Who's the greatest Alabama QB of all time?
-
-
NFL or NCAA level?? AJ McCarron and Tua lit up the College game. Tua had Ruggs, Juedy, Waddle and Devante to throw to so that counts for something. NFL level there is not enough data unless you default Brody Croyle for starting some games.Comment -
I think Mac Jones had the best season of any recent Bama QB and will be a better PRO than both AJ and TUA.Comment -
I'll be more specific, which U of Alabama QB had the best NFL career.Originally posted by seaborneq
I wasn't 100 percent specific.Comment -
My vote would be "The Snake."Originally posted by stevenashComment -
see post #1 Buck him and Namath excluded. slim pickings now?Originally posted by BuckandadimeComment -
This question had nothing to do with passing or passing yards just to be clear!! Who was the greatest besides Namath and Stabler
One guy no one remembers is Pat Trammel went 26-2-4 Bear Bryant's all time favorite player!
or AJ McCarron 36-4
L didn't see the NFL part until after my answer but these 2 as collage winners!!Comment -
Nash wants best NFL career not college success.Originally posted by jackpot269Comment -
Look aboveOriginally posted by Easy-Rider 66Comment -
Originally posted by jackpot269
Comment -
Jay BarkerWhere's the fuckin power box, Carol?Comment -
Originally posted by Easy-Rider 66
That wasn't in the original post!! I edited my other postComment -
If you're talking best NFL player, maybe Richard Todd.Where's the fuckin power box, Carol?Comment -
It’s impossible to choose one it’s not even a respectable conversationComment -
Bottom Line Nash is take out Namath and Stabler it's slim pickings at least for who I remember. I think Mac Jones will prove to be the best of the bunch in due time. excluding the 2 you mentioned.Comment -
Originally posted by jjgold
Get LostWhere's the fuckin power box, Carol?Comment -
Damn...Originally posted by Easy-Rider 66
Well, go with my second choice then...
Bart Starr..Comment -
Most of you won't remember this guy, but Richard Todd was a really good player but was overshadowed by THE NYSE. Klecko and Gastineau. I would say Richard Todd over Brodie Croyle by a country mile. Todd had the Jets in the playoffs and the brink of the Super Bowl a couple of times.Comment -
yeah forgot about Todd. good callOriginally posted by seaborneqComment -
Richard Todd with the jets!! LOL that was a joke
Really I would say Star also!! I think he won he win 2 super Bowls? Before my time!Comment -
Maybe he was better than I rememberOriginally posted by seaborneqComment -
It's better than 99.8 percent of the trash you post ya half a hump ya.Originally posted by jjgold
Comment -
The answer has to be Starr, btw.
Late drive in the Ice Bowl was epic.Where's the fuckin power box, Carol?Comment -
What years was it that they were on brink of super bowl?Originally posted by seaborneq
23 NYJ qb 14 13 6 2-4-0 65 162 40.1 870 3 1.9 12 7.4 44 5.4 2.4 13.4 66.9 33.2 29 233 3.34 0.82 15.2 0 1 -1 24 NYJ QB 14 12 11 3-8-0 133 265 50.2 1863 11 4.2 17 6.4 87 7.0 5.0 14.0 155.3 60.3 24 203 5.74 3.86 8.3 1 3 8 25 NYJ qb 14 5 5 2-3-0 60 107 56.1 849 6 5.6 10 9.3 49 7.9 4.9 14.2 169.8 61.6 15 122 5.96 3.25 12.3 1 1 4 26 NYJ QB 14 15 15 8-7-0 171 334 51.2 2660 16 4.8 22 6.6 72 8.0 6.0 15.6 177.3 66.5 25 222 6.79 4.92 7.0 10 27 NYJ QB 14 16 16 4-12-0 264 479 55.1 3329 17 3.5 30 6.3 55 6.9 4.8 12.6 208.1 62.7 42 326 5.76 3.83 8.1 0 2 11 28 NYJ QB 14 16 16 10-5-1 279 497 56.1 3231 25 5.0 13 2.6 49 6.5 6.3 11.6 201.9 81.8 30 224 5.71 5.54 5.7 2 1 11 29 NYJ QB 14 9 9 6-3-0 153 261 58.6 1961 14 5.4 8 3.1 56 7.5 7.2 12.8 217.9 87.3 23 206 6.18 5.90 8.1 13 30 NYJ QB 14 16 16 7-9-0 308 518 59.5 3478 18 3.5 26 5.0 64 6.7 5.2 11.3 217.4 70.3 42 314 5.65 4.20 7.5 0 1 8 31 NOR QB 11 15 14 6-8-0 161 312 51.6 2178 11 3.5 19 6.1 74 7.0 4.9 13.5 145.2 60.6 33 267 5.54 3.70 9.6 5 5 6 32 NOR 14 2 0 16 32 50.0 191 3 9.4 4 12.5 56 6.0 2.2 11.9 95.5 60.3 1 10 5.48 1.85 3.0 1 119 108 48-59-1 1610 2967 54.3 20610 124 4.2 161 5.4 87 6.9 5.3 12.8 173.2 67.6 264 2127 5.72 4.25 8.2 9 14 71 NYJ 102 94 42-51-1 1433 2623 54.6 18241 110 4.2 138 Comment -
Yeah, first name that popped in my mind when I heard the question.Originally posted by ChuckyTheGoatComment -
I guess this is cracker barrel stuff. As long as it does not get disrespectful to the regular Joe’s on the teams that they were just dirt.
At the end of the day - the quality of the regular Joe’s is just as important?Comment -
There's a reason I had Richard Todd on the brain. He's the answer to THIS trivia Q:
*What Alab QB followed Ken Stabler in College and Joe Namath in the pros?Where's the fuckin power box, Carol?Comment -
1981 He won a playoff game and 1982 he made it to the nastiest and sloppiest AFC Championship game in history.Originally posted by jackpot269Comment -
OK buddy I had forgot about that!! I remember those 1st couple years in the NFL was rough and he was a really good collage player !!Originally posted by seaborneqComment -
Broadway Joe has made more money and definitely got laid more although The Snake was a near dead heat second. Oh, and won a Super Bowl as a double digit dog.Comment -
no need to exclude namath certainly not the greatest just the most popular, but Id have to go with bart starr with stabler excludedComment -
There’s no question other than Namath/Snake it’s StarrComment -
If memory serves me right Todd held the NFL record for many years for most completions in a game.Comment
