Giants Made Massive Mistake Taking Barkley Instead Of QB

JAKEPEAVY21 · 10-23-18, 07:20 AM

The Giants fans and media are getting exactly what they asked for. All hell broke loose last year when Eli was benched, now live with it!

They can draft a QB this upcoming draft, Barkley is a stud obviously..it might work out for them in the long run?

bigtymer56 · 10-23-18, 07:20 AM

None of that matters when you're O-line is trash. Hard to win when you cant run for a couple of yards whenever you need to. Guys couldn't even successfully do a qb sneak.

Hman · 10-23-18, 07:21 AM

They'll get a QB in next year's draft.

Derek Carr will probably be available soon too.

jjgold · 10-23-18, 07:28 AM

Barkley is great of course and draws fans but winning and injury proof NO

It is about a QB

Bluehorseshoe · 10-23-18, 08:05 AM

How about trading Barkley and getting some bodies?

Legions36 · 10-23-18, 09:42 AM

Originally posted by Bluehorseshoe

How about trading Barkley and getting some bodies?

They trade barkley and I will never forgive them. Suck the season up as a lose and fill the holes next year.

clockwise1965 · 10-23-18, 09:46 AM

Derrick Carr will be a available.

pickle_texas · 10-23-18, 09:51 AM

and you guys think NY will pay for Carrs ridiculous current contract?

LT Profits · 10-23-18, 10:04 AM

Finish this year 1-15 and then draft Herbert

Would not be a bad nucleus with Herbert-Saquon-OBJ and Engram

And Herbert could bring out best in OBJ with his excellent deep ball

PaperTrail07 · 10-23-18, 10:06 AM

They wanted Eli.....you got em LOL...

Art Vandelay · 10-23-18, 10:17 AM

Originally posted by LT Profits

Finish this year 1-15 and then draft Herbert

Would not be a bad nucleus with Herbert-Saquon-OBJ and Engram

And Herbert could bring out best in OBJ with his excellent deep ball

Best part of that: Shurmer will be long gone! That was embarrassing last night...

shocka1212 · 10-23-18, 10:32 AM

Yea, Because id be booking my Super Bowl weekend itinerary as we speak if Darnold was at the helm.

shocka1212 · 10-23-18, 10:34 AM

Originally posted by LT Profits

Finish this year 1-15 and then draft Herbert

Would not be a bad nucleus with Herbert-Saquon-OBJ and Engram

And Herbert could bring out best in OBJ with his excellent deep ball

regret the Engram pick. say what you want about McAdoo, guy wanted Maholmes bad enough to try and trade up and dumbass Jerry reese wouldn't do it.

turkkatarian · 10-23-18, 10:36 AM

Giants shoulda took Darnold at 2 and then tooken a RB in the 3rd or 4th rounds. Other teams have struck gold in the Later rounds with rbs. Chiefs Kareem Hunt and the Steelers James Conner. I will say Saquan is a Beast but Eli is more then Washed up. They needed a QB and Blew it.

LT Profits · 10-23-18, 10:40 AM

Originally posted by turkkatarian

Giants shoulda took Darnold at 2 and then tooken a RB in the 3rd or 4th rounds. Other teams have struck gold in the Later rounds with rbs. Chiefs Kareem Hunt and the Steelers James Conner. I will say Saquan is a Beast but Eli is more then Washed up. They needed a QB and Blew it.

I look at things differently. I think Saquon will be better in NFL than any RB coming out this year and I think Herbert will be better than any QB in this past draft class. With that in mind, Giants played it right (provided they tank for Herbert).

jjgold · 10-23-18, 10:58 AM

We need a qb bad

Bench him

GzaTheGenius · 10-23-18, 12:12 PM

Best RB of our generation potentially.. yeah bad move

Looks like they'll be in position for a good draft pick this year too

Great pick IMO

ChuckyTheGoat · 10-23-18, 01:08 PM

Originally posted by jjgold

QB's have the most impact on a game not a RB

WOW

Get some new material. Not good anymore.

Bluehorseshoe · 10-23-18, 01:15 PM

Originally posted by LT Profits

I look at things differently. I think Saquon will be better in NFL than any RB coming out this year and I think Herbert will be better than any QB in this past draft class. With that in mind, Giants played it right (provided they tank for Herbert).

