D. Moore v B. Pettigrew

[infamousbacardi]

10 team dynasty league.

Need a WR as I've had Maclin go down and Stevie Johnson battling a hammy now.

I've been offered D. Moore for B. Pettigrew. Start 5 WRs and 2 TEs...my other TEs are Gronk, B. Myers, V. McDonald and Delanie Walker.

Is it worth giving up Pettigrew for D. Moore?

Should also note I have R. Streater already.

[infamousbacardi]

My other WRs are Hakeem Nicks, Stevie Johnson, Mike Wallace, Jeremy Maclin, James Jones, R. Streater, Ryan Broyles, Emmanuel Sanders and Rueben Randle

[BigSpoon]

I'd turn down that deal. Nicks, Johnson, Wallace, Jones and Sanders should be okay for your WR's for the season imo.

[infamousbacardi]

3 of my 5 in that post there though have struggled with injuries. Nicks always hurt. Johnson with his hammy now...Wallace has had issues to. Just getting a little thin there I feel.

[BigSpoon]

3 of my 5 in that post there though have struggled with injuries. Nicks always hurt. Johnson with his hammy now...Wallace has had issues to. Just getting a little thin there I feel.

I see your point but I'm not sure D. Moore is a huge upgrade over what you got. I don't see him improving on last year's numbers with Matt Flynn throwing him the ball.

Pettigrew is arguably a top 12 TE which has value when you have to start 2 TE's. Plus, Gronk is no sure bet to be healthy for the start of the season so you would be weakening your TE depth.

[onlooker]

Plus, Gronk is no sure bet to be healthy for the start of the season so you would be weakening your TE depth.

Gronk might start season on PUP list, and that means inactive for at least 6 games.

[Grits n' Gravy]

Gronk might start season on PUP list, and that means inactive for at least 6 games.

I've heard wk 3 is the plan but who knows with Bill.

As for original question, why would you willingly take a Raider? Their qb's all suck and Pettigrew is Stafford's 2nd favorite target.

[infamousbacardi]

Yeah it seems to make sense to keep Pettigrew I suppose. I think the real kicker is already having Streater. 2 raiders WRs?? Just can't do that really. I won this league 2 of the last 3 years. Maclin injury really sucks because he was in contract year to. Overall, no sense in doing anything too drastic I guess, I'm still ok at WR.

[onlooker]

Yeah it seems to make sense to keep Pettigrew I suppose. I think the real kicker is already having Streater. 2 raiders WRs?? Just can't do that really. I won this league 2 of the last 3 years. Maclin injury really sucks because he was in contract year to. Overall, no sense in doing anything too drastic I guess, I'm still ok at WR.

When did you draft?

Who runs the league. May I suggest not drafting so early? End of August/beginning of September is best.

[infamousbacardi]

When did you draft?

Who runs the league. May I suggest not drafting so early? End of August/beginning of September is best.

It's a dynasty league on MFL, $50 a year entry per team, 10 team league. You keep your entire 31 player roster every season. Our draft is usually a few weeks after the actual NFL draft, and we only draft 5 rounds which is just the new rookies who have entered the NFL.

[makaveli66]

Turn that deal down.

[oiler]

wouldn't take that deal at all

[Cross]

Not much of a deal.

[Straight Cash]

I would say that they are about even production wise, but that Pettigrew has more upside.

[infamousbacardi]

Thanks guys. I rejected the deal. I'll post any other offers here to.

[Wrigley]

I think you made the right decision