Eli Manning IS An ELITE Pro QB.......

[NYSportsGuy210]

......eat it bitches!!

NY Giants football all day!!

[rsnnh12]

No. Just no. Good? Yes. Elite? No way in hell

[NYSportsGuy210]

Just like SB XLVII all over again......

[NYSportsGuy210]

No. Just no. Good? Yes. Elite? No way in hell

Clearly you don't know football buddy. He outplayed Tom Brady twice.....one for a Superbowl ring as a HUGE underdog. Eli one of the best fade touch passers in the league.

The kid knows how to play QB.

[Full Time Hobo]

Not elite. Pro QB, yes.
Love seeing the Pats lose though and watching Brady pout

[blackbeSSt]

**cough** 35 yard pass interference **cough**

[NYSportsGuy210]

Yea like Tom "Terrific" doesn't get pass interference calls from time to time. It was a legit PI. Just part of the game people.

[Monitor-Tan]

Nothing more awesome then watching Pats lose at home. Not only did Eli beat Brady in the SB, now he beats him at home without his #1WR and his #1 RB. That is solid. Eli was trying to back up what he said in that interview.. Eli is pretty good QB when coming from behind and in 4th quarter

[blackbeSSt]

Yea like Tom "Terrific" doesn't get pass interference calls from time to time. It was a legit PI. Just part of the game people.

no doubt it was legit. my point was that helped them down the field to score. no PI, no TD

[rsnnh12]

Clearly you don't know football buddy. He outplayed Tom Brady twice.....one for a Superbowl ring as a HUGE underdog. Eli one of the best fade touch passers in the league.

The kid knows how to play QB.

Did you watch the game?? He threw some God awful passes that should have been picked off. Only reason he got the PI call at the end was because his throw was so far off that Sergio misread where the receiver was.

Just like the Tyree catch, Eli got lucky as hell

[zoo youk]

just said the same thing in the in game thread! and started a thread about this being his career year!

[The Bet Master]

Nah. Good, not great.

[NYSportsGuy210]

no doubt it was legit. my point was that helped them down the field to score. no PI, no TD

Thats simply a statement you can't make. Eli is certainly capable of STILL making big pass plays on virtually any down to put the Giants in scoring position. He could have easily came back and threw a 25 yarder to Manningham or Ballard on the next down even if no PI call the play before. The guy is an elite veteran.

[zoo youk]

Thats simply a statement you can't make. Eli is certainly capable of STILL making big pass plays on virtually any down to put the Giants in scoring position. He could have easily came back and threw a 25 yarder to Manningham or Ballard on the next down even if no PI call the play before. The guy is an elite veteran.

and he is doing it this year with lesser talent than he has ever had around him.

granted Nicks, Cruz and Manningham are all really developing well.

now if we could just get Jerril Jernigan and Barden going........

[DMB40]

no doubt it was legit. my point was that helped them down the field to score. no PI, no TD

Still have to get the td which ELI did.

Why does everyone hate him so much. Plays the game right. Wins. What else do you need. He is having his best season so far and has no major weapons.

[robmpink]

New York Giants Comp Att Yds Pct Y/A Sack YdsL TD Int Rating
Eli Manning(notes) 20 39 250 51.3 6.4 0 0 2 1 77.9

[blackbeSSt]

Thats simply a statement you can't make. Eli is certainly capable of STILL making big pass plays on virtually any down to put the Giants in scoring position. He could have easily came back and threw a 25 yarder to Manningham or Ballard on the next down even if no PI call the play before. The guy is an elite veteran.

and i'll counter that that's simply a statement that you can't make. all i heard all game was about how he's throwing off his back foot and makes horrible throws (see the PI call which was really short).

[BobHarvey]

Elite? Not even close. He's an older version of Andy Dalton.

[zoo youk]

New York Giants Comp Att Yds Pct Y/A Sack YdsL TD Int Rating
Eli Manning(notes) 20 39 250 51.3 6.4 0 0 2 1 77.9

yeah? what you trying to say? the W and final score is what matters.

[NYSportsGuy210]

Did you watch the game?? He threw some God awful passes that should have been picked off. Only reason he got the PI call at the end was because his throw was so far off that Sergio misread where the receiver was.

Just like the Tyree catch, Eli got lucky as hell

Nah Eli has that "magic". It's that Manning spunk. Archie is truly a god send to the NFL.

Oh yea and fcuk Kevin Boss too. You cave him out in Oakland. We got the second coming of Mark Bavaro at TE with this Ballard kid. What a pair hands on this guy.

Bring on Jim Harbaugh and corn hole SF 69er squad next week. Our front four will expose their fraud QB and take it 23-13 next week in their building.

[blackbeSSt]

oh and don't forget the 20 yard PI call to put the ball at the 1.

[zoo youk]

and i'll counter that that's simply a statement that you can't make. all i heard all game was about how he's throwing off his back foot and makes horrible throws (see the PI call which was really short).

if i recall Brett Favre made some of the worst throws you can possibly imagine and I believe leads the NFL in all time interceptions...but is still considered one of the greatest QBs to play...

[blackbeSSt]

if i recall Brett Favre made some of the worst throws you can possibly imagine and I believe leads the NFL in all time interceptions...but is still considered one of the greatest QBs play...

HA! now you are putting them in same sentence? please.

[GunShard]

I can tell you live in New York. You're obviously going to be biased on New York based teams, lol.

[zoo youk]

HA! now you are putting them in same sentence? please.

you obviously dont get it. no sense in debating any longer as you are going to believe what you want and what the talking heads tell you "all I heard all game how Eli was making throws off his back foot and what terrible passes he made"

[sneakerhead]

Re-read the definition of elite

[NYSportsGuy210]

Listen name a list of the top 10 QB in the league. Eli is at least 7th. Would take him over Vick, Romo or Phillip Rivers anyday.

[DwightShrute]

Elite Manning

[Monitor-Tan]

Listen name a list of the top 10 QB in the league. Eli is at least 7th. Would take him over Vick, Romo or Phillip Rivers anyday.

Lol, cuz they don't have a ring

[Monitor-Tan]

One thing I can definitely say is, when the games on the line and my team's down and needs to win, I'll give the ball to Eli over Peyton anytime

[NYSportsGuy210]

Elite Manning

Haha...YES

[rsnnh12]

Listen name a list of the top 10 QB in the league. Eli is at least 7th. Would take him over Vick, Romo or Phillip Rivers anyday.

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Peyton
Big Ben
Rivers
Schaub
Vick
Eli

I have him 9th right now, obviously my list is for the past couple years and this year

[Monitor-Tan]

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
Peyton
Big Ben
Rivers
Schaub
Vick
Eli

I have him 9th right now, obviously my list is for the past couple years and this year

No ring for Schaub, Vick and Rivers, they don't know how to get it done yet, so sorry Eli already goes ahead of the list. Eli can be a QB that you can rely on when you are down. There's no denying that. Eli is more clutch then Peyton. But as a NY fan I won't say he's elite yet..

[k13]

We'll see what he does against an Elite D.

[rsnnh12]

No ring for Schaub, Vick and Rivers, they don't know how to get it done yet, so sorry Eli already goes ahead of the list. Eli can be a QB that you can rely on when you are down. There's no denying that. Eli is more clutch then Peyton. But as a NY fan I won't say he's elite yet..

So Eli is better than Marino and Jim Kelly too, right?