When is winning going to effect Aaron Rodgers legacy?

[Goat Milk]

??? a loss is a loss rookie

peyton never lost a SB as a 2 td favorite

if u want to play games
brady never started a SB with his center sending the snap into the end zone to gift wrap points and the ball to the opponent ... and the 2013 hawks were the ultimate version of the legion of boom hawks... ton more depth that year vs 2014 and stars weren't playing the super bowl with injuries... and they didn't lose their nickel corner to freak injury after he got a pick like what happened to hawks vs brady after he threw dumbass pick in the end zone to Lane. he abused Lane's backup later in the game once he figured out to do that

2014 seahawks were stacked. Basically same exact team. Brady was down 10 going into the 4th quarter of that game. Did you forget that? Down 10 against the greatest D in history basically and he scores 2 tds in the 4th. Shredded them. The same D Manning folded up shop against with superior offense.

Safety in endzone happened because Manning panicked. Tried to change the play like a fool while crowd was going nuts. No one could hear shit. Bad mental error.

And I brought up Eagles cause you said Brady's stats in that game weren't good. Was tossing yards to bums like it was nothing. Manning has had Hall of fame WRS. Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison. D Thomas and E Sanders aren't HofFame but they are one step down from it. Brady's best WR of the last 12 years has been Julian Edelman bro. Guy barely has a 1000 yard season to his name.

[rm18]

Edelman not even close to Moss and Welker. Brandin Cooks better too.

[Goat Milk]

Edelman not even close to Moss and Welker. Brandin Cooks better too.

Moss was like more than a decade ago. Brady turned bums like James White and Kevin Faulk and Dion Branch into winners. Through pure leadership. Captain America. Half of sports is mental. It's not all about athleticism/pure talent.

[rm18]

He got cut 9 seasons ago.

[MiDNiTe]

and what was his stats in 5 afc title games? or are those not big time games... so the games today weren't big time?

mahome's stats won't count in 7 years when we look back and say "he got to play Tannehill" so that doesn't count... boy did it count earlier today when people had their money loaded up on titans spread/ML

Superbowls are the pinnacle of a players career, can't even compare Brady to Peyton, u love Peyton ok I rather have Rodgers than peyton if u think differently that's fine

[asiagambler]

Manning played Brady 4 times in the AFC title game and won 3 of them. That has to count for something though I personally think it's pointless to award team accomplishments to a single player. Put Rodgers on SF and they go 19-0

[MiDNiTe]

If your life depended on winning a game and u could only pick out of Peyton or Rodgers most here would pick Peyton? Rodgers for me

[asiagambler]

I would pick Rodgers

[The General]

liberal leanings got him screwed up.

[Duckshit]

Gay
Grumpy
and Short.....needs to come out of the closet.
Needs to stop being a Dik to his teammates and his family.

[Inspirited]

Rodgers likely got robbed of a sb appearance when his teammate decided to go off his assignment as a blocker and go after the onside kick.
Brees likely got robbed of a sb appearance last year on that non pass interference call.

Manning was gifted a sb his last year with the Broncos.

All these guys would likely have more sb wins had they been on the Patriots with Belichick as coach.

[The J-Dizzle]

He's 1-3 in NFC Championship games and has only played in 1 SB (which granted he did win).

You all crowned this guy way too early. He's getting up there in age now and this is all that is on his resume.

If 1-3 is all you look at then you're way off pal. First off, look at how many points they have allowed in pretty much every playoff loss. It's around 40 per game. In the other losses, he was never given the chance in OT.

[pologq]

rodgers is good. i just think he needs more talent around him.

brady made more out of nothing so i give brady the nod over rodgers.

imo, if rodgers is so good he would not be 1-3 in nfc championships, sorry. rodgers had chances yesterday.

