poor Rodgers was in 2009 compared to Favre was one play away from leading the shitbag Vikings to the SB, hell I guess I should go find a thread that says the Colts are great 2 years and tell them how wrong they were

Lol, "shitbag Vikings"? They were known as a good to great team minus the QB position for several years. When Favre doesn't throw to an open receiver, that's his fault. Nothing else you said isn't addressed by what me and Yisman already said. You apparently didn't learn your lesson the first time, and have made yourself look even sillier.

Actually, don't learn a lesson. Keep writing silly rebuttals with poor grammar. It's good theater.

[yisman]

HE HAS VIRTUALLY THIS SAME OFFENSIVE LINE (4/5ths of it) IN 2007 AND WENT 13-3 WITH HIS 3RD BEST QB RATING SEASON EVER AT 95.7!

PULL YOUR HEAD OUT OF YOUR ASS!!!!

Unbelievable how clueless some people are.

Yeah, unbelievable how clueless some people are. How could someone who pretends to know something say that Green Bay has the same offensive line that they did in 2007?

Green Bay current offensive line

Lang-Colledge-Spitz/Wells-Sitton-Barbre (they haven't had much consistency either, with guys constantly being injured. Spitz and Lang are injured now)


Barbre didn't start once in 2007. He's started 7 games this year.
Sitton wasn't on the roster in 2007. He's started all 8 this year.
TJ Lang is a rookie

Same offensive line? Not for people who actually follow the game.

My favorite part of the thread.

Of course, Sekrah quit responding after I made that post. The only thing he said in the ensuing day was:

LOL.. Look at this stupidity.. I'm done arguing rolling in the mud with clueless meatheads.

Yeah, clueless meatheads like himself, who was apparently too stupid to use the Internet. Aside from him not knowing much about Green Bay, most people could've used the Internet and not looked so damn foolish.

[slacker00]

I thought we'd finally put Favre to rest after he actually retired this time. The fact that Favre is still a topic speaks volumes.

[Fishhead]

Rodgers is average at best, you've got a superstar in Favre, why trade greatness for averageness, I realize they promised the starting QB job to Rodgers when Favre retired but he changed his mind and wanted to come back, if u like the playoffs and winning let him come back, u can develop your run of the mill QB whenever Favre decides to quit for real

[Fishhead]

1. The Packers are one of the youngest teams in the league and don't need a 40 yr old egomaniac with diminished skills who held the entire franchise hostage for two years for his own selfish reasons leading their team and setting a horrible example for developing players.

2. Rodgers has all the tools and, more importantly, the character (which he valiantly displayed last night), to be a perennial pro-bowler in the league for 10 years. Ask anyone who talks intelligently about the NFL.

3. Donald Lee dropped the ball on 4th down in the end zone sir.

4. I think you have Favre confused with someone if you're referring to him as the Supermodel. If he equates to any supermodel, it would be that tore up, over the hill, stomach turning, obnoxious, primadonna Janice Dickinson.

5. You saw how your "supermodel" worked out for the Jets last year.

6. His last year with the Packers was his best in a decade but that was an anomaly not the norm. He was embarrassingly bad for the several years before and a good percentage of Packer fans wanted him gone then.

[Fishhead]

This.

Decent arm strength, good accuracy, but he's got a strain of the David Carr-disease. I really don't think he has the "It"-factor to shake it.

Comparing RODGERS to CARR.........................

[Fishhead]

RODGERS REMINDS ME MORE OF JEFF GEORGE every time i see him not exactly same but like how every1 loved that guy and his cannon arm and look how his career went.. so sick of hearing what rodgers does well. lets focus on the things he sux at which happen to be the most important tools a qb needs.
he cannot process and read a d for shit it looks as if by time he plants his bak foot on his drop he still has know clue where the ball is going which leads 2 problem number 2 happy feet! blame there line all you want and sure it is weak. but no1 can block for 8 dam seconds!! this guy is terrible decision maker holds ball way to long and bottom line he is not or never will be a winner..RODGER F3KIN RABBIT ALWAYS HOPIN AROUND LIKE A DAM FOOL TRY 5 STEPS PLANT FOOT THROW BALL CAUSE THIS WHOLE 5 STEPS THAN LOOK DOWN FIELD SHIT WONT GET IT DONE IN THE NFL

[Fishhead]

Good point. Favre is a HOFer for a reason. It's not so much that Rodgers sucks, but that Favre left behind some huge shoes to fill. I think Steve Young still carries around an inferiority complex from his years behind Montana. Even if Rodgers wins a ring some day, he'll always be cast in the shadow of Favre.

