what do you guys think of Dan Hanners NCAAB projections compared to KenPom?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • zoo youk
    SBR Posting Legend
    • 10-23-11
    • 10701

    #1
    what do you guys think of Dan Hanners NCAAB projections compared to KenPom?
    apparently this Hanner is supposed to be all the new rave. hard to compete with Pomeroy though.

  • TPowell
    SBR Posting Legend
    • 02-21-08
    • 18842

    #2
    this is awful. Missouri and Tenny are fringe top 25 teams at best. Kentucky is way overrated. Miami is WAY too low, as well as Michigan. VCU is way too low.
    Comment
    • Emily_Haines
      SBR Posting Legend
      • 04-14-09
      • 15917

      #3
      Kenpom says that the teams don't very much year to year.

      Yesterday, RealGM’s Dan Hanner released his brand new, thoroughly impressive preseason projection system, one that uses a variety of historical data inputs to predict future performance for all 345 Division I teams.


      The logic goes like this: If you could have one thing to predict a team’s offense, what would it be? It turns out last season’s offensive efficiency would be that thing. It does a good job of predicting offense the following season. After that, the previous season’s offensive efficiency is the next best predictor, and after that, last season’s defensive efficiency helps a bit. (Flip the script for the defensive predictors.) Those three things are the foundation of the system.

      I'm just not a big believer in these model guys. Kenpom data alone does not win against the Vegas lines and neither will the Hanner data. No doubt for the handicapper that the numbers are a helpful handicapping tool but on their own they do not win.

      Honestly I don't see much difference in the two. Looks like the same offense efficiency, defense efficiency type dat that you get with kenpom.
      Comment
      • Emily_Haines
        SBR Posting Legend
        • 04-14-09
        • 15917

        #4
        Originally posted by TPowell
        this is awful. Missouri and Tenny are fringe top 25 teams at best. Kentucky is way overrated. Miami is WAY too low, as well as Michigan. VCU is way too low.
        It just all depends what people think. I think even though Missouri lost four starters the people they have coming in with the addition of Bowers this year who sat out last year put them well in the top 20.

        That's part of the problem with these early season numbers. No one really knows and we all are just guessing.
        Comment
        • TPowell
          SBR Posting Legend
          • 02-21-08
          • 18842

          #5
          Stanford above Cal is awful. South Florida is drastically underrated, as well as St Johns.
          Comment
          • TPowell
            SBR Posting Legend
            • 02-21-08
            • 18842

            #6
            Originally posted by Emily_Haines
            It just all depends what people think. I think even though Missouri lost four starters the people they have coming in with the addition of Bowers this year who sat out last year put them well in the top 20.

            That's part of the problem with these early season numbers. No one really knows and we all are just guessing.

            They return 3 guys from their team last year and don't bring in THAT MUCH. Unreal how overrated they are
            Comment
            • Emily_Haines
              SBR Posting Legend
              • 04-14-09
              • 15917

              #7
              They add the best player from Pepperdine Keion Bell
              They add Alex Oriakhi from UConn
              and they get
              Laurence Bowers after sitting out last year

              They lost some good offensive players Marcus Denmon and Kim English, but they added three players two of which are outstanding players on defense. I don't see how anyone can think this team will not be very good.
              Comment
              • TPowell
                SBR Posting Legend
                • 02-21-08
                • 18842

                #8
                Originally posted by Emily_Haines
                They add the best player from Pepperdine Keion Bell
                They add Alex Oriakhi from UConn
                and they get
                Laurence Bowers after sitting out last year

                They lost some good offensive players Marcus Denmon and Kim English, but they added three players two of which are outstanding players on defense. I don't see how anyone can think this team will not be very good.

                did you watch Oriakhi play? The guy isn't the same player from 2 years ago. They also lost Ratcliffe and the other Pressley kid. They return TWO guys that played last year... get 1 guy back from injury, add a couple good transfers and people think they'll be as good as they were last year?
                Comment
                • ChalkyDog
                  SBR Hall of Famer
                  • 10-02-11
                  • 9598

                  #9
                  Extraordinarily useful.

                  To get multiple takes on the same thing is essential.

