Could a player on a terrible team win the Heisman?

[Albert Pujols]

Say Robert Griffin on Baylor? Kid is amazing.

[Fishhead]

Absolutely no chance.............

[Chi_archie]

its only happened a few times....

[Fishhead]

its only happened a few times....

.....and it's not happening with a kid from Baylor.

[Albert Pujols]

Absolutely no chance.............

Thinking the same, but it is a shame.

[LT Profits]

Yes, but the player's stats would have to BLOW AWAY the stats of other leading contenders from the better schools.

[Club]

More likely, a terrible player on a great team would win it. I don't know how anyone can take the Heisman trophy award seriously after Gino Toretta won it.

[Doc JS]

the last player that I can think of who won from a bad team was Paul Hornung from Notre Dame.

While LT is, at least, theoretically right, a player from a bad team could win it...I think it highly unlikely.

Doc

[Doc JS]

More likely, a terrible player on a great team would win it. I don't know how anyone can take the Heisman trophy award seriously after Gino Toretta won it.

well...I dont think a terrible player will win it...but I do agree that a prominent player (althought not necessairly great player) on a great team has a better chance.

Doc

[Albert Pujols]

What were the preseason odds?

[Puppy]

.....and it's not happening with a kid from Baylor.

[Louisvillekid1]

lol @ fishhead...

[TexansFan]

Say what Fish?

[rm18]

lol @ fishhead...

Fishhead posted before the 2010 season not 2011 Griffin got 0 Heisman votes that year I think

[Glitch]

Fishhead posted before the 2010 season not 2011 Griffin got 0 Heisman votes that year I think

also notice he said "A" kid from baylor not "the" kid from baylor

but i suppose the program has improved.

[Inkwell77]

OP is sharp to call this, even though it was a year too soon

[TexansFan]

Fishhead posted before the 2010 season not 2011 Griffin got 0 Heisman votes that year I think

We know what year the thread was started, but that's not what fish said though.

[HoulihansTX]

I'm from TX, and would have agreed wholeheartedly with Fish's post.

Baylor football has been a joke for decades. B4 RG3, the best player to come out of Baylor was a punter, Supulveda, who won the Ray Guy in two consecutive years.

They used to go by the name "Bye-lor". Lol

[BettingWizard]

.....and it's not happening with a kid from Baylor.

[Sunde91]

another swing and a miss from fishdick

good one albert