PEYTON MANNING iS THE MOST OVERRATED ATHLETE EVER -- EVER. This guy gets hyped up every year like he is a god, then he chokes every year. The only question is - when will his annual choke occur. I was so so hoping he would wait until the SB again this year to choke against the Seahawks again. But I knew there was no way he would wait that long 2 straight years. This guy has a career losing playoff record despite being on a #1 or #2 seed team almost every year. Only 1 ring when he has been #1 seed like 6-7 times. This guy spent most of his career in a garbage division where he padded his stats against terrible Texan teams, horrendous Jag teams, and generally bad Titan teams. Anytime and I mean Anytime he faces a really good defense he looks like a damn joke. But he runs up his numbers against all the garbage teams. The Colts would have won the division all those years with any average QB. Most years the rest of the division was a freaking joke. His brother has more rings than him and Russell Wilson will have more rings at the end of this season despite having only 3 full season to Mannings 20 or so. I remember years ago when the colts kicker vanderjeight called Mannings sissy ass out, but no one wanted to listen because Manning is so freaking perfect. Perfectly OVERRATED.
-
-
Gawd, would you f..ks just go away already, he's out of the playoffs find some else to bash low life.Comment -
interesting read
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-most-clutch-postseason-quarterback-of-all-time-is-eli-manning/
Manning’s teams have been favored, according to our Elo ratings, in 17 of his 24 postseason games. It’s often been a narrow advantage; viewed probabilistically, you’d set the over line at 13 or 14 wins. Manning has won 11. It’s not a totally disastrous record — Manning has won a Super Bowl, after all, and led his team to two others — but it’s on the lower end for great quarterbacks relative to the lofty expectations they establish.Comment -
The Sheriff seems like a good guy and is a good QB. Yeah he has struggled in the playoffs, but has that one ring. There are many other athletes more deserving of your diatribe other than the Sheriff. BTW How many coins did you lose on Denver yesterday?Comment -
There is already hundreds of Peyton bashing threads on PT, I wish the mod would just merge these threads into one. We get it, you don't like Peyton and you feel great by saying it, now dissappear troll.Comment -
I would never in my life lay -7 on this guy in the playoffs. LOL. I have been calling him choke boy on this board for over a year, even back before he choked against us last year. I would lay -7 on this guy in the playoffs against anyone. No chance in hell. I still remember all the times his team was #1 seed, favored huge and lose in their first game.Comment -
He sucks.
Brady > everyone elseComment -
Eli will always have more rings than Peyton.Comment -
Brady Rogers Big Ben all more clutch. In second tier with Brees Romo Flacco Brother.Comment -
I couldn't agree moreComment -
Why was he playing if he was so badly injured? Osweiler could have done better. Terrible performance!Comment -
He is to the NFL like the Atlanta Braves were for so many years in MLB.
Great during the regular season but a choke artist in the playoffs.
The bigger the game the worse he plays.Comment -
Unlike my Boy Russell Wilson who says " I was made for these situations"Comment -
Manning has always been a loser.Comment -
Manning has always been a loser.Comment -
All these manning bashing threads are funny.. He was injured and that explains the bad 4-5 games to end the season . He's 38 fkn years old half you old fks can't even get off the coach and he's breaking NFL records at that age. A 30 year old manning > any qb EVER. All you penetrating clowns don't realize Indy played a great game against a injured qb. They deserved it but that wasn't peytons fault.
Broncos will make one last push next year and when they beat Indy and New England on route to their super bowl this thread will get bumped and my post will be quoted .Comment -
Did the ravens win Nav? Lmao.
Broncos another superbowl push lmao?
Is terrell Davis coming back?
Elway is a loser as well. Broncos LMAOComment -
Overrated implies he's never accomplished anything. Far from it.Comment -
This might have been useful months ago. How can we use this to bet against him now? Look forward, not backward.Comment -
Comment -
Brady won 3 SBs by a field goal each time. Manning needed Vanderjagt to make a 40 yard fg to beat Pittsburgh. He missed and Pitt went on to win the SB. Manning had Flacco beat and their defense couldn't stop a 70 yd pass w/30 seconds left. The Ravens went on to win the SB. The Pats scored 31 points total in the 2 SB losses to the Giants. 15.5 points/game ain't cutting it Mr Brady? Point is...that its a team game and even a great QB needs help. I don't know how many times I watched Rivers chew up Indy in the playoffs...I was at one game. Peyton throws a long TD with 3 min left and Rivers wins it anyway.Comment -
Tom Brady is the greatest QB of the modern era.Comment -
Oh god.. 38 year old manning couldnt make it to a SB again what a shamee..
over-rated? lmao yes hes been awful in the playoffs but can you name a better QB that can read a Defense better or has better mechanics than manning? H'es in the same situation Kobe Bryant is, people were riding his Dlck in his prime but all of the sudden hes the worst player ever because hes old as shet.Comment -
Had his playoff struggles no doubt and will never be on par with some other greats post season wise no doubt. I even put a small asterisk next to his lone title ...Grossman really?!? Title of thread still beyond moronic and Peyton is arguably best reg season QB ever and top 5 overall all-time. Maybe a tad overhyped due to postseason failures year in and year out with alot of that being him playing like shit but still legend!Comment -
If Manning is overrated, then Brett Favre is also overrated. Get over it, it's annoying to constantly flame him for his playoff choking.Comment