                  Hanner seems to know what he is doing. I think Ken Pom is still and will remain the authority on NCAA basketball, but that doesn't mean there isn't room for improvement or at the very least differing opinions.
                  Comment
                  • ChalkyDog
                    SBR Hall of Famer
                    • 10-02-11
                    • 9598

                    #10
                    Originally posted by TPowell
                    Stanford above Cal is awful. South Florida is drastically underrated, as well as St Johns.
                    Stanford will be decent this year - they have some good players. Cal is a big question mark - but their coach is insanely better than Stanfords.
                    Comment
                    • TPowell
                      SBR Posting Legend
                      • 02-21-08
                      • 18842

                      #11
                      Originally posted by ChalkyDog
                      Stanford will be decent this year - they have some good players. Cal is a big question mark - but their coach is insanely better than Stanfords.
                      They lost Kamp and Guthirez (sp) but they still have Crabbe and Cobbs back. I think Solomon will be a big time player for them this year too
                      Comment
                      • TPowell
                        SBR Posting Legend
                        • 02-21-08
                        • 18842

                        #12
                        Originally posted by ChalkyDog
                        Stanford will be decent this year - they have some good players. Cal is a big question mark - but their coach is insanely better than Stanfords.
                        Stanford has a stud in Randle and return a couple more key guys, but a freshman that averaged 14 points a game should be expected to go nuts. They also have a couple freshman who could make the team pretty good, but I'd rather take my chances with a well coached team with a lot of talent coming back
                        Comment
                        • ChalkyDog
                          SBR Hall of Famer
                          • 10-02-11
                          • 9598

                          #13
                          Originally posted by TPowell
                          They lost Kamp and Guthirez (sp) but they still have Crabbe and Cobbs back. I think Solomon will be a big time player for them this year too
                          Crabb could run away with the PAC-POY award. Huge fan of his game.

                          The conference is Arizona and UCLA, and everyone else playing for 3rd.
                          Comment
                          • TPowell
                            SBR Posting Legend
                            • 02-21-08
                            • 18842

                            #14
                            Originally posted by ChalkyDog
                            Crabb could run away with the PAC-POY award. Huge fan of his game.

                            The conference is Arizona and UCLA, and everyone else playing for 3rd.
                            I disagree. I have Cal and UCLA at the top of the conference with Stanford about a point back and Zona a point back of Stanford
                            Comment
                            • zoo youk
                              SBR Posting Legend
                              • 10-23-11
                              • 10701

                              #15
                              the ncaa denied the kid wells from xavier to play this year, has to sit. thats huge asarizona would have got aroumd 15 ppg from him
                              Comment
                              • zoo youk
                                SBR Posting Legend
                                • 10-23-11
                                • 10701

                                #16
                                Originally posted by Emily_Haines
                                They add the best player from Pepperdine Keion Bell
                                They add Alex Oriakhi from UConn
                                and they get
                                Laurence Bowers after sitting out last year

                                They lost some good offensive players Marcus Denmon and Kim English, but they added three players two of which are outstanding players on defense. I don't see how anyone can think this team will not be very good.
                                keion bell is disgustingly good. glad hes gonna get recognized finally
                                Comment
                                • ChalkyDog
                                  SBR Hall of Famer
                                  • 10-02-11
                                  • 9598

                                  #17
                                  Originally posted by zoo youk
                                  the ncaa denied the kid wells from xavier to play this year, has to sit. thats huge asarizona would have got aroumd 15 ppg from him
                                  Arizona?

                                  Lyons is fully cleared to play, is starting at point guard. Just saw the guy tear it up in the Arizona version of midnight-madness.

                                  Maybe it's another kid?
                                  Comment
                                  • ChalkyDog
                                    SBR Hall of Famer
                                    • 10-02-11
                                    • 9598

                                    #18
                                    Originally posted by TPowell
                                    I disagree. I have Cal and UCLA at the top of the conference with Stanford about a point back and Zona a point back of Stanford
                                    Cal and Stanford are going to have trouble finishing ahead of Colorado - who is the only other team even in the possible discussion.

                                    UCLA has their best player having extreme issues getting cleared to play. On top of that, who I think to be their best player, their 6'8" "Point Guard" is also not cleared.

                                    Arizona has the biggest front court in the conference. (assuming height - Josh Smith of UCLA is obviously the fattest). All of them are top 10 recruits, and the sophomore is a top 50 recruit that has the California records for career/game blocks and something else - he's most likely coming off the bench. That doesn't even touch on Arizona's best players in Seniors Solomon Hill and Kevin Parrom.

