Demonstrated clear control/possession, took a couple steps, then lunged towards the end zone and the ball only moved once he hit the ground... Ground CANNOT cause a fumble. Should have been first and goal.
-
-
hate the call. but it was the correct call bro. ask calvin johnson about the rule..Comment -
It was a 50/50 call on review. But EVERYONE knows for a fact that the gift they got last week impacted the decision on this playComment -
Eddy it's such a bonehead rule and was a catch all fukking day! Just bumped Moneyshots thread where I brought it up awhile back and Briguy acted like I had no clue what I was talking about lol.Comment -
that was a catch. anyone who thinks otherwise is a penetrating idiot. penetrate green bay that was bullshitComment -
He made a "football" move after the catch, thereby demonstrating control. At what point does what happens with the ball, once hitting the ground, become irrelevant to the catch itself?Comment -
Bryant shouldn't have reached for the goal line when falling down, that's what caused the ball to hit the ground.Comment -
Just another stupid rule and reason the book is 10x bigger than it should be. Catch all day and night long as it never hits ground it shouldn't matter if he bobbled it toward end. It's just football don't over think so much nonsense with bonehead rules!Comment -
"Process of the catch." You must control the ball throughout the process. You can hate the rule, but they got it right. Calvin's years ago was far worse than this.Comment -
Selfish play by Bryant. All he had to do was hold onto ball. Instead like so many he wanted the Glory by reaching out for the goal line. He will have to live with this for rest of his lifeComment -
If you didn't know this rule existed (see Calvin Johnson), you're a moron and should stop betting on sports you don't know.Comment -
Its a problem that that was not a catch. Calvins catch should have counted too. Fix this.Comment -
Meader I'm fully aware they got it right by letter of the law. Just saying it's a stupid rule that needs to follow the "tuck" and see it's way out the door! If it had to Fukk somebody on this stage though glad it was Dallas but we see this dumb call in most games every wk.
Comment -
Tuck rule 2.0
Why should there be rules in place that contradict common sense? If everyone knows it's a catch, then there shouldn't be any arbitrary rule in place that overturns what everybody knows to be true.... that Dez caught the football.Comment -
Dez Bryant caught the ball.
The refs were wearing fudge packers jerseys all damn day long.
Garrett screwed up with the time out call in the first half.Comment -
Does it even matter anymore? Nfl is such a garbage product. Without betting and fantasy foots id watch maybe 5 games a year. Slow games with a million commercials and 50% of the time the refs decide the winner. Detroit got screwed last week and this week dallas.Comment -
what gets me is he had the ball clearly and even rolled over with the ball, it
wasn't until after he rolled over that the ball dangled in his fingers.
Thus, he was clearly DOWN WITH THE BALL. catch. once he was DOWN
and rolled over = that's IT. Play is dead if no fumble. catch.
Last night the refs almost blew the game for New England. Last week
they messed up with the Lions. Now this.
Not even football is safe from the interventionist "we control you" bullshit
so prevalent in our society. If you go back in NFL history I bet a lot of
games would have had different outcomes if the rules of now were
employed, who the hell knows anymore. As a gambler I want the
influence of the THIRD TEAM (officiating) as little as possible and
therefore NFL is turning into a lesser sport for me. Tennis and Volleyball.
Perhaps Golf .. anything without interventionist pricks ruining it.Comment -
Yep Eddy tuck rule 2.0 no doubt! Sucks for fans/players when ignorant rules cost you a gm or in this case "potentially" cost you. But unless you are flat out retarded or bias to the point of ignorance everyone knows Raiders won that gm and had it sealed after Woodsons strip. Too bad it just won't ever count as a W in books
Comment -
I'm fine with changing the rule... Another rule I would like to see done away with is the ball touching the ground. Make it simple, if the ball hits the ground, it's incomplete, period.Meader I'm fully aware they got it right by letter of the law. Just saying it's a stupid rule that needs to follow the "tuck" and see it's way out the door! If it had to Fukk somebody on this stage though glad it was Dallas but we see this dumb call in most games every wk.Comment -
Glad you put that. Ton of time left and they way Green Bay moved the ball in the 4th, I don't doubt the Packers still win.Yep Eddy tuck rule 2.0 no doubt! Sucks for fans/players when ignorant rules cost you a gm or in this case "potentially" cost you. But unless you are flat out retarded or bias to the point of ignorance everyone knows Raiders won that gm and had it sealed after Woodsons strip. Too bad it just won't ever count as a W in booksComment -
Comment -
Yeah Meader even a Girls td there would not have necessarily ended it and GB would only need a fg for potential tie or win. See this dumb rule every wk though it's nothing new. When "tuck".happened I think 95% of fans and even players didn't know what was happening or had ever seen or heard of it. Crazy how zebras pulled that outta their ass on the fly from page 100263.article 2b of the rule book lol.Comment -
I get this. But my point is, at what point do we determine whether the ground is causing a FUMBLE or an INCOMPLETION. He caught it cleanly, no bobbling whatsoever. He then turned his body towards the endzone, and managed to get three feet and a knee down before the ball ever pops loose.Comment -
There are plenty of rules that people don't know and/or have no place in the game. I remember on a kickoff return one time, the ball rolled and stopped right next to the sidelines. Randall Cobb stepped out of bounds and picked up the ball. That is ruled a kickoff out of bounds and the ball is spotted at the 40 yard line. How does that work?Comment -
Part of the problem also is that Dez Bryant was trying to be the hero and get the touchdown. If he had concentrated on catching the ball instead of reaching out, Dallas would have had a new set of downs to get the touchdown.
Billy don't be a hero... (old 70s songComment -
First of all, for all of you complete and total moron's who think they know the rule and do not, here is the rule:
"If a player goes to the ground in the act of catching a pass (with or without contact by an opponent), he must maintain control of the ball after he touches the ground, whether in the field of play or the end zone. If he loses control of the ball, and the ball touches the ground before he regains control, the pass is incomplete. If he regains control prior to the ball touching the ground, the pass is complete."
That is exactly what happens, you idiots. If you think not, you have no business being in here. As usual, you guys who ALWAYS lose your arse try to blame it on anyone but yourselves. The real b lame goes to the Dallas Cowgirls who could not defeat a crippled QB who could not move. If you are going to put the blame on something, blame Dallas. Also blame yourselves for being so stupid that you took Dallas and the ML. You guys are the biggest bunch of pu**ies I have seen. My grandson could kick all of your worthless arses. Now go back and hide behind your comuter and mommy's apron, you wusses.Comment -
well no matter what happened, you see how greenbay rolled down the field afterwards. so boys ML wouldnt hit imo.Comment -
Big daddy you are one of the biggest fukkin idiots on this forum so Stfu! Just like thread last week with controversial call in Cowboy gm half the retards in their missed the whole point! Don't see anyone crying in here about losing a bet it's the fact the league has too many overthought rules. Now eat your dinner , get cleaned up and ready for bed the short bus is arriving early in morning for you son. B#tch ass motherfukker
I never really talk that kinda shit here but you are an exception and true bona fide p.o.s.!
Comment -
He turned his body, took three steps and lunged, demonstrating possession and making a "football" move before going to the ground. This is a part of the rule that is supposed to be considered, even Jason Garrett alluded to it after the game.
And the part of the rule I highlighted in red doesn't apply because Dez never lost control of the ball before the ball touched the ground.Comment -
Touche!Comment