[Fishhead]

There is a big difference between Rodgers and Favre. Yes Rodgers is a stat monster, but he is not a leader. A true leader in the NFL, elevates the play of the people around him. Favre is a true leader and a true champion. Two things that Aaron Rodgers and his dead fish like attitude will never be.

[SparJMU]

Rodgers is average at best, you've got a superstar in Favre, why trade greatness for averageness, I realize they promised the starting QB job to Rodgers when Favre retired but he changed his mind and wanted to come back, if u like the playoffs and winning let him come back, u can develop your run of the mill QB whenever Favre decides to quit for real

Why is it so much fun to read incompetent posts and then make fun of them? There should be some kind of rule where people like this need to be publicly humiliated.

My group of friends are all big Eagles fans, and I have been a season ticket holder forever. When Vick was shocking the world last year they all drank the kool aid and started talking about how he is the future of the franchise. I am not an idiot, so I let them all know that Michael Vick is an amazing athlete and a sub-par QB, therefore would not win a playoff game in 2011. Once they lost last year we went into a public forum and I was allowed to throw a pie in each of their faces. It was a very entertaining spectacle to witness.

The moral of the story is, this guy needs to be publicly humiliated for his incompetence.

[BeatTheJerk]

He 1st called him Aaron Brooks until we corrected him.

[Weeton]

Who said Rodgers was great (before I bumped the thread)?



Lol, "shitbag Vikings"? They were known as a good to great team minus the QB position for several years. When Favre doesn't throw to an open receiver, that's his fault. Nothing else you said isn't addressed by what me and Yisman already said. You apparently didn't learn your lesson the first time, and have made yourself look even sillier.

Actually, don't learn a lesson. Keep writing silly rebuttals with poor grammar. It's good theater.

This thread is grrrreat!

[Fishhead]

if this kind of post doesn't get someone warned i don't know what should

[slacker00]

Just wait until Rodgers gets his next concussion behind that dubious line against some serious defenses coming up. LOL

If there's any criticism left for Rodgers, it's his durability. 2 of the 3 seasons behind Favre he finished the season on IR as a BACKUP, he got injured in PRACTICE for Christ sakes. Last year he got touched on the helmet and missed 1 1/2 games with a concussion. The guy is glass fragile and is one hit away from being a woulda coulda been great one. Sure, he's playing great at the moment, but he will never get close to Favre's career numbers because Rodgers' body simply won't hold up to the weekly beatings like Favre did.

[ThaTopMoron]

Favre is 95x the QB Rodgers why sink your own organization, hell if Favre wants to come back let him come back at least hes not throwin 2 yrd wide open incompletes on 4th and goal

If you were dating a supermodel and fukin her every night then she said she wanted to breakup and you start dating a fukin hog would you tell her to fuk off when she wants to come back a month later bc youve gotten used to the hog

wow...

[ThaTopMoron]

Just for the record u guys saying how great Rodgers were back then were fukin idiots

GB was about a .500 team that year while the Vikings started 10-1 and shouldve been in the Super Bowl but lost in OT to the SB champion Saints after Favre didnt see a wide open receiver in regulation and the Vikings beat the shit out of the Packers in the regular season TWICE making Rodgers their bitch on both occasions

You smartasses go back over 2 years and pull out threads in hindsight without looking at how piss poor Rodgers was in 2009 compared to Favre was one play away from leading the shitbag Vikings to the SB, hell I guess I should go find a thread that says the Colts are great 2 years and tell them how wrong they were

the facts are, the Vikings were built to win that year... and the Packers on the other hand, were still forming their new identity with Rodgers at QB. Rodgers himself, was still doing the learning curve thing when it comes to be an NFL starter.

saying at that point, in 09, that the Packers had made a mistake by not keeping an ancient QB just because his team was doing better (as they were built to win that year) was just plain stupid.

Rodgers tore it up in his playoff game vs the Cardinals... but his D was tore up too by another hall of famer, and he had that crazy play in OT so they lost... not everybody can be Brady and get a do-over.

