Who's Your NFL MVP?

Louisvillekid1 · 12-10-12, 05:11 PM

RG3

Popcorn Trick · 12-10-12, 05:12 PM

A lot of people will probably dismiss Luck because of his Int's, but man he should be considered. Same to a lesser degree with Matt Ryan.

Aaron Rodgers
Peyton Manning
Eli Manning
Adrian Petersen

Goat Milk · 12-10-12, 05:12 PM

Brady, Manning, Peterson

one of those 3 will get it

no one else in the discussion. rodgers? no chance.

a lot depends on Brady's performance on b2b prime time games against 2 of the best teams in the league (houston, 49ers)

Louisvillekid1 · 12-10-12, 05:13 PM

AP/Peyton is going to win it ....

Smoke · 12-10-12, 05:13 PM

Suh

Popcorn Trick · 12-10-12, 05:17 PM

I guess maybe AD would be the wise pick if you were going to put money on someone. QB's might really split the vote up.

mynameismud · 12-10-12, 05:22 PM

purple jezus

Gamble32jn · 12-10-12, 05:41 PM

Peyton manning for me

Bcatswin · 12-10-12, 05:50 PM

It's going to be Peyton.

falconticket · 12-10-12, 05:50 PM

Gonzalez

face · 12-10-12, 05:58 PM

if brady wins next two games it's brady for me

iifold · 12-10-12, 06:03 PM

Well if MVP means "most valuable player"...

Which in turn means "best" player...

Then I think you'd have to give it to the greatest football player to ever live...

A.Rodgers...

They win 3 games without him...

-No line
-No running game
-Defense injured and soft

Yet has them in the playoffs and once again SB Contenders...

Brady would be lucky to win 8 games on this Packer team...

Goat Milk · 12-10-12, 06:13 PM

Originally posted by iifold

Well if MVP means "most valuable player"...

Which in turn means "best" player...

Then I think you'd have to give it to the greatest football player to ever live...

A.Rodgers...

They win 3 games without him...

-No line
-No running game
-Defense injured and soft

Yet has them in the playoffs and once again SB Contenders...

Brady would be lucky to win 8 games on this Packer team...

yeah give Brady the greatest cornerback in nfl history and he'd win multiple superbowls with him.

Brady will win the MVP. Watch.

BMoreBird · 12-10-12, 06:17 PM

adrian pederson or peyton manning. whoever doesn't win mvp will win comeback. jj watt obvious defensive player of year.

frostno98 · 12-10-12, 06:19 PM

If the Broncos finish 13-3, Manning might get the MVP. If the Patriots loses today or next week, and Denver clinches the 2nd seed, Mannings a lock for the MVP.

balls2wall · 12-10-12, 06:20 PM

Originally posted by Louisvillekid1

AP/Peyton is going to win it ....

this

Hopefully the one of those two that doesn't win it will get comeback player of the year

I think Peyton ends up getting it because his team is playoff bound and has a shot at making it to the super bowl

If AP's team was better...

d2bets · 12-10-12, 06:23 PM

Peyton Manning

Goat Milk · 12-10-12, 06:24 PM

No one giving Brady any credit

unreal

better stats

same record

will show everyone why he's the best tonight and next week

Witness

rsnnh12 · 12-10-12, 06:26 PM

Originally posted by frostno98

If the Broncos finish 13-3, Manning might get the MVP. If the Patriots loses today or next week, and Denver clinches the 2nd seed, Mannings a lock for the MVP.

This. Toss up between Manning and Brady right now, if Brady has great games these next 2 weeks than its his to lose. If he doesn't do well, Manning will get it and fairly easily. Peterson has an outside shot if both QBs play poorly these next few weeks.

iifold · 12-10-12, 06:38 PM

Lets see...

Manning plays Raiders Twice, Chargers Twice, and Chiefs Twice

Brady plays Dolphins Twice, Bills Twice, and Jets Twice

Rodgers plays Bears Twice, Vikings Twice, and Lions Twice...

How about we throw records and stats out the fukkin window and just watch the fukkin games...

If you can't tell Rodgers is the greatest QB we've ever seen, well then there is no hope for you...

Popcorn Trick · 12-10-12, 06:48 PM

Originally posted by Goat Milk

yeah give Brady the greatest cornerback in nfl history and he'd win multiple superbowls with him.

Brady will win the MVP. Watch.

Interesting point, except if you are talking about Woodson.. Makes me feel uneasy just reading that.

Deion did bring the Niners a Superbowl tho

iifold · 12-10-12, 06:52 PM

Rodgers saved Woodson's career...

He's always been an overrated tweener...

Rodgers gave this defense the leads they need to be the attacking, risk-taking defense they have become...

slacker00 · 12-10-12, 06:53 PM

To me, it's Manning-Brady and Manning has the edge. Brady needs to win out with nice stats to have a shot.

