PEYTON MANNING iS THE MOST OVERRATED ATHLETE EVER -- EVER

[broadway6]

The guy has a ring. Pipe the fukk down.

[rocky16]

The guy has a ring. Pipe the fukk down.

Trent dilfer has a ring.

[broadway6]

Trent dilfer has a ring.

IMO if you want to call someone overrated, call Dan Marino overrated.

people that think Manning is the best ever (if anyone does), then yes, overrated

[k13]

So is Brady since all he does is choke in the playoffs now...probably another loss this year.

[jjgold]

lol

Manning one of best ever

Tough to win titles

[BriGuy]

interesting read

http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-most-clutch-postseason-quarterback-of-all-time-is-eli-manning/

Manning’s teams have been favored, according to our Elo ratings, in 17 of his 24 postseason games. It’s often been a narrow advantage; viewed probabilistically, you’d set the over line at 13 or 14 wins. Manning has won 11. It’s not a totally disastrous record — Manning has won a Super Bowl, after all, and led his team to two others — but it’s on the lower end for great quarterbacks relative to the lofty expectations they establish.

Yes I read this. Of course, it doesn't hurt that he has made the playoffs only 5 times in 11 years so he doesn't really have all that many losses.

[GunShard]

This made me laugh:

[rocky16]

So is Brady since all he does is choke in the playoffs now...probably another loss this year.

9 AFC championship games. SBR members, still retarded.

[rocky16]

lol

Manning one of best ever

Tough to win titles

Its not about only winning titles pal. 9 one and dones most of those at home coming off bye and favored. Guy is a total focking loser. Was in college too. Always has been a loser and always will be a loser.

[R.P. McMurphy]

And been OWNED most his career by Brady his biggest rival and measuring stick! If it weren't for a fluke catch '07 by Tyree, and a missed catch by Welker in the next one which he makes more often than not I'm willing to bet. Then Brady would be 5-0 in SB's but still has a very impressive 3. And let's not forget the "Patriot way" is far different and be much tougher for many guys to excel at year in year out. Working with a constant different rotation while your best proven players get shipped so NE can avoid paying them.

[BeanTownClown88]

Manning is over rated because 95-100% of all these one and dones happened when manning's team was the favorite.
And he lost to the same teams that he beat in the regular season..death, taxes, manning losing in the playoffs unless Rex Grossman is playing

[boomer62]

Tired of all the Manning bashing. DUMFUKS ,he is a HALL OF FAMER! One of the best ever. YES, he has lost many big playoff games. He also hasn't always had a complete team around him and many suspect defenses. And Brady another Hall of FAMER has had the privilege of playing for the best run organization in the NFL for the last 10 plus years with a great coach and owner. Brady has failed many times as well. Can't win every year. (Can't BEAT ELI , only Peyton LMAO)
Good luck finding the next Brady and Manning out there. Their is only a handful of good QB's out there and 2/3 of the league has NONE and can't find one. STF up already. Like him or not, HALL OF FAMER and one of the BEST, give RESPECT where respect is due. (Kids now a days, no respect)

[slacker00]

Trent dilfer has a ring.

Fair point. Put 2015 Peyton Manning on the 2000 Ravens and he gets a ring. It's a team sport, guys.

[R.P. McMurphy]

@Boomer ...Well excuse the fukk out of some here who don't jerk off to this guys poster over our bed and give him a free pass for everything without question. Been watching Nfl for 30 years and no kid. I know Manning apologists want to make an excuse for him at every stop. I did mention in my 1st response here the guy is a legend and arguably goat in reg season.

I just question his postseason record and can't find many excuses really for a guy at his caliber. Hes been on plenty of great teams loaded on offense and solid at least on D while favored in all postseason games I can think of yet well below .500 with many awful performances by him personally. The old saying goes where there's smoke there's fire and something to be said for his disappearing acts in postseason. Once again the guy is legend but getting hurt was the best thing that ever happened to Indy so they could get Luck. And sorry Denver fans but I think you've got the best you will see outta him. Good luck with your next QB search even good solid ones hard to find.

[z-doggie]

what about the pizza ??

Is that overrated too ??

[R.P. McMurphy]

Yes but doubt he eats it much or drives a Buick at all. Just another annoying whore we have to see on every other commercial when football is on.

[sweethook]

I would say there is 812,045 others more over rated then he is

[pavyracer]

He is the Dan Marino of his era. Good stats but can't win when it matters.

[dfish]

[slacker00]

Yes but doubt he eats it much or drives a Buick at all. Just another annoying whore we have to see on every other commercial when football is on.

Yep, those pizza commercials are so sickening. Bringing Joe Montana back from the dead isn't helping either.

