How was that not offensive pass interference in GIants/Eagles game

[OmgUrMom]

the throw where eli threw off his back foot.

Giants wr was just trying to break up play and not going forball.

now they made the 3rd down conversion

[Austin103]

Agree.

[Resler]

Well they called it a catch in the first quarter when the Giants were in a long 3rd down situation. I also think Manningham's TD in the First Quarter could have been called offensive pass interference. Refs seems to be missing a lot.

[Resler]

Wow, now a ridiculous fumble call. That analyst on FOX always makes the correct call and he was baffled when they ruled the fumble.

[OmgUrMom]

yep seems to be a pretty big homefield advantage so far in this game

[nyed1010]

Wow, now a ridiculous fumble call. That analyst on FOX always makes the correct call and he was baffled when they ruled the fumble.

I'm obviously biased for the Giants, but seriously? The most important thing about that play was the ruling on the field was a catch and fumble. I don't think you could overrule that call based on the replays. It was clear the ball was coming out before he was down, the question was whether he had possession of the ball to start with, nothing on the replays showed conclusively that he did not gain full possession after the catch. The right call was made and don't really think it matters. The Giants are thoroughly dismantling the eagles right now. When the Giants are healthy which they are today(with the exception of Smith) they are a better team than the eagles.

[Resler]

Giants are dismantling them, but still some terrible calls. Also, that fumble decision was huge, 7 points, 17-3 much better than 24-3, but yes Giants are looking tough.

[bobbyfk]

doesn't matter..Giants look to good. Game is over

[OmgUrMom]

I'm obviously biased for the Giants, but seriously? The most important thing about that play was the ruling on the field was a catch and fumble. I don't think you could overrule that call based on the replays. It was clear the ball was coming out before he was down, the question was whether he had possession of the ball to start with, nothing on the replays showed conclusively that he did not gain full possession after the catch. The right call was made and don't really think it matters. The Giants are thoroughly dismantling the eagles right now. When the Giants are healthy which they are today(with the exception of Smith) they are a better team than the eagles.

this one was a tough call, could of gone either way really