Here's the odds:
Manning 1-2
Brady 7-2
Peterson 20-1
Luck 30-1

Peterson pretty much has to break some kind of record to have a shot, ie 506 yards in last 3 games to break Dickerson's single season 2105 yards would do it. Peterson has that kind of capacity in him, but that's asking a lot considering the schedule. I don't even know what Luck would have to do, I just can't see a rookie winning it even though Luck is taking a worse team than last years 2-12 Colts to the playoffs.

GunShard · 12-10-12, 06:54 PM

Legendary QB Peyton Manning.

SCS · 12-10-12, 06:55 PM

Adrian Peterson, with Robert Griffin III a distant second.

Goat Milk · 12-10-12, 06:58 PM

Originally posted by iifold

Rodgers saved Woodson's career...

He's always been an overrated tweener...

Rodgers gave this defense the leads they need to be the attacking, risk-taking defense they have become...

Woodson overrated? lol just look at the stats. Who can tackle like woodson at that size? Rodgers is no where near Brady or Manning. Come talk to me when Rodgers has a couple more rings. All Rodgers cares about is stats.

Woodson was on his way to taking a shit raiders team to the superbowl before the Brady tuck rule was invented after Woodson stripped him on the biggest play of the game. Woodson is the reason the Packers won the superbowl against Pitt buddy. In the lockroom at halftime when Woodson went down everyone shut up even Mccarthy and Woodson gave a speech. All the players talked about it afterwards.

Popcorn, I think Woodson is a better pure CB that Deion although Deion is obviously the better all around player as he was kick returner and could play safety and corner all at a HoFame level.

Popcorn Trick · 12-10-12, 06:58 PM

Originally posted by SCS

Adrian Peterson, with Robert Griffin III a distant second.

Who do you have for third? Is he Black?

I can see a lot of reporters thinking this: AP for comeback POY and Offensive POY. Manning MVP.

Popcorn Trick · 12-10-12, 07:01 PM

Originally posted by Goat Milk

Woodson overrated? lol just look at the stats. Who can tackle like woodson at that size? Rodgers is no where near Brady or Manning. Come talk to me when Rodgers has a couple more rings. All Rodgers cares about is stats.

Woodson was on his way to taking a shit raiders team to the superbowl before the Brady tuck rule was invented. Woodson is the reason the Packers won the superbowl against Pitt buddy. In the lockroom at halftime when Woodson went now everyone shut up even Mccarthy and Woodson gave a speech. All the players talked about it afterwards.

Popcorn, I think Woodson is a better pure CB that Deion although Deion is obviously the better all around player as he was kick returner and could play safety and corner all at a HoFame level.

I appreciate your love for Woodson. Loved when my Raiders drafted him. Still think he is great. I guess I have just seen him hold and get beat so much that I no longer, in good faith, say he is in that ultra-elite level. Felt this way for last 5 -7 years about him.

Dom Capers has been great for him tho.

Goat Milk · 12-10-12, 07:03 PM

Originally posted by Popcorn Trick

I appreciate your love for Woodson. Loved when my Raiders drafted him. Still think he is great. I guess I have just seen him hold and get beat so much that I no longer, in good faith, say he is in that ultra-elite level. Felt this way for last 5 -7 years about him.

Dom Capers has been great for him tho.

Didn't Woodson win DPOY 2 years ago? One of the best years of his career. Here's how I look at it. His picks have gone up in GB because ppl think he is slipping. Back when he was in OAK, I swear, teams would not even look Woodson's way. Sometimes I would watch an OAK game a QB would not even throw to Woodsons side even once the whole game, I swear.

KKoz9 · 12-10-12, 07:10 PM

Originally posted by Louisvillekid1

AP/Peyton is going to win it ....

No one else even close to these two...

RGIII, puh-lease, 3 good games and fools wanna crown him

rm18 · 12-10-12, 07:11 PM

JJ Watt as of now but I think the Texans might go on a huge losing streak

rm18 · 12-10-12, 07:12 PM

Originally posted by KKoz9

No one else even close to these two...

RGIII, puh-lease, 3 good games and fools wanna crown him

Griffin has been playing great all year, he has no receivers. The Redskins are actually 6-1 when Garcon plays, if Davis did not get hurt the Redskins might of had a chance to win it all

SCS · 12-10-12, 07:16 PM

Originally posted by Popcorn Trick

Who do you have for third? Is he Black?

What does color have to do with anything? I think Peterson has been the most valuable player to his team by a wide margin. I also happen to think that given his weapons, RGIII has been tremendous for the 'Skins. His performances have meant more towards Washington's success than Manning's (for example) have for Denver, IMO.

I would have Manning 3rd and Brady 4th if that's any consolation for you.

nygmen86 · 12-10-12, 07:17 PM

Peyton Manning