They're not even close to having a functioning offensive line so it really doesn't matter.

209 Life · 10-23-18, 01:17 PM

Originally posted by Hman

They'll get a QB in next year's draft.

Derek Carr will probably be available soon too.

Nope! stop buying into the hype, Carr isn't going anywhere

stevenash · 10-23-18, 01:25 PM

We should have had Rivers but Eli was a baby and refused to play in San Diego.

GzaTheGenius · 10-23-18, 01:26 PM

Originally posted by stevenash

We should have had Rivers but Eli was a baby and refused to play in San Diego.

2 Super Bowls

chico2663 · 10-23-18, 02:25 PM

j j stick to videos and hookers. Giants line is atrocious. Qb would be getting the david klinger book on being an nfler behind that line. With rb he can break a few tackles and make things better. They should be in position to draft a qb and decent line. You brought up connor but it is pitts line that is making him.

chico2663 · 10-23-18, 02:26 PM

Originally posted by LT Profits

I look at things differently. I think Saquon will be better in NFL than any RB coming out this year and I think Herbert will be better than any QB in this past draft class. With that in mind, Giants played it right (provided they tank for Herbert).

lt they need to address that line

reigle9 · 10-23-18, 02:30 PM

did you make this thread specifically for me to call you a retarded \*\*\*\*\*\*?

which qb? arent they all buried except for darnold, who is a fruitloop and will eventually implode

barkley is the best player in the nfl, just draft a competent qb this coming year...i really really wanted to like the oregon qb but he's about 14yo and needs another year

everyone else sucks, idk what they should do...they're just buried i guess

Goat Milk · 10-23-18, 02:40 PM

Qbs are easy to find. Barkley is a once in a generation player. They'll be more qbs next year and the year after and the year after. There won't be another Barkley for another 20 years.

jjgold · 10-23-18, 03:22 PM

Running backs get hurt all the time it’s a passing league now

ikid2groove415 · 10-23-18, 03:47 PM

Franchise QB is the hardest thing 2 find in the NFL- over the years giants always win with defense - Average QB at best
-

stevenash · 10-23-18, 04:00 PM

Originally posted by reigle9

barkley is the best player in the nfl,

I like Bark myself a lot, but best player in the NFL?
Come on, rethink that.
Gurley may break Tomlinson's record for most TD's by a RB.
Do we want to talk WR's? Or is that comparing apples to oranges.
Bark is a top five or six RB, give him three more season's before we call him the best player in the NFL.

ikid2groove415 · 10-23-18, 04:03 PM

Originally posted by Goat Milk

Qbs are easy to find. Barkley is a once in a generation player. They'll be more qbs next year and the year after and the year after. There won't be another Barkley for another 20 years.

Just stop goat

reigle9 · 10-23-18, 04:13 PM

gurley is having a better season, you don't think barkley would be doing just as good if not better in the same position?

the fact barkley can do anything on this shit dead to rights offense is surreal

i said he's the best player, not that he should win mvp or whatever

shadymcgrady · 10-23-18, 04:16 PM

Yeah it's Barkley's fault that Eli would've been out of the league 4 yrs ago if not for his last name. Barkley is a stud, none of the QBs would've had a bigger impact

shadymcgrady · 10-23-18, 04:22 PM

Originally posted by stevenash

I like Bark myself a lot, but best player in the NFL?
Come on, rethink that.
Gurley may break Tomlinson's record for most TD's by a RB.
Do we want to talk WR's? Or is that comparing apples to oranges.
Bark is a top five or six RB, give him three more season's before we call him the best player in the NFL.

While Barkley is certainly not the best player in the NFL, he is a better rb than gurley. Gurley is having a ladainian like season statistically but given gurleys situation it is unfair to say that he is the best running back based on his stats

Barkley is right up there with David Johnson as the best running back in the NFL right now. Stats only pertain to situation and fantasy football leagues

reigle9 · 10-23-18, 04:25 PM

i'm happy that you can be objective about barkley, shady...as he does come from rape children U

is he on your fantasy team or are you a giants fan? this doesn't make sense coming from you