Will you accept a 5-4 SCOTUS decision on ObamaCare ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Turd Ferguson
    SBR Hall of Famer
    • 08-26-10
    • 7260

    #36
    Originally posted by itchypickle
    There is a reason why the media has already been spinning it for weeks as "an extreme, radical court"

    Yeah, who could possibly still think that Scalia is a partisan hack after his rant the other day...
    Comment
    • boondoggle
      SBR MVP
      • 09-29-10
      • 3014

      #37
      The sheep will never tire of being controlled by their corporate lackeys.
      Comment
      • NYSportsGuy210
        SBR Posting Legend
        • 11-07-09
        • 11347

        #38
        Any civilization that doesn't feel that it is imperative to care of it's peoples' health needs is a savage society to begin with. Wouldn't be surprised if ObamaCare gets dismantled entirely.....it's not like this nation is selfless or mature.
        Comment
        • ChalkyDog
          SBR Hall of Famer
          • 10-02-11
          • 9598

          #39
          Holy christ. Frogsrangers, are you for real with that 2nd Amendment crap?

          The movement to do away with it is about as big as the westboro baptist church. Both are being done by crazed lunatics.

          But hey, I will tell you what. You show me proof of one member on the court that is interested in overturning the 2nd Amendment, I will give you 100 points.

          Please do not point to the recent decision, because that is painfully retarded.

          Seriously, show me proof of a justice who has gone on record in an opinion or otherwise stating they wanted to OVERTURN the second amendment. 100 points.
          Comment
          • d2bets
            BARRELED IN @ SBR!
            • 08-10-05
            • 39995

            #40
            Went from 83% to 71.5% now at Intrade.
            Comment
            • Tully Mars 63
              SBR MVP
              • 08-06-11
              • 2750

              #41
              Does intrade have some record on SCOTUS rulings? I haven't been able to find one. I mean when they have trades showing one position, issue or candidate will probably win an election I can understand but the SCOTUS so often shocks even long time court scholars I find it hard to imagine how random people trading stocks/positions on a case could be all that accurate.
              Comment
              • frogsrangers
                Restricted User
                • 04-25-12
                • 5792

                #42
                Originally posted by ChalkyDog
                Holy christ. Frogsrangers, are you for real with that 2nd Amendment crap?

                The movement to do away with it is about as big as the westboro baptist church. Both are being done by crazed lunatics.

                But hey, I will tell you what. You show me proof of one member on the court that is interested in overturning the 2nd Amendment, I will give you 100 points.

                Please do not point to the recent decision, because that is painfully retarded.

                Seriously, show me proof of a justice who has gone on record in an opinion or otherwise stating they wanted to OVERTURN the second amendment. 100 points.




                Both 5-4 decisions in which 4 justices voted to basically nullify the individual's right to own a firearm

                With these two supports, the Breyer dissent goes on to conclude, "there simply is no untouchable constitutional right guaranteed by the Second Amendment to keep loaded handguns in the house in crime-ridden urban areas." It proposes that firearms laws be reviewed by balancing the interests (i.e., "'interest-balancing' approach") of Second Amendment protections against the government's compelling interest of preventing crime.
                Comment
                • Sam Odom
                  SBR Aristocracy
                  • 10-30-05
                  • 58063

                  #43
                  Originally posted by NYSportsGuy210

                  Wouldn't be surprised if ObamaCare gets dismantled entirely.....

                  what would you know , your shit is still green
                  Comment
                  • ChalkyDog
                    SBR Hall of Famer
                    • 10-02-11
                    • 9598

                    #44
                    Originally posted by frogsrangers
                    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DC_vs._Heller



                    Both 5-4 decisions in which 4 justices voted to basically nullify the individual's right to own a firearm
                    I believe you are reading those wrong. More specifically to my point, neither of those opinions has a Justice gone out and said they want to do away with/overturn the 2nd Amendment.

                    Had to deal with this in Con Law, and I remember this specifically. Those two cases are fantastic and are all about a individual's right to own, and more importantly does it extend to the states. Because I don't want to get into some convoluted con law discussion, my point remains. I would love to see someone point out a justice that has publicly stated they want to overturn the 2nd.