[freakydave]

Just wait until Rodgers gets his next concussion behind that dubious line against some serious defenses coming up. LOL If there's any criticism left for Rodgers, it's his durability. 2 of the 3 seasons behind Favre he finished the season on IR as a BACKUP, he got injured in PRACTICE for Christ sakes. Last year he got touched on the helmet and missed 1 1/2 games with a concussion. The guy is glass fragile and is one hit away from being a woulda coulda been great one. Sure, he's playing great at the moment, but he will never get close to Favre's career numbers because Rodgers' body simply won't hold up to the weekly beatings like Favre did.

Wow & you are a founder of this forum.Welcome to the clown list your the top CLOWN in this circus.

[ehp6737]

Got any stock tips? Thks

[mikea33]

Got any stock tips? Thks

Too funny!

Loved Rodgers on Cal. Loved him from his first game as a pro. Was Peyton Manning as good as he is now when he was Rookie? Sure he was behind Favre and what not, but until you actually play in the NFL your going to make "rookie" mistakes in your 3rd or 4th year in the league.

[MysteryMung]

Just wait until Rodgers gets his next concussion behind that dubious line against some serious defenses coming up. LOL

If there's any criticism left for Rodgers, it's his durability. 2 of the 3 seasons behind Favre he finished the season on IR as a BACKUP, he got injured in PRACTICE for Christ sakes. Last year he got touched on the helmet and missed 1 1/2 games with a concussion. The guy is glass fragile and is one hit away from being a woulda coulda been great one. Sure, he's playing great at the moment, but he will never get close to Favre's career numbers because Rodgers' body simply won't hold up to the weekly beatings like Favre did.

Favre Superbowls - 1
Rodgers Superbowls - 1

Nobody gives a shit about the rest. If Rodgers brings another, you'll be turning from Brett Favre Way onto Aaron Rodgers Drive.

[meader99]

Just wait until Rodgers gets his next concussion behind that dubious line against some serious defenses coming up. LOL

If there's any criticism left for Rodgers, it's his durability. 2 of the 3 seasons behind Favre he finished the season on IR as a BACKUP, he got injured in PRACTICE for Christ sakes. Last year he got touched on the helmet and missed 1 1/2 games with a concussion. The guy is glass fragile and is one hit away from being a woulda coulda been great one. Sure, he's playing great at the moment, but he will never get close to Favre's career numbers because Rodgers' body simply won't hold up to the weekly beatings like Favre did.

Seems to me that Rodgers already has as many trophies in his short career than Favre does. Isn't that the career number that matters? Durability? Really? Guess he didn't prove anything making it through a season in which he was sacked 50 times. Apparently we have another fella that knows more than Ted Thompson even though a blind man can see he made all the right moves.

[meader99]

the facts are, the Vikings were built to win that year... and the Packers on the other hand, were still forming their new identity with Rodgers at QB. Rodgers himself, was still doing the learning curve thing when it comes to be an NFL starter.

saying at that point, in 09, that the Packers had made a mistake by not keeping an ancient QB just because his team was doing better (as they were built to win that year) was just plain stupid.

Rodgers tore it up in his playoff game vs the Cardinals... but his D was tore up too by another hall of famer, and he had that crazy play in OT so they lost... not everybody can be Brady and get a do-over.

Yes sir...Some folks forget that Tarvaris Jackson himself won 10 games with that Viking team the year before Favre came on board. Yeah, that's right, Tarvaris Jackson.

[warriorfan707]

ya wtf were they thinking

what a bunch of morons

[bettilimbroke999]

Rodgers was a piss poor goal line interception throwin bitch in October 2009, having gone an abismal 6-10 his previous season and blowing games left and right including every close game he played.

He has developed into a great QB which is fine but the idiots that were touting him in October 2009 had their heads up their asses, he WAS garbage back then

Maybe Cam Newton will develop into a SB winning QB in three years, maybe he wont, we have to judge how he plays currently since none of us have a time machine and can predict whether a run of the mill QB is going to fully develop his talents or not. Look at the NFL's hit or miss history with rookie QBs, sometimes you get a Peyton Manning sometimes you get a Ryan Leaf. Rodgers has developed from run of the mill to gold.