Hey SBR community,
I wanted to share some honest thoughts and get feedback from other sharp bettors—especially anyone who’s used OddsJam for DFS Pick’em platforms like PrizePicks, Underdog Fantasy, Betr Picks, Dabble, Rebet, and others.
I have been a long-time OddsJam subscriber and a serious sports bettor for the past few years. Throughout this time, I have consistently followed the OddsJam YouTube channel and closely tracked Alex Monahan’s live streams and betting strategies to sharpen my approach.
For the past few years I have been living in a state without access to legal U.S. sportsbooks, but I have actively used multiple DFS Pick ‘em platforms, including PrizePicks, Underdog Fantasy, Betr Picks, Dabble, Rebet, and others. During this time I have been able to devote significant time to tracking market inefficiencies across these platforms using OddsJam tools such as the Positive EV tool, Fantasy Optimizer, Arbitrage, and Middles tools. I saw this as a potential long-term side hustle with the expectation that, over a large sample size, my edge would generate consistent profits.
However, despite my extensive volume and disciplined approach, my results have been significantly worse than expected. Unlike the success stories frequently highlighted on OddsJam’s platform and social media, I have found this to be a costly and time-consuming endeavor rather than a profitable one.
Key Issues:
Alex recently posted a YouTube video titled How I Made $115,000 on DFS (PrizePicks, Betr, Underdog Fantasy) in 2024: Full Tutorial for Beginners, where he displayed massive profits across various DFS apps via his Pikkit results:
How is this possible? I have followed Alex’s content intently and implemented the exact same strategies, yet my results are nowhere near the same. In fact, I am losing on the majority of these platforms while simultaneously being aggressively limited.
I have attempted to bet on Rebet, but I am capped at $20 per wager and often have bets outright rejected by their risk team. In contrast, Alex has shown screenshots of betting upwards of $5,000 per slip—how is he and other Rebet users allowed to get such a large bet size down while I struggle to get down $20 wagers on this platform?
Exchange-Based Betting & Further Concerns:
More recently, I have started using exchange-based platforms like Novig and Prophet X, which do not impose strict limits on bettors. Despite continuing to beat CLV over a large sample size, I am still down thousands of dollars between the two.
At what point does "variance" stop being a reasonable explanation? I have set up multiple 1:1 coaching calls with OddsJam experts in the past year, but each time, my losses are attributed to variance. Given my large sample size, this no longer seems like an adequate answer.
Pikkit Bet Tracker Summary:
I have attached a few screenshots of my Pikkit results dating back to November 2022, however, I did not begin betting significant volumes on most of these platforms until late 2023 . Here is a breakdown of my all-time profit/loss across different platforms:
Profitable Platforms:
Losing Platforms:
Final Questions:
This was supposed to be a lucrative side hustle with +EV over time. Instead, it’s been a huge time sink and financial hit. At this point, I’m seriously considering canceling my subscription and walking away unless I get real answers—or find a community of others who’ve found alternative approaches that actually work.
Would love to hear your thoughts—especially from others who use OddsJam or similar tools in unregulated states and focus primarily on DFS Pick’ems and/or legal betting exchanges like ProphetX and Novig.
Appreciate any honest insight or shared experience!
I wanted to share some honest thoughts and get feedback from other sharp bettors—especially anyone who’s used OddsJam for DFS Pick’em platforms like PrizePicks, Underdog Fantasy, Betr Picks, Dabble, Rebet, and others.
I have been a long-time OddsJam subscriber and a serious sports bettor for the past few years. Throughout this time, I have consistently followed the OddsJam YouTube channel and closely tracked Alex Monahan’s live streams and betting strategies to sharpen my approach.
For the past few years I have been living in a state without access to legal U.S. sportsbooks, but I have actively used multiple DFS Pick ‘em platforms, including PrizePicks, Underdog Fantasy, Betr Picks, Dabble, Rebet, and others. During this time I have been able to devote significant time to tracking market inefficiencies across these platforms using OddsJam tools such as the Positive EV tool, Fantasy Optimizer, Arbitrage, and Middles tools. I saw this as a potential long-term side hustle with the expectation that, over a large sample size, my edge would generate consistent profits.