                    This was in respect to your statement, that the court was one crazy liberal away from doing away with the 2nd Amendment all together. I am not asking to show where all 4 state such a strong opinion, just one - anywhere.

                    Sure, there are hardcore liberals that occupy seats that are out on that ledge asking to do away with it, same as there are wingbats asking to do away with the 14th (probably the single most significant amendment).
                    Comment
                    • d2bets
                      BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                      • 08-10-05
                      • 39995

                      #45
                      Democrats are talking proposing Medicare for all program if ACA is struck down. Like I said Republicans - be careful what you wish for because you might get it. The mandate was a Republican idea. Republicans turned against it when Democrats started saying it sounded OK.
                      Comment
                      • Sam Odom
                        SBR Aristocracy
                        • 10-30-05
                        • 58063

                        #46
                        "be careful what you wish for because you might get it."


                        I hope so... I want the US Constitution to be followed. Dont you ??
                        Comment
                        • Tully Mars 63
                          SBR MVP
                          • 08-06-11
                          • 2750

                          #47
                          Originally posted by Sam Odom
                          "be careful what you wish for because you might get it."


                          I hope so... I want the US Constitution to be followed. Dont you ??
                          If it were clear as day there'd be no need for a SCOTUS.
                          Comment
                          • Sam Odom
                            SBR Aristocracy
                            • 10-30-05
                            • 58063

                            #48
                            Originally posted by Tully Mars 63

                            If it were clear as day there'd be no need for a SCOTUS.

                            Tomorrow it will be clearer to more people
                            Comment
                            • Tully Mars 63
                              SBR MVP
                              • 08-06-11
                              • 2750

                              #49
                              Originally posted by Sam Odom
                              Tomorrow it will be clearer to more people

                              It's completely possible the court could punt the main issue and basically say "no one's been force to buy anything yet" get back to us when that happens.

                              Would that make you happy?
                              Comment
                              • Sam Odom
                                SBR Aristocracy
                                • 10-30-05
                                • 58063

                                #50
                                Originally posted by Tully Mars 63

                                It's completely possible the court could punt the main issue and basically say "no one's been force to buy anything yet" get back to us when that happens.

                                Would that make you happy?

                                Might be the right thing to do. Usually there has to be an aggrieved party

                                some say there is already an aggrieved party in lawyer speak
                                Comment
                                • Tully Mars 63
                                  SBR MVP
                                  • 08-06-11
                                  • 2750

                                  #51
                                  Originally posted by Sam Odom
                                  Might be the right thing to do. Usually there has to be an aggrieved party

                                  some say there is already an aggrieved party in lawyer speak
                                  I have no insight in what they might do but I am expecting the unexpected.

                                  I also think both sides are reading the possible out comes incorrectly. Both sides seem to think if the court sides with them it's a no brainer win. I disagree. It's and election year... losing might actually help your party more. The get out the vote on the right would go through the roof if the mandate is up held. If the mandate goes down the left will rally. The same thing just sort of happened with Az Im. ruling, the Dems won 3 of 4 of it but lost the biggy. Money started pouring in to the Az Dem party the next day and Dem voter reg. ticked up as well.

                                  The health care issue effects far more people then immigration.
                                  Comment
                                  • andywend
                                    SBR MVP
                                    • 05-20-07
                                    • 4805

                                    #52
                                    Originally posted by jw
                                    That is not actually totally accurate .. the polls that the Republicans keep shouting and screaming about also show a portion of people "against Obamacare" who .. like me .. would like to scrap the bill .. and then pass an even stronger version of the bill which gives us a 100% government controlled healthcare option.

                                    So while the Republicans may shout and scream that most are against .. in fact .. more people would rather have the bill as it stands right now .. than no version of the bill at all.

                                    This is going to be another public policy decision where the Republicans are jumping up and down and calling for a version of something when they are in fact ... in a minority ...
                                    The democrats have been trying to get socialized medicine passed for over 50 years and the American people continue to come out strongly AGAINST it.

