Most OVERRATED players in the NFL

[C-Gold]

QB: Michael Vick and it isn't even close.
QB: Tim Tebow for the 2% of people that don't realize he sucks.
RB: Michael Turner
WR: Desean Jackson
OLB: Brian Orakpou
CB: Terrance Newman
CB: Deangelo Hall
S: Bob Sanders is an oldie but goodie.

[wtt0315]

QB. Carson Palmer

[BoutDemCowboys]

CB: Terrance Newman - Is concidered overrated? Is he even rated? If any of the cowboys CB's were over-rated it would Mike Jenkins if ANYTHING.... I feel like there are way more qualified "over-rated" CB's out there I like the rest though..........

[face]

ndumbakong suh

[Louisvillekid1]

bob sanders was never overrated, just always hurt...

I was going to say Terrance Newman when I saw the thread title...

[Louisvillekid1]

CB: Terrance Newman - Is concidered overrated? Is he even rated? If any of the cowboys CB's were over-rated it would Mike Jenkins if ANYTHING.... I feel like there are way more qualified "over-rated" CB's out there I like the rest though..........

Well coming out of KST he was supposed to be all that, and it took a while for people to catch on...

[C-Gold]

bob sanders was never overrated, just always hurt...

I was going to say Terrance Newman when I saw the thread title...

Bob Sanders was WAYYYYYYYYYYY overrated. When he wasn't actually injured all they did was talk about him. "He's a short guy but he plays big. He's a great tackler. He's great back there." Over and over and over again like he was Ronnie F-in LOT. He was a midget that was always hurt that made some hits. No better no worse. They constantly talked about him and he wasn't all that. The guy was Ken Griffey Jr. Injury prone too. He's not even close to the player Troy P. is but they talked about him that much or more because the Colts defense wasn't that good and he had SOME talent but not nearly as much as they talked about.

He was the safety version of Michael Vick or Mark Reynolds. Strike out strike out and then BOOM home run that winds up on sports center.

[GunShard]

Overrated: QB Tim Tebow
Underrated: WR Stephen Hill

[ChalkyDog]

Chris Johnson. This guy owes Tennesse all the money he got in that contract. Needs to give it back.

Further, he should pay every fantasy owner in a money league at least $20.

CJ2K is the biggest load of shit in the NFL.

[GamblerSpirit]

Cry me a [Philip] Rivers.

[Stompin_Tom]

wheres matt ryan? people think hes god cause he blows out crap teams at home.

[Holtgetsback]

Bob Sanders was WAYYYYYYYYYYY overrated. When he wasn't actually injured all they did was talk about him. "He's a short guy but he plays big. He's a great tackler. He's great back there." Over and over and over again like he was Ronnie F-in LOT. He was a midget that was always hurt that made some hits. No better no worse. They constantly talked about him and he wasn't all that. The guy was Ken Griffey Jr. Injury prone too. He's not even close to the player Troy P. is but they talked about him that much or more because the Colts defense wasn't that good and he had SOME talent but not nearly as much as they talked about.

He was the safety version of Michael Vick or Mark Reynolds. Strike out strike out and then BOOM home run that winds up on sports center.

the only year he stayed healthy the colts won the super bowl

bob sanders was a great player "when healthy"

[k4cowboys4k]

Troy Polamalu is the most overrated player in the NFL period.

[TexansFan]

Mario Williams

[antifoil]

arian foster

[hankcream]

Namdi Asomugah, or however you spell his name. If you watched the Eagles / Ravens game you would have to agree- way overpaid. Eagles should have kept Samuel.

[Chi_archie]

Troy Polamalu is the most overrated player in the NFL period.

yep, that is what I planned on writing as well.

[romecloneout]

tony romo...he is dog shit

[mynameismud]

tony romo...he is dog shit

[Br0nxer]

Matt Ryan

Guy has done nothing but regress since he has been in the league

Dont care what he fukkin did against KC last week. We saw what they were yesterday in Buffalo.

Fully expecting Ryan to lay an egg tonight

[marcoloco]

Bob Sanders was WAYYYYYYYYYYY overrated. When he wasn't actually injured all they did was talk about him. "He's a short guy but he plays big. He's a great tackler. He's great back there." Over and over and over again like he was Ronnie F-in LOT. He was a midget that was always hurt that made some hits. No better no worse. They constantly talked about him and he wasn't all that. The guy was Ken Griffey Jr. Injury prone too. He's not even close to the player Troy P. is but they talked about him that much or more because the Colts defense wasn't that good and he had SOME talent but not nearly as much as they talked about.

He was the safety version of Michael Vick or Mark Reynolds. Strike out strike out and then BOOM home run that winds up on sports center.

He was a play maker, better than most other safetys around the league and played a pretty big role on colts defense. I dont think anyone put him above Reed or Troy. He seemed top 3-5 during his time, which is about right to me

[marcoloco]

Matt Ryan

Guy has done nothing but regress since he has been in the league

Dont care what he fukkin did against KC last week. We saw what they were yesterday in Buffalo.

Fully expecting Ryan to lay an egg tonight

He is like Romo, great season numbers

[marcoloco]

Namdi Asomugah, or however you spell his name. If you watched the Eagles / Ravens game you would have to agree- way overpaid. Eagles should have kept Samuel.

he was pretty dominate on the raiders tho, in case you missed those games

[marcoloco]

Rivers, Palmer, Reggie Bush....

[dlunc3]

Namdi Asomugah, or however you spell his name. If you watched the Eagles / Ravens game you would have to agree- way overpaid. Eagles should have kept Samuel.

he has actually played well this season... sure he got beat by jones for the td, it happens... but take a look at the rest of the game... he completely blanketed boldin who was completely silent.. and did the same thing the week before vs the browns..

no doubt he was probably overpaid, as he is a step slower as he is getting older.. but he is still a premiere corner in this league... Asante is a bum who is scared of contact and gets beat repeatedly. He gambles and gets a lot of picks, but gets killed on every double move. He didnt fit the eagles new defensive scheme in the slightest as he cant play man to man d

[k13]

Tom Brady.

[nic9212]

Back up QB Tim Tebow. media all over this guy

[bb_skoots]

If SBR is still around in 10 years, will someone please bump this thread when Polomalu goes into the Hall of fame?

[broadway6]

Darren McFadden (can not stay healthy)

[Vegas39]

29 posts and no one says Mark Sanchez

[k4cowboys4k]

If SBR is still around in 10 years, will someone please bump this thread when Polomalu goes into the Hall of fame?

He probably will go into the Hall of Fame solely because of the flashy plays he makes (diving over the line, etc.). However, Ryan Clark is the real safety in Pittsburgh as he is forced to cover both his and TP's zones on nearly every play.

Also, I'll throw in that Revis is fairly overrated.

[Andy117]

29 posts and no one says Mark Sanchez

Who thinks he's that good? He's an avg QB, that's it.

[dlunc3]

29 posts and no one says Mark Sanchez

everyone knows he sucks

[Andy117]

Also, I'll throw in that Revis is fairly overrated.

No he's not. Best CB in the league.

[Sol Diablo]

Tom Brady.