Trade Review

[MexicanStallion]

Keeper League
Standard Scoring + 0.5 Per Reception

Team A Trades
Alfred Morris/Kevin Smith

for

Team B
Michael Vick/Mark Ingram

Below are the Teams rosters without those players. Thoughts on the trade?
Team A
QB: Schaub
Locker
Luck

RB: Charles
Bradshaw
Reggie Bush
Royster

Team B
QB: Cam Newton
Russel Wilson

RB: Michael Turner
Jonathan Stewart
Peyton Hillis
Bernard Scott

[Speedy88]

One of those trades that benefit both teams. Both teams really upgraded. Team A badly needed a QB, and Team B badly needed help at the RB position.

[dudekid]

yeah i guess you could make this trade, only because its ppr. bush and charles get a bit of an edge in a ppr league but i still like morris and smith more than all the RBs on team A's roster. schaub isnt really the worst QB either but you would think vick is an upgrade (although if he keeps playing this way that definitely isnt the case). id think this trade benefits team B more than A, as he gives away a QB he doesnt even use and gets 2 very solid RBs in return, and mark ingram is a joke lol. also not sure why these teams are rostering 3 QBs but maybe that is due to the league settings

[MexicanStallion]

yeah i guess you could make this trade, only because its ppr. bush and charles get a bit of an edge in a ppr league but i still like morris and smith more than all the RBs on team A's roster. schaub isnt really the worst QB either but you would think vick is an upgrade (although if he keeps playing this way that definitely isnt the case). id think this trade benefits team B more than A, as he gives away a QB he doesnt even use and gets 2 very solid RBs in return, and mark ingram is a joke lol. also not sure why these teams are rostering 3 QBs but maybe that is due to the league settings

I'm not in this trade actually. Just curious about feedback around here. Now Team A has 4 QBs lol. It is keeper, so that's why Luck was sitting behind Schaub and Locker was a late round pick. Vick and Cam were both keepers while he tried to trade Vick in the offseason. Wisconsin fan reason for adding Wilson. Benches are deep, so can afford 1 or 2 picks to hold out onto.. Its an IDP League too.

[Bigbill365]

i wouldnt trade Kevin Smith for ingrahm Kevin Smith is going to be Detroits go to guy for Running and Goalline because they dont have a real FB they use

[dudekid]

ah i gotcha, yeah i would say team A should not make the trade mainly b/c of the reasons above...kevin smith when healthy is a great RB and also as big bill mentioned, he is their full time, goal line RB...im just not very big on vick but i never have been...aside from the one great year i dont think he is all that spectacular, just gets a little boost because of rushing yds