Fukk Off...Peyton Manning Is NOT The NFL Comeback Player Of The Year

Andy117 · 12-23-12, 06:20 PM

AP should get MVP.
Peyton gets comeback. He actually missed a whole season. AP didn't miss anything, doesn't fit my definition of comeback.

DJ Dalamar · 12-23-12, 06:22 PM

Peyton plays bad teams every week and they still suck him off.

jeffdane · 12-23-12, 06:24 PM

jamal charles had a decent comeback

mikefromsd · 12-23-12, 06:24 PM

Originally posted by DJ Dalamar

Peyton plays bad teams every week and they still suck him off.

Peyton has something to do with them being bad teams.

nvrlose37 · 12-23-12, 06:24 PM

Originally posted by Andy117

AP should get MVP.
Peyton gets comeback. He actually missed a whole season. AP didn't miss anything, doesn't fit my definition of comeback.

This times 20. Perfect definitions

DJ Dalamar · 12-23-12, 06:27 PM

Originally posted by mikefromsd

Peyton has something to do with them being bad teams.

Only 2 they have beaten that will be playoff teams are Balt and Cincy, and they are barley making it in.

mikefromsd · 12-23-12, 06:28 PM

Originally posted by DJ Dalamar

Only 2 they have beaten that will be playoff teams are Balt and Cincy, and they are barley making it in.

You missed my point.

JMon · 12-23-12, 06:30 PM

Peyton plays bad teams every week and they still suck him off.

Aside the NYG, the Broncos had the hardest schedule coming into the season. Look it up.

that belongs to Adrian Peterson besides the MVP too.

TOTALLY agree!

PhillyFlyers · 12-23-12, 06:39 PM

Originally posted by Andy117

AP should get MVP.
Peyton gets comeback. He actually missed a whole season. AP didn't miss anything, doesn't fit my definition of comeback.

Adrian could barely function this time last year. Knee torn to shreds. Comes back one year later and may set the single season rushing record. That doesn't qualify as comeback?

Especially if you concede that he is the most valuable player this season.

Mikeyanks23 · 12-23-12, 06:47 PM

Originally posted by PhillyFlyers

Adrian could barely function this time last year. Knee torn to shreds. Comes back one year later and may set the single season rushing record. That doesn't qualify as comeback?

Especially if you concede that he is the most valuable player this season.

dude he missed one game i think. Didnt he get hurt this weekend last yr?

Manning missed the whole season.

You may be the dumbest poster on this site.

You prove it with every thread you make

PhillyFlyers · 12-23-12, 06:50 PM

Originally posted by Mikeyanks23

dude he missed one game i think. Didnt he get hurt this weekend last yr?

Manning missed the whole season.

You may be the dumbest poster on this site.

You prove it with every thread you make

Fukk you and suck a dikk.

Did AP sustain a severe injury? Yes.

Did he come back from that injury? Yes.

Has he performed at a superlative level after sustaining said injury? Yes.

Is he the most valuable player right now? Yes.

Does he qualify for comeback player of the year? Yes.

GamblerSpirit · 12-23-12, 06:52 PM

AP all day MVP and comeback player of the year! Fukk yes!!

InTheDrink · 12-23-12, 07:05 PM

Originally posted by Mikeyanks23

dude he missed one game i think. Didnt he get hurt this weekend last yr?

Manning missed the whole season.

You may be the dumbest poster on this site.

You prove it with every thread you make

Lightbulb

JMon · 12-23-12, 07:05 PM

Originally posted by Mikeyanks23

dude he missed one game i think. Didnt he get hurt this weekend last yr?

Manning missed the whole season.

You may be the dumbest poster on this site.

You prove it with every thread you make

rip up your knee (that's ended many RB's career) and rush for 2000 yards the following year. Manning had a year+ to heal. However, I do see your point...def MVP.

DJ Dalamar · 12-23-12, 07:07 PM

Originally posted by JMon

Aside the NYG, the Broncos had the hardest schedule coming into the season. Look it up.

TOTALLY agree!