                                    Obama and the democrats stuffing ObamaCare down the throats of the American people who clearly did NOT want it is the main reason why the democrats got THRASHED in the 2010 mid-terms just 2 short years after being given a total mandate at the voting booth in 2008.

                                    Its always a mistake to take anything a liberal democrat says at face value. Only the loony left-wing wants socialized medicine with everyone else strongly against it.
                                    Comment
                                    • andywend
                                      SBR MVP
                                      • 05-20-07
                                      • 4805

                                      #53
                                      If you get really sick, would you rather have the current system as it stands (quality healthcare at a high cost) or a government run socialized system where the majority of hospitals will resemble county type clinics.

                                      85%-90% of Americans have some form of medical insurance and very few of these people ever complain about the quality of healthcare they receive. They only complain about the cost of the escalating medical insurance premiums, co-payments/deductibles, etc.

                                      Severely lowering the quality of healthcare to save money is ABSOLUTELY INSANE. I wish there was a way to give all liberal democrats the socialized medical care system they so strongly desire while leaving the current high quality medical care system currently in place for only republicans to use.

                                      This way, the average democratic voter would live many years less than the republican voter.

                                      Wouldn't that be a "win-win" scenario!!!
                                      Comment
                                      • jw
                                        SBR MVP
                                        • 10-25-09
                                        • 3999

                                        #54
                                        Originally posted by andywend
                                        The democrats have been trying to get socialized medicine passed for over 50 years and the American people continue to come out strongly AGAINST it.

                                        Nope .. money from big business has come out against it ... there is less money to be made if a government option passes.

                                        Originally posted by andywend
                                        Obama and the democrats stuffing ObamaCare down the throats of the American people who clearly did NOT want it is the main reason why the democrats got THRASHED in the 2010 mid-terms just 2 short years after being given a total mandate at the voting booth in 2008.

                                        Its always a mistake to take anything a liberal democrat says at face value. Only the loony left-wing wants socialized medicine with everyone else strongly against it.

                                        .. and once again you are wrong .. more people want what we have right now .. or legislation that goes further .. than those who want a total repeal and to go back to where we were .. your spin might work for the small minded Right wing nutjobs that you surround yourself with .. but step out of your comfort zone and you will find people who don't agree with you.

                                        Originally posted by andywend
                                        If you get really sick, would you rather have the current system as it stands (quality healthcare at a high cost) or a government run socialized system where the majority of hospitals will resemble county type clinics.
                                        If I were to get really sick .. i'd be on the first plane back to the UK ..

                                        Originally posted by andywend
                                        I wish there was a way to give all liberal democrats the socialized medical care system they so strongly desire while leaving the current high quality medical care system currently in place for only republicans to use.
                                        There is .. and they have this system in the UK .. though your ignorance and arrogance on the subject do not seem to allow you to admit that people can have views that don;t agree with yours and yet the views they have can also be valid ...

                                        In the UK .. as well as the government run system .. there is also a "private" system .. pay a little extra each month and you can get to see the exact same doctors that will treat you on the government run system ... only you can get an appointment a few days earlier, you can get a private room with cable tv and a choice of meals .. etc etc ...

                                        A government run system working side by side a private system .. not exactly re-inventing the wheel, but it works, and it works very, very well.


                                        Maybe you should try and research the system you so hate so much Mr Wend .. you might actually learn something.
                                        Comment
                                        • brooks85
                                          SBR Aristocracy
                                          • 01-05-09
                                          • 44709

                                          #55
                                          Originally posted by jw
                                          Nope .. money from big business has come out against it ... there is less money to be made if a government option passes.




                                          .. and once again you are wrong .. more people want what we have right now .. or legislation that goes further .. than those who want a total repeal and to go back to where we were .. your spin might work for the small minded Right wing nutjobs that you surround yourself with .. but step out of your comfort zone and you will find people who don't agree with you.



                                          If I were to get really sick .. i'd be on the first plane back to the UK ..



                                          There is .. and they have this system in the UK .. though your ignorance and arrogance on the subject do not seem to allow you to admit that people can have views that don;t agree with yours and yet the views they have can also be valid ...

