Well hell then I'm going with my 4 and give me Alex Smith. He's by know means a great starter but KC just does not have the weapons and that "offensive genius" Reid wouldn't know what to do if he had the weapons. Come to think bout it tho Seattle pretty much has the consummate gm manager starting for them now already. He's certainly no A-Rodg,Brady, Peyton, or Brees anyhow.
-
Comment -
The bears are the obvious answer. They are probably better with their backup.Comment -
Good point about KC, their D has wilted against decent QBs. Maybe my original point about NE's D still has weight?Originally posted by R.P. McMurphy
Brady won his first after starting most of the season. Bledsoe was the "reliever" in the AFCC.
If we go back to the 2000 Ravens, Dilfer didn't start until mid season after Tony Banks went down.
But we have to go back to 1990 to see Hos take over for Simms week 15 and take them the rest of the way.
Before that, go back to 1987 Redskins and Doug Williams taking over for Schroeder week 17 and going all the way.
Originally posted by R.P. McMurphy
Yeah, it's a very academic exercise. I guess it's a hot topic because Romo and Rodgers went down, who's next?
Someone mentioned Foles, but he's kinda like Dilfer who started over half the year, that's not really a true backup.Comment -
does reemer ever win?Comment -
Flynns not done bad,that Defense hasnt done him alot of favours.Comment -
If Manning went down,Denver would be completley helpless.Comment -
i agree. Seattle are San Fran have the 2 most complete teams. Although Kaep and Wilson are goodOriginally posted by BennyBigNuts
they are no where near the caliber of a Tom Brady, Peyton Manning or Cam Newton...Comment -
Chase Daniel is going to win a game as a starter ? Really ?Originally posted by KermitComment -
Interesting, Anderson is a QB that can compete and Newton is not that great.Originally posted by rm18Comment -
Tavaris Jackson is absolute GARBAGE !!!!Originally posted by BennyBigNutsComment -
Orton is the best back up he might be better than Romo but Dallas can't win a playoff game with that Defense EVER with any QB.Originally posted by Big BearComment -
Eagles could win with Vick but Foles is worlds better.Comment -
He's a .500 backup, about the same as Orton and everyone else in this discussion.Originally posted by EmpireMakerComment -
This has to be the winner. If Foles goes down in any game, Eagles fans gotta feel ok with Vick coming in off the bench.Originally posted by EmpireMakerComment -
I'm not a big Josh Johnson fan but he is better than some back upsOriginally posted by brooks85Comment -
guys not very good and is working with about an 80 IQOriginally posted by slacker00Comment -
you would be going from a great game manager to a really bad oneOriginally posted by slacker00Comment -
How about Colt McCoy with the 49ers, it could workComment -
Seattle is a complete team but Jackson would fukk it up somehowComment -
Car
Philly
SF
NE
Sea
Cin
I guess this is my orderComment -
You might be right about his IQ. Tarvaris Jackson's wonderlic score was 19, but Derek Anderson also scored 19.Originally posted by EmpireMakerComment -
that surprises meOriginally posted by slacker00Comment -
I see old Tavaris make a lot of bad decisionsComment -
Far as Vick goes I disagree. No way I want to put that much trust into a low I.q. wildcard like Vick who is going to go off the script too much and probably give the other teams QB (who I'm gonna assume is a Rodgers, Brady, Manning since we are in a SB ) 3/4 extra possessions off bonehead turnovers. Just give me the safe smart guy who is gonna stick to the gameplan while not trying to do too much In this spot and let the cast around him mainly the defense dictate the pace and flow.Comment -
19 isn't a good score. A perfect score is 50, most NFL QBs are in the high 20's & 30's.Originally posted by EmpireMakerComment -
Marino got like 16 and he got the ball out faster than anyone, Jackson is a bad player though.Comment -
Terry Bradshaw and Jim Kelly scored the same and are in the NFL HOF. Jeff George scored a 10, lol. QB IQ is overrated.Originally posted by rm18Comment -
Bradshaw is a dopeComment -
A dope with 4 rings.Originally posted by Chi_archieComment -
Lol no doubt Bradshaw was dumb as a stump I believe someone said once he could not spell cat if you spotted him the c and the t hahahah. That was a little different era though and Terry was never asked to do too much there is no way he could lead in today's nfl and do the job of a Peyton or Brady. It's about leadership and accountability too and making your guys BELIEVE more than anything. Look at Rgme he is a prime example of a smart guy that just does not get it. Still though end of the day I want a guy under center that possesses leadership and has something working between the ears.Comment -
Then you have a guy like Tebow who inspires and a born leader pretty much opposite of Rgme. However he obviously lacks the skills required at the pro level and to me comes across dumb as a stump as well. He may be well versed in the bible but the way he stutters and mumbles thru interviews is sad. He certainly does not seem like a guy that is well spoken or well versed in other areas of life. I've heard some mention he should go into broadcasting....god help us all lol!Comment -
Tebow scored 22 on the wonderlic, still way below the NFL average for active Super Bowl winning QBs: 30.7.
I like Tebow and wish he'd find a way back into the NFL. I see nothing wrong with expressing one's personal beliefs, ESPECIALLY since it seems so politically incorrect to do so. In some ways Jesus' message is anti-establishment and anti-authority, but instead finding authority in a personal savior which ultimately can only be witnessed personally. I'd like to see more Tim Tebow religious types in the NFL, hopefully with more intelligence, questioning the authority everywhere and perhaps even within the scripture itself. In a sport that's meant to distract us, I'd like to see more voices offering an alternative message to the consumerist tripe between timeouts.Comment -
i wonder how some of you are smart enough to remember how to breathe...Comment -
Speaking of Terry Bradshaw and low bible IQ, that duck dynasty anti-gay dude was starting QB ahead of TB at LT.
Comment