I don't care what ESPN says they played 3 good teams this year and lost to all 3. The best team they beat was Balt in the middle of the wheels coming off of their season. OAK,SD, KC twice a year is not a tough schedule.

Walulu · 12-23-12, 07:16 PM

Good teams beat bad teams. Exactly what they are supposed to do. If you don't you lose the moniker good and are average. That being said you can argue Manning for both. Denver is not the same team without him. The same can be said for AP.

lakerboy · 12-23-12, 07:23 PM

So wait the pats beat up on shit teams all year but no one says brady beats up on them.

pats wins this year

jags/dolphins/bills(2)/colts/jets(2)/tenny/denv/stl/houst

lost to zona/balty/sf and sea.

so brady beat 3 playoff teams all year.

MUHerd37 · 12-23-12, 07:29 PM

Lots of people tear up their knee and come back and play at a high level. Fukking up ur kneck/spine is career ending shit. Manning should get comeback player of the year. MVP is a tossup.

19th Hole · 12-23-12, 07:42 PM

Originally posted by InTheDrink

Lightbulb

Originally posted by Mikeyanks23

dude he missed one game i think. Didnt he get hurt this weekend last yr?

Manning missed the whole season.

You may be the dumbest poster on this site.

You prove it with every thread you make

Originally posted by mikefromsd

You missed my point.

Originally posted by nvrlose37

This times 20. Perfect definitions

Originally posted by mikefromsd

Peyton has something to do with them being bad teams.

Originally posted by Andy117

AP should get MVP.
Peyton gets comeback. He actually missed a whole season. AP didn't miss anything, doesn't fit my definition of comeback.

InTheDrink · 12-23-12, 07:52 PM

I like the third hole best but 19th hole is good people

Lakers Dynasty · 12-23-12, 08:03 PM

Tough call, but I will take AP. Every team stacks eight guys in the box & he still gets the job done.

face · 12-23-12, 08:06 PM

i don't know man, peyton putting up some crazy numbers. broncos hardly ever kick field goals, all TDs by manning. covered -14 spread today with ease

frostno98 · 12-23-12, 08:14 PM

AP will not beat packers and the vikings will miss the playoffs. Lol, that a MVP for ya.

You mad bro · 12-23-12, 08:17 PM

Guy has 4 neck surgeries and a pinched nerve which could have cost him not to play ever again .. Ap comes back from a torn acl late last season

They should just split it

iQon · 12-23-12, 08:19 PM

Clueless keyboard warriors on SBR. What else is new?

AP's numbers this season are unheard of. The first season back from an ACL injury with RB's are historically a wash. Most never return to form at all.

AP's flirting with 2,000 yards.

I could careless who gets the award, but some of you morons have no business evaluating either player's accomplishments.

stevenash · 12-23-12, 08:34 PM

OK, here we go again.
The operative word in MVP is 'valuable'

Would the Vikings be knocking on the door of a playoff game without AP? Hell no. With Christian under center yet!
Would Denver be 12 and 3 without Peyton? No. But they would probably be going to the playoffs with a lesser QB anyway, but they would probably wouldn't be 12-3.

AP is without a doubt the most valuable player this season, oh, one more thing, he's on the cusp of breaking the single season rushing record.

Comeback player I'd give a slight nod to Peyton, he came back from nothing last season, hell, one might say he came back from the grave.

d2bets · 12-23-12, 08:40 PM

Technically they both qualify for "comeback", but I think Peyton's is more of a comeback given that he missed a whole season, switched teams and many thought he'd never play again. Certainly Peterson recovered quickly from injury, but he was so good before he went down. It's just not really a "comeback" as I'd consider it just because he healed faster than expected.

Andy117 · 12-23-12, 08:52 PM

Originally posted by PhillyFlyers

Adrian could barely function this time last year. Knee torn to shreds. Comes back one year later and may set the single season rushing record. That doesn't qualify as comeback?

Especially if you concede that he is the most valuable player this season.