                                          In the UK .. as well as the government run system .. there is also a "private" system .. pay a little extra each month and you can get to see the exact same doctors that will treat you on the government run system ... only you can get an appointment a few days earlier, you can get a private room with cable tv and a choice of meals .. etc etc ...

                                          A government run system working side by side a private system .. not exactly re-inventing the wheel, but it works, and it works very, very well.


                                          Maybe you should try and research the system you so hate so much Mr Wend .. you might actually learn something.


                                          here is a great idea everybody, lets see what jw thinks. The person who doesn't even know why healthcare cost were rising in the first place.



                                          Everyone is going to have fun waiting to see the doctor if the right decision isn't made.
                                          Comment
                                          • d2bets
                                            BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                                            • 08-10-05
                                            • 39995

                                            #56
                                            Originally posted by Tully Mars 63
                                            It's completely possible the court could punt the main issue and basically say "no one's been force to buy anything yet" get back to us when that happens.

                                            Would that make you happy?
                                            I hear you, but if that was the case then why would they have heard the case now at all? Pretty insane from a practical standpoint to have spent all the time and work on the case only to say come back to us in 18 months and we'll do it all over again. I don't think that's going to happen.
                                            Comment
                                            • d2bets
                                              BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                                              • 08-10-05
                                              • 39995

                                              #57
                                              Originally posted by Sam Odom
                                              "be careful what you wish for because you might get it."


                                              I hope so... I want the US Constitution to be followed. Dont you ??
                                              Right, so they'll fix it and follow the Constitution by instead creating single payer funded by taxes. Everyone agrees that's the more Constitutional alternative. Will you prefer that?
                                              Comment
                                              • Sam Odom
                                                SBR Aristocracy
                                                • 10-30-05
                                                • 58063

                                                #58
                                                Originally posted by d2bets

                                                Will you prefer that?

                                                Originally posted by Sam Odom

                                                You would be shocked as to what Sammy Odom thinks should happen with Healthcare



                                                I believe some sort of phased-in single payer/'Medicare for all' & merge Medicaid into Medicare is the solution - cannot crash the health Ins industry overnight


                                                Just an idea , not saying it is workable but ---> begin with 'Medicare for all' for prenatal - 18yo (gap) then 55yo Up. Start closing the 'gap' gradually over X number of years.


                                                .
                                                Comment
                                                • d2bets
                                                  BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                                                  • 08-10-05
                                                  • 39995

                                                  #59
                                                  Originally posted by Sam Odom



                                                  I believe some sort of phased-in single payer/'Medicare for all' & merge Medicaid into Medicare is the solution - cannot crash the health Ins industry overnight


                                                  Just an idea , not saying it is workable but ---> begin with 'Medicare for all' for prenatal - 18yo (gap) then 55yo Up. Start closing the 'gap' gradually over X number of years.
                                                  Fair enough. I'd be good with pairing that with allowing those in the gap optionally to buy into medicare, regardless of pre-existing conditions. Kind of like the government option.
                                                  Comment
                                                  • convick
                                                    SBR MVP
                                                    • 11-03-11
                                                    • 3954

                                                    #60
                                                    Originally posted by andywend
                                                    Its always a mistake to take anything a liberal democrat says at face value. Only the loony left-wing wants socialized medicine with everyone else strongly against it.
                                                    Thats a pretty stupid blanket statement to make. Im a loony leftist and I want no part of this. I know others with similar political leanings have the same opinion.
                                                    Comment
                                                    • Sam Odom
                                                      SBR Aristocracy
                                                      • 10-30-05
                                                      • 58063

                                                      #61
                                                      convick , TRUE Liberals opposed to ObamaBots hate what ObamaCare turned into...
                                                      Comment
                                                      • d2bets
                                                        BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                                                        • 08-10-05
                                                        • 39995

                                                        #62
                                                        Anyone know what time the ruling is expected to be announced tomorrow?
                                                        Comment
                                                        • andywend
                                                          SBR MVP
                                                          • 05-20-07
                                                          • 4805

                                                          #63
                                                          Originally posted by convick
                                                          Thats a pretty stupid blanket statement to make. Im a loony leftist and I want no part of this. I know others with similar political leanings have the same opinion.
                                                          convick, considering you're an admitted "loony leftist", I would guess that you oppose ObamaCare because you don't think it goes far enough.