[BriGuy]

Its not about only winning titles pal. 9 one and dones most of those at home coming off bye and favored. Guy is a total focking loser. Was in college too. Always has been a loser and always will be a loser.

I agree. Guy has been choking in big games ever since he was Steve Spurrier's annual biotch.

Peyton Manning in college: 39-3 against everyone except Florida, but 0-3 against the Gators which back then was the biggest game of the year.

[frostno98]

This is what this stupid homer leahmichele get for making fun of Peyton Manning, Russell Wilson is absolutely putrid in the NFC championship game.

[44 Mag]

So is Brady since all he does is choke in the playoffs now...probably another loss this year.

[LeahMichele]

All these manning bashing threads are funny.. He was injured and that explains the bad 4-5 games to end the season . He's 38 fkn years old half you old fks can't even get off the coach and he's breaking NFL records at that age. A 30 year old manning > any qb EVER. All you penetrating clowns don't realize Indy played a great game against a injured qb. They deserved it but that wasn't peytons fault.

Broncos will make one last push next year and when they beat Indy and New England on route to their super bowl this thread will get bumped and my post will be quoted .

Injured ? WTF is the excuse all the other years. He has been hyped up only to choke for the last 15 years.

[LeahMichele]

This is what this stupid homer leahmichele get for making fun of Peyton Manning, Russell Wilson is absolutely putrid in the NFC championship game.

ROFLMAO. Maybe he will have a better game in the SUPERBOWL. LOL. ROFLMAO. Even with todays bad game, Russell Wilson has the highest playoff QB rating in NFL HISTORY and in 2 weeks he will have more rings in 3 seasons than choke boy has in what ? 15 ? Not to mention beating choke boy by the largest margin in SUPERBOWL HISTORY. " There is no way the Broncos will win 6 games this year" --- FROSTNO98

[stefan084]

what does the seahawks having a better team than Denver have to do w/ Wilson being better? by that logic trent dilfer is an awesome qb, he won a superbowl right?

[frostno98]

what does the seahawks having a better team than Denver have to do w/ Wilson being better? by that logic trent dilfer is an awesome qb, he won a superbowl right?

You can't talk sense into these bandwagon fans.

[2daBank]

This is what this stupid homer leahmichele get for making fun of Peyton Manning, Russell Wilson is absolutely putrid in the NFC championship game.

you calling ppl a "stupid homer"? pot meet kettle..

[nyplayer33]

Brady is a top 5 qb of all time. 3 titles going for number 4..look at his career numbers, he is the best QB for tds to int ratio. He is at 3 to 1 ratio. Many other qbs are up there, but not as good.

[2daBank]

Brady is a top 5 qb of all time. 3 titles going for number 4..look at his career numbers, he is the best QB for tds to int ratio. He is at 3 to 1 ratio. Many other qbs are up there, but not as good.

best of this generation w/o a doubt.. that really all ya can be, it a exercise in futility to try and compare from one generation to the next as the game has changed so much, of coarse now days qbs are gonna hold every record because the gm is a bitch made shell of its former self.. by my math best of this generation would indeed put him in the top 5 so you sir are correct..

[swordsandtequila]

Brady is a top 5 qb of all time. 3 titles going for number 4..look at his career numbers, he is the best QB for tds to int ratio. He is at 3 to 1 ratio. Many other qbs are up there, but not as good.

Actually, that would be Aaron Rodgers, and it's not close. 3.96 to 2.74. FWIW.

http://www.footballdb.com/leaders/career-passing-tdintratio

[LeahMichele]

what does the seahawks having a better team than Denver have to do w/ Wilson being better? by that logic trent dilfer is an awesome qb, he won a superbowl right?

dude wilson has won more games than any qb ever id in his first 3 seasons, has he highest playoff qb rating ever, will have 2 rings in 3 full seasons. Dilfer did not do ay of that. choke boy manning has been on a top 3 team almost every year of his career. so the choke boy fans crying that he hasnt been on good team, well they must be on drugs. He has been on a SB contender team every year ????????? you guys try to make it sound as if he has been qbing the jags all his career

[willydk]

Manny lost his touch this year

[terpkeg]

Nah, I think the constant jabber about whether he is a "great" or not demonstrates that he is underrated. He revolutionized the sport running a "no huddle" that controlled clock and kept the other teams offense off the field. Guy is a football genius.

[frostno98]

Beside Superbowl rings, what else they want from this guy. The guys has been to 15 playoffs game out of 16 seasons in his entire career, with his rookie year being his only miss. The guy has also won 10 division titles. And oh, he also owns virtually every NFL passing record and played in three Super bowls.

That's enough to explain why OP should return to adult school and learn how to do some research. Before babbling his mouth away, and making a fool of his bandwagon Seahawks fan homer self.