Different injuries. The ACL didn't happen until the year. Guys comeback from torn ACLs and while it is very impressive it's not exactly rare. To be a comeback player of the year should at least miss a decent portion of the season to be in the running. No one really thought AP was done for his career, there were plenty of people who thought Manning would never play again.

stefan084 · 12-23-12, 09:01 PM

Originally posted by PhillyFlyers

Fukk you and suck a dikk.

Did AP sustain a severe injury? Yes.

Did he come back from that injury? Yes.

Has he performed at a superlative level after sustaining said injury? Yes.

Is he the most valuable player right now? Yes.

Does he qualify for comeback player of the year? Yes.

yeah peyton only had like 4 neck surgeries fusing his vertebrae together

DJ Dalamar · 12-23-12, 09:42 PM

Originally posted by frostno98

AP will not beat packers and the vikings will miss the playoffs. Lol, that a MVP for ya.

Vikes already made Playoffs homer.

PhillyFlyers · 12-23-12, 09:52 PM

Originally posted by Andy117

Different injuries. The ACL didn't happen until the year. Guys comeback from torn ACLs and while it is very impressive it's not exactly rare. To be a comeback player of the year should at least miss a decent portion of the season to be in the running. No one really thought AP was done for his career, there were plenty of people who thought Manning would never play again.

Guys come back from ACLs? Do they play at a higher level than they did before they sustained the injury like AP has?

What do you mean no one really thought AP was done for his career?

Vikings bracing for very bad news on Peterson

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/12/24/vikings-bracing-for-very-bad-news-on-peterson/

When the left knee of Vikings running back Adrian Peterson caved inward during a third-quarter tackle against the Redskins, it looked bad.

Minnesota Vikings: Breaking News, Rumors & Highlights | Yardbarker

http://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/adrian_peterson_tears_his_acl_nfl_career_could_be_in_jeopardy/8938105

Minnesota Vikings rumors, news and videos from the best sources on the web. Sign up for the Vikings newsletter!

Ambition · 12-23-12, 09:58 PM

Originally posted by frostno98

AP will not beat packers and the vikings will miss the playoffs. Lol, that a MVP for ya.

A player who is going to rush for over 2,000 yards with 10+ TD's in a season on a team where he is the only player and having defense stack 8 players in the box and still averaging over 5 yards per carry with a quarterback who is terrible. Also has a chance at breaking the single season rushing record after tearing his ACL last year. Lol, yeah that's an MVP.

Who do you think is MVP Homer? Peyton Manning? Brady deserves it more than Manning does this year.

Also Manning isn't that valuable to Denver if Denver made the playoffs and won a playoff game with Tebow as their quarterback last year. Denver is an all around good team.

Full Time Hobo · 12-23-12, 09:58 PM

Originally posted by stevenash

OK, here we go again.
The operative word in MVP is 'valuable'

Would the Vikings be knocking on the door of a playoff game without AP? Hell no. With Christian under center yet!
Would Denver be 12 and 3 without Peyton? No. But they would probably be going to the playoffs with a lesser QB anyway, but they would probably wouldn't be 12-3.

AP is without a doubt the most valuable player this season, oh, one more thing, he's on the cusp of breaking the single season rushing record.

Comeback player I'd give a slight nod to Peyton, he came back from nothing last season, hell, one might say he came back from the grave.

This....

And people don't realize that there have been many players in the NFL to come back from the SAME surgeries that Peyton has gone through... and they are not all QBs either...

Regardless, in the end MVP and Comeback Player will be split between these 2.

DJ Dalamar · 12-23-12, 10:08 PM

Originally posted by JMon

Aside the NYG, the Broncos had the hardest schedule coming into the season. Look it up.

TOTALLY agree!

Going back to this I just looked up Jags schedule this year they played a playoff team 9 out of the 16. Denver played 5 and lost to 3 of them. This tough schedule thing is just BS perpetrated by ESPN that doesn't hold up to anyone that actually examines it.

Thats just one radom team I looked up cause they are in last place. I bet many more have much tougher schedule then Denver.