                                    If UCLA doesn't get their guys cleared, especially Shabazz - they're gonna be lucky to get a decent seed in the NIT.
                                    Comment
                                    • TPowell
                                      SBR Posting Legend
                                      • 02-21-08
                                      • 18842

                                      #19
                                      Originally posted by ChalkyDog
                                      Cal and Stanford are going to have trouble finishing ahead of Colorado - who is the only other team even in the possible discussion.

                                      UCLA has their best player having extreme issues getting cleared to play. On top of that, who I think to be their best player, their 6'8" "Point Guard" is also not cleared.

                                      Arizona has the biggest front court in the conference. (assuming height - Josh Smith of UCLA is obviously the fattest). All of them are top 10 recruits, and the sophomore is a top 50 recruit that has the California records for career/game blocks and something else - he's most likely coming off the bench. That doesn't even touch on Arizona's best players in Seniors Solomon Hill and Kevin Parrom.

                                      If UCLA doesn't get their guys cleared, especially Shabazz - they're gonna be lucky to get a decent seed in the NIT.

                                      obviously I'm including UCLA with everybody healthy and eligible. As far as Arizona, I'm not betting on a bunch of freshman (none in the top 10 in their class) beating a well coached veteran team. The Parrom kid isn't a star player by any stretch. Arizona has Hill and the Johnson kid that are very good players and the transfer in Lyons but who knows what the young bigs are going to do and 2 of the 3 are going to have to start. With Colorado, I don't see what you see. They only return 2 starters and 1 more key reserve from a team that overachieved last year
                                      Comment
                                      • CollegeOverUnder
                                        SBR Hall of Famer
                                        • 10-20-10
                                        • 5520

                                        #20
                                        How are you guys not talking about Colorado in any of this I barely read this thread I just see PAC12 being talked about, but Colorado should be in this discussion
                                        Comment
                                        • TPowell
                                          SBR Posting Legend
                                          • 02-21-08
                                          • 18842

                                          #21
                                          Originally posted by CollegeOverUnder
                                          How are you guys not talking about Colorado in any of this I barely read this thread I just see PAC12 being talked about, but Colorado should be in this discussion
                                          I don't get the hype. 2 starters back and 1 role player from last year and they are supposed to be better this year?
                                          Comment
                                          • CollegeOverUnder
                                            SBR Hall of Famer
                                            • 10-20-10
                                            • 5520

                                            #22
                                            PAC12

                                            #1 Arizona
                                            #2 UCLA
                                            #3 Standford
                                            #4 Colorado
                                            #5 USC
                                            #6 California
                                            #7 Oregon
                                            #8 UTAH
                                            #9 Washington
                                            #10 Washington St
                                            #11Oregon St
                                            #12 Arizona St

                                            those are really sketchy on my part though
                                            Comment
                                            • CollegeOverUnder
                                              SBR Hall of Famer
                                              • 10-20-10
                                              • 5520

                                              #23
                                              Originally posted by TPowell
                                              I don't get the hype. 2 starters back and 1 role player from last year and they are supposed to be better this year?
                                              dramatically, keep digging man CU was one of the teams I actually did my research on this summer. I no you know your college hoops bud its there though.
                                              Comment
                                              • TPowell
                                                SBR Posting Legend
                                                • 02-21-08
                                                • 18842

                                                #24
                                                Originally posted by CollegeOverUnder
                                                PAC12

                                                #1 Arizona
                                                #2 UCLA
                                                #3 Standford
                                                #4 Colorado
                                                #5 USC
                                                #6 California
                                                #7 Oregon
                                                #8 UTAH
                                                #9 Washington
                                                #10 Washington St
                                                #11Oregon St
                                                #12 Arizona St

                                                those are really sketchy on my part though

                                                1. Cal
                                                1. UCLA
                                                3. Arizona
                                                4. Stanford
                                                5. Oregon State
                                                6. Washington
                                                7. Washington State
                                                8. Colorado
                                                9. Oregon
                                                10. USC
                                                11. Arizona State
                                                12. Utah
                                                Comment
                                                • CollegeOverUnder
                                                  SBR Hall of Famer
                                                  • 10-20-10
                                                  • 5520

                                                  #25
                                                  Originally posted by zoo youk
                                                  apparently this Hanner is supposed to be all the new rave. hard to compete with Pomeroy though.

                                                  http://www.basketballprospectus.com/...articleid=2426
                                                  ok now im interested because this guys rankings are off the wall. This im gonna actually have to sit down and organize his numbers because I cant believe im saying this but Louisville is not the #10 team lmao. I dont even like VILLE and I can tell this is already skewed as fuk. Ville is top 4 no matter what.

