🏒 NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Predictions Tonight: Top Goal Scorer Picks for March 12

Cutter Gauthier leads our NHL anytime goal scorer predictions tonight for Thursday's 14-game slate.
 Anaheim Ducks left wing Cutter Gauthier - who's featured in my anytime goal scorer predictions - celebrates his goal.
Pictured: Anaheim Ducks left wing Cutter Gauthier - who's featured in my anytime goal scorer predictions - celebrates his goal. Photo by: Gary A. Vasquez-Imagn Images
Enjoying SBR content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

🎙️ SBR Intel: Anytime goal scorer predictions (March 12)

Cutter Gauthier (+140) is a goal-scoring machine and is taking on a Leafs team ranked bottom five in expected goals against, he's the easiest bet on the board for me. Elsewhere, Dylan Guenther (+140) takes on a Blackhawks team ranked 28th in expected goals against, while Quinn Hughes (+440) is providing tremendous value vs. the Flyers.


πŸ’ NHL anytime goal scorer predictions tonight: March 12

See all of our experts' NHL picks based on the latest NHL odds. Odds via FanDuel.

πŸ’° Anytime goal scorer βš–οΈ Units 🧠 Notes
Cutter Gauthier, Ducks (+140) 0.5u -> 1.20u A heater against one of the worst defensive teams in hockey? I'll take that.
Dylan Guenther, Mammoth (+140) 0.5u -> 1.20u Scored just three days ago against Blackhawks, who have no answer for him.
Quinn Hughes, Wild (+440) 0.2u -> 1.08u Flyers come in seventh in PIMs, Hughes providing huge value as QB of PP1.

Total wagered: 1.2 units | Max profit: 3.48 units

📃 Affiliate disclosure

Sportsbook Review may receive a commission if you sign up through our links. Not intended for use in MA. Bonuses not applicable in Ontario. 21+ only. (Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)


πŸ₯… Best anytime goal scorer pick tonight

Cutter Gauthier (+140) vs. Leafs

Gauthier is the hottest rookie in the NHL right now - it's an easy tail for one of the highest volume shooters in the league, too. He's coming off a nine-shot game vs. the Flames and a five-shot performance vs. the Canadiens. Against a Leafs team ranked dead-last in shots allowed per game, Gauthier will have plenty of looks. I'd price this closer to +120, so we're getting some value from FanDuel here.

  • Puck drop: 7 p.m. ET
  • Puck line: Ducks -1.5 (+200)
  • How to watch Ducks vs. Leafs: ESPN+, Sportsnet

🤑 More NHL player props

If you're looking for another plus-money player prop, look no further than Gauthier 5+ shots at +158. The Leafs couldn't be any worse in their own end since the Olympic break, and Gauthier will be buzzing tonight.


πŸ”₯ More NHL goal scorer picks

Dylan Guenther (+140) vs. Blackhawks

Guenther has been a volume shooter against the Blackhawks this season, firing eight shots on goal across three meetings while scoring against this team just a couple days ago. Chicago's defensive metrics haven't been anything to write home about, allowing 3.16 goals per game (22nd in the NHL). They'll be up against a hot power play in Utah, which has converted 35% of opportunities over their last eight games - Guenther is the trigger man on PP1. I'd price this play closer to +110 as a result.

  • Puck drop: 9 p.m. ET
  • Puck line: Mammoth -1.5 (+105)
  • How to watch Blackhawks vs. Mammoth: ESPN+, Sportsnet+

Quinn Hughes (+440) vs. Flyers

While Hughes isn't your typical goal-scorer, I'm seeing value at +440, so I'm taking advantage. Since the Olympic break, Hughes is firing three shots per game and is showing a willingess to get pucks to the net over distributing. He's taking on a Flyers penalty kill that has dropped to 78.2%, which is good for 21st in the NHL. With Philadelphia taking a ton of penalties this season, I'll the chance on Hughes to find the back of the net on the man advantage, but wouldn't bet this any shorter than +440.

  • Puck drop: 8 p.m. ET
  • Puck line: Wild -1.5 (+100)
  • How to watch Flyers vs. Wild: ESPN+, Sportsnet+

πŸš€ Best NHL goal scorer parlay

💵 NHL goal scorer parlay picks

  • Gauthier (+140)
  • Guenther (+140)
  • Hughes (+440)

Best odds: +3010 via FanDuel (0.2u -> 6.02u)


πŸ’΅ My betting record for NHL picks

All hockey picks have been tracked since March 5.

Bet type Record Net profit
Overall 5-7 +1.21 units βœ…
Player props (March) 3-4 +0.23 units βœ…

πŸ’‘ How I'm betting NHL goal scorer picks today

Follow all of our NHL analysis and expert predictions this season.

Bankroll management is a crucial element for a long-term, successful betting strategy.

The number of units I wagered reflects how confident I am in each player's chances of scoring. On a heavy slate, I'm not exposing more than half a unit from my bankroll. We're riding with a pair of hot hands and a value play tonight. However, while I like all three of these plays, it's important to remember that goal-scorer props can be difficult to predict, so it’s crucial to be strategic with your wager sizes. For the most part, I keep these under one unit unless the data suggests leaning more into my bankroll.