However, despite my extensive volume and disciplined approach, my results have been significantly worse than expected. Unlike the success stories frequently highlighted on OddsJam’s platform and social media, I have found this to be a costly and time-consuming endeavor rather than a profitable one.
Key Issues:
- I have taken advantage of sign-up bonuses on all of these platforms.
- I have been using all available DFS Pick’em platforms, only placing optimal slip types for each (e.g., 5- and 6-man flex for PrizePicks & Betr Picks, 6-man insured for Underdog Fantasy, 3- and 5-man non-insured for Dabble, etc.).
- I have incorporated correlated plays in my fixed payout parlays and used Kelly Criterion for bet sizing.
- Despite consistently beating Closing Line Value (CLV) across a large sample size, I am still down over $5,000 across these platforms.
- Worse yet, I have been heavily limited on multiple platforms (PrizePicks, Underdog, Betr, Dabble) despite not even being profitable on most of them.
Alex recently posted a YouTube video titled How I Made $115,000 on DFS (PrizePicks, Betr, Underdog Fantasy) in 2024: Full Tutorial for Beginners, where he displayed massive profits across various DFS apps via his Pikkit results:
- $14,440.01 profit on Underdog Fantasy
- $67,581.10 profit on Betr
- $14,063.34 profit on Rebet
- $32,546.86 profit on Dabble
How is this possible? I have followed Alex’s content intently and implemented the exact same strategies, yet my results are nowhere near the same. In fact, I am losing on the majority of these platforms while simultaneously being aggressively limited.
I have attempted to bet on Rebet, but I am capped at $20 per wager and often have bets outright rejected by their risk team. In contrast, Alex has shown screenshots of betting upwards of $5,000 per slip—how is he and other Rebet users allowed to get such a large bet size down while I struggle to get down $20 wagers on this platform?
Exchange-Based Betting & Further Concerns:
More recently, I have started using exchange-based platforms like Novig and Prophet X, which do not impose strict limits on bettors. Despite continuing to beat CLV over a large sample size, I am still down thousands of dollars between the two.
At what point does "variance" stop being a reasonable explanation? I have set up multiple 1:1 coaching calls with OddsJam experts in the past year, but each time, my losses are attributed to variance. Given my large sample size, this no longer seems like an adequate answer.
Pikkit Bet Tracker Summary:
I have attached a few screenshots of my Pikkit results dating back to November 2022, however, I did not begin betting significant volumes on most of these platforms until late 2023 . Here is a breakdown of my all-time profit/loss across different platforms:
Profitable Platforms:
- PrizePicks: + $8,896.93 (limited to $5 per slip)
- Boom Fantasy: + $2,367.00 (no longer supported by OddsJam)
- Sleeper: + $673.80
- Thrive Fantasy: +$466.00 (Thrive Fantasy appears to now be illiquid)
Losing Platforms:
- Chalkboard Fantasy: -$10.80 (no longer supported by OddsJam)
- Rebet: - $203.38 (Capped at $20 per bet, bets often flagged and rejected by risk team)
- ParlayPlay: - $976.90
- NoVig: - $1,125.53
- Underdog Fantasy: - $1,657.13 (Limited to three $25 slips per day)
- Dabble: - $1,778.28 (Limited to $23.62 for 3-man slips, $13.81 for 5-man slips)
- ProphetX: - $2,469.04
- Jock MKT: - $2,545.50 (No longer supported by OddsJam)
- Hotstreak: - $3,482.75
- Betr: - $3,704.63 (Limited to $10 per slip)
Final Questions:
- Has anyone else experienced similar long-term negative results while beating CLV using OddsJam tools?
- Are others getting limited despite losing money on these platforms?
- How are Alex and others on YouTube betting thousands per slip on platforms like Rebet when many of us can’t get $20 down without being flagged?
- Are the strategies taught by OddsJam really viable long term, or is there something we’re not being told?
This was supposed to be a lucrative side hustle with +EV over time. Instead, it’s been a huge time sink and financial hit. At this point, I’m seriously considering canceling my subscription and walking away unless I get real answers—or find a community of others who’ve found alternative approaches that actually work.
Would love to hear your thoughts—especially from others who use OddsJam or similar tools in unregulated states and focus primarily on DFS Pick’ems and/or legal betting exchanges like ProphetX and Novig.
Appreciate any honest insight or shared experience!
Attached Files