                                                  Eh I can respect Kansas at #4 I suppose if you pushed around a lot of numbers I can see that happening

                                                  Im a Duke fan but nope not #7

                                                  Tennesee and Pittsburgh are ranked

                                                  Minnesota? I mean I guess if you tried really really hard to rank them they could get in there
                                                  Comment
                                                  • TPowell
                                                    SBR Posting Legend
                                                    • 02-21-08
                                                    • 18842

                                                    #26
                                                    Originally posted by CollegeOverUnder
                                                    dramatically, keep digging man CU was one of the teams I actually did my research on this summer. I no you know your college hoops bud its there though.

                                                    I see they have a couple top 100 prospects which I somehow missed but they lost their starting PG from last year and the kid replacing him this year is only a sophomore which i don't like. I'm gonna say marginally better than last year at best but more than likely slightly worse
                                                    Comment
                                                    • TPowell
                                                      SBR Posting Legend
                                                      • 02-21-08
                                                      • 18842

                                                      #27
                                                      Originally posted by CollegeOverUnder
                                                      ok now im interested because this guys rankings are off the wall. This im gonna actually have to sit down and organize his numbers because I cant believe im saying this but Louisville is not the #10 team lmao. I dont even like VILLE and I can tell this is already skewed as fuk. Ville is top 4 no matter what.

                                                      Eh I can respect Kansas at #4 I suppose if you pushed around a lot of numbers I can see that happening

                                                      Im a Duke fan but nope not #7

                                                      Tennesee and Pittsburgh are ranked

                                                      Minnesota? I mean I guess if you tried really really hard to rank them they could get in there

                                                      Minnesota is going to be solid with Mbakwe back. He is a potential first team All American IMO. I have them around a point better than Pitt and a couple better than Tenny
                                                      Comment
                                                      • TPowell
                                                        SBR Posting Legend
                                                        • 02-21-08
                                                        • 18842

                                                        #28
                                                        our big differences seem to be USC and Oregon State. I think USC will be dramatically better than last year obviously, but I can't quantify that in my power ratings. They have the biggest upgrade from last year than any team I've done and maybe I've sold them short but hard to upgrade a team 10+ points. Oregon State should be better this year, as they return everybody except Robinson, their star last year. Robinson has been a good coach as well
                                                        Comment
                                                        • ChalkyDog
                                                          SBR Hall of Famer
                                                          • 10-02-11
                                                          • 9598

                                                          #29
                                                          Originally posted by CollegeOverUnder
                                                          How are you guys not talking about Colorado in any of this I barely read this thread I just see PAC12 being talked about, but Colorado should be in this discussion
                                                          My earlier post stated I felt CU is the only other team in the discussion, alongside UCLA and 'Zona.

                                                          Cal and Stanford I feel, at this point, are not better than Colorado going forward.

                                                          UCLA
                                                          ZONA
                                                          CU

                                                          In any order... if only you could put that in a trifecta box.

                                                          Originally posted by TPowell
                                                          our big differences seem to be USC and Oregon State. I think USC will be dramatically better than last year obviously, but I can't quantify that in my power ratings. They have the biggest upgrade from last year than any team I've done and maybe I've sold them short but hard to upgrade a team 10+ points. Oregon State should be better this year, as they return everybody except Robinson, their star last year. Robinson has been a good coach as well
                                                          USC will be much improved this year. Assuming Kevin O'Neil doesn't kill his players (literally) prior to conference play. I agree with that 100%. USC much improved is still middle of the Road in the PAC.

                                                          if I were to guess right now.

                                                          1/2 Arizona/UCLA
                                                          3 Colorado
                                                          4/5. Stanford/Cal
                                                          6. USC
                                                          7. Oregon
                                                          8. Washington
                                                          9. Oregon St.
                                                          10. Washington St.
                                                          11/12. Utah/ASU
                                                          Comment
                                                          • zoo youk
                                                            SBR Posting Legend
                                                            • 10-23-11
                                                            • 10701

                                                            #30
                                                            Originally posted by ChalkyDog
                                                            Arizona?

                                                            Lyons is fully cleared to play, is starting at point guard. Just saw the guy tear it up in the Arizona version of midnight-madness.

                                                            Maybe it's another kid?
                                                            shit yea. i was thinking about Dez Wells to Maryland.
                                                            Comment
                                                            Search
                                                            Collapse
                                                            SBR Contests
                                                            Collapse
                                                            Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                                                            Collapse
                                                            Working...