[seaborneq]

Aaron Rodgers completed nearly 80% of his passes yesterday and the Packers were never in the game. Looks like his window has closed. Maybe Aaron Rodgers is so good that the team never had a chance to to build a powerhouse around him. Every season that he starts and finished the Packers probably pick in the 20's and none of the best Free agents in their prime have signed with the Packers since Reggie White. Outside looking in Aaron Rodgers is bringing a plastic knife to a gunfight.

[Git Lo]

There some serious knowledge in this thread, Im impressed.

Books had it right when they made GB huge underdogs, they never had a good offense going into the playoffs not rodgers fault hes got 1 good receiver and a decent rb thats it, they finally gave him an okay defense all these years but look at the players other teams have had on offense for years and how tf did andy reid not play mahomes over alex smith the year the lost to tennessee even the players were saying that mahome was outplaying him in practice and its obvious now.

[Snowball]

Obviously quarterback can only do so much

Jimmy G was 6 of 8 passing !

[shocka1212]

fifth playoff loss where his Defense gave up 37 or more points.... y'all got some fuckn nerve.........

[Booya711]

fifth playoff loss where his Defense gave up 37 or more points.... y'all got some fuckn nerve.........

fumbled twice (got one back) and threw two picks....and the game didnt start out 37-0 did it? your boy Eli was better in postseason shocka

[jjgold]

He does well year after year

[ThaTopMoron]

Superbowls are the pinnacle of a players career, can't even compare Brady to Peyton, u love Peyton ok I rather have Rodgers than peyton if u think differently that's fine

u saw it... Rodgers can't carry a playoff team to victory vs a better overall opponent in the playoffs. he did it maybe once vs Dallas but they had a rookie QB and Garrett... big whoop

u should go look up how many times Manning overcame facing the leagues #1,2 or 3rd best defenses in the playoffs. or that one team he came out a winner vs 1,2 and 3 in the same playoffs... first QB to ever do it. stats in the playoffs are for rookie viewers.

what was Jimmy's stats again yesterday?

[packerd_00]

Garoppolo threw for 77 yards,and his team scores 37 points. You do the f@cking math.

[packerd_00]

Bro stop

His run defense was the pits,you can overlook it if you choose.

[MiDNiTe]

u saw it... Rodgers can't carry a playoff team to victory vs a better overall opponent in the playoffs. he did it maybe once vs Dallas but they had a rookie QB and Garrett... big whoop

u should go look up how many times Manning overcame facing the leagues #1,2 or 3rd best defenses in the playoffs. or that one team he came out a winner vs 1,2 and 3 in the same playoffs... first QB to ever do it. stats in the playoffs are for rookie viewers.

what was Jimmy's stats again yesterday?

Hard to reason with a idiot, yes Peyton is the best, it's like a tennis player thinking a grand slam semi is as or more important than a gs win or final

[ThaTopMoron]

Hard to reason with a idiot, yes Peyton is the best, it's like a tennis player thinking a grand slam semi is as or more important than a gs win or final

Rodgers only nfccg win was vs a bears team when cutler got hurt

let me know when he wins his 5th MVP ... but he never wins because he is always holding onto the ball or throwing it away so he doesn't have to throw risky passes and risk his td to int ratio

rodgers will face a real schedule next season and you'll see what's up

[MiDNiTe]

Rodgers only nfccg win was vs a bears team when cutler got hurt

let me know when he wins his 5th MVP ... but he never wins because he is always holding onto the ball or throwing it away so he doesn't have to throw risky passes and risk his td to int ratio

rodgers will face a real schedule next season and you'll see what's up

I already knew Rodgers would get hammered by 9ers, I said 9ers would represent nfc start of playoffs, said Packers no chance before the match, how many threads saying 9ers overrated and lose 1st game, people overreacting because they faded 9ers, yeah dig through my past post. You love Peyton ok that's your opinion don't be a idiot forcing your opinions onto other people

[nyplayer33]

He doesnt have the team...stop thinking hes everything

[nyplayer33]

Not sure rodgers worrirs about td to int ratio....got to love the pass he made few years ago vs dallas in playoffs...lol