                                                          If you are against socialized medicine in its entirety and want to keep the current medical care system exactly as is, then I'll retract my previous statement.
                                                          Comment
                                                          • Tully Mars 63
                                                            SBR MVP
                                                            • 08-06-11
                                                            • 2750

                                                            #64
                                                            Originally posted by d2bets
                                                            I hear you, but if that was the case then why would they have heard the case now at all? Pretty insane from a practical standpoint to have spent all the time and work on the case only to say come back to us in 18 months and we'll do it all over again. I don't think that's going to happen.
                                                            Well they're hearing arguments on more then one issue and even if they opt to hear a one issue case, say death penalty, doesn't mean they're going to over rule the lower court. They could easily rule on all issues but the mandate and then punt. Or they could up hold the whole damn thing. On several cases the SCOTUS has sided with Congress and the lower courts, meaning they heard the case but chose not to over turn it. Two cases come to mind- Gonzales vs. Raich and United States v. Comstock the court ruled that congress has the right under the commerce clause to over rule states (medical MJ) and ruled broad interpretation to Congress’s authority to pass legislation that it considers “necessary and proper.” Health care is something like 15-18% of GDP, depending on your source. Maybe they'll consider congresses actions “necessary and proper.”

                                                            I still think they over turn at least the mandate but really I wouldn't place money anywhere near this and I still expect something really unexpected. What that is... I have no idea.

                                                            We'll out find out soon... then I expect a whole lot of bitching.
                                                            Comment
                                                            • Tully Mars 63
                                                              SBR MVP
                                                              • 08-06-11
                                                              • 2750

                                                              #65
                                                              Originally posted by d2bets
                                                              Anyone know what time the ruling is expected to be announced tomorrow?
                                                              I want to say 10am Eastern, but I could be wrong.
                                                              Comment
                                                              • Sam Odom
                                                                SBR Aristocracy
                                                                • 10-30-05
                                                                • 58063

                                                                #66
                                                                T-Minus 59 minutes and counting
                                                                Comment
                                                                • Tully Mars 63
                                                                  SBR MVP
                                                                  • 08-06-11
                                                                  • 2750

                                                                  #67
                                                                  Originally posted by Sam Odom
                                                                  T-Minus 59 minutes and counting
                                                                  They have 3 (?) rulings due today... any bets that this will be the last one they issue?
                                                                  Comment
                                                                  • Sam Odom
                                                                    SBR Aristocracy
                                                                    • 10-30-05
                                                                    • 58063

                                                                    #68
                                                                    Tully , the universe is not static
                                                                    Comment
                                                                    • Tully Mars 63
                                                                      SBR MVP
                                                                      • 08-06-11
                                                                      • 2750

                                                                      #69
                                                                      Originally posted by Sam Odom
                                                                      Tully , the universe is not static

                                                                      I was out until 2 and didn't crash until nearly 4... I'm sorry I don't get your point here. Could you clarify? If not I'll drink some more coffee and nurse this headache and re-read in a while.
                                                                      Comment
                                                                      • opie1988
                                                                        SBR Posting Legend
                                                                        • 09-12-10
                                                                        • 23429

                                                                        #70
                                                                        Originally posted by NYSportsGuy210
                                                                        Any civilization that doesn't feel that it is imperative to care of it's peoples' health needs is a savage society to begin with. Wouldn't be surprised if ObamaCare gets dismantled entirely.....it's not like this nation is selfless or mature.

                                                                        Listen to this fukkin idiot.

                                                                        What would you possibly know, kid? You should be thankful that your parents were allowed into this country instead of trying to act like a 21 year old that actually knows anything.
                                                                        Comment
                                                                        Search
                                                                        Collapse
                                                                        SBR Contests
                                                                        Collapse
                                                                        Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                                                                        Collapse
                                                                        Working...