Crazy to bench Peyton?

[TPowell]

I have Carson Palmer who I'm very confident in. Has put up 2 touchdowns in every game he's played this season. The snow doesn't really bother me, but the wind being 25+ all game does. Manning doesn't throw a hard ball so the wind should play a huge factor in his throwing. Anyone agree?

[burrissa]

I was thinking the same thing but my reasoning is different. My league uses a tired rule, so if you use a player three weeks in a row the third week he only gets half points. My other option though is Hoyer against Jacksonville's defense.

[BarkingToad]

Not if it's still snowing and windy game time.

[burrissa]

They're reporting that the snow should stop by game time but the wind should pick up (15-18 mph) and expecting gust up to 40 mph.

[TPowell]

wind is supposed to drop over the course of game but still going to be 17-20 MPH, not including gusts

[MikeTizzy]

lol tired rule..? Carson was just that safe start today

[Andy117]

I was thinking the same thing but my reasoning is different. My league uses a tired rule, so if you use a player three weeks in a row the third week he only gets half points. My other option though is Hoyer against Jacksonville's defense.

That's an interesting rule. What happens on the 4th week?

[Robber]

Peyton vs Carson is never a debate but I guess you got
Lucky

[MexicanStallion]

I wouldn't sit Manning any week during the season, but it worked out well for you here. Not bad.

[jjgold]

I don't know about fantasy but in the playoffs maybe it is a good idea to bench Peyton??

[LordVodka]

Peyton looked like an old man today. Not even a slice of that Papa Johns pizza could brong him back to life.

[Otters27]

might want to think about trading one of these guys to beef up your roster for the playoffs. Probably trade palmer as he is more likely to get injured

[mpaschal34]

I wouldn't blame the loss all in manning. Yes he made some bad plays. However I credit the Patriots more for their good play. They are white hot right now. Their offense is almost unstoppable at this time.

[MikeTizzy]

so how did ur benching of old man manning go??

[Andy117]

Peyton looked like an old man today. Not even a slice of that Papa Johns pizza could brong him back to life.

Old man still threw for 438 yds and 2 TDs. When that's a bad day, you're not too bad.

[Auto Donk]

stay with manning..... I saw him popping geritol after the game... he'll be fine next week

[EmpireMaker]

When you spend that high of a draft pick on a player you start him every week, unless he gets injured.

[STAX]

When you spend that high of a draft pick on a player you start him every week, unless he gets injured.

outdated fantasy logic here... you never factor in where you drafted a player in any decision you make, period.

[TPowell]

ended up starting Manning. He had 1 more point than Palmer did. Glad it didn't really matter in the long run

[Andy117]

That's an interesting rule. What happens on the 4th week?

Burissa, you never answered that question.

[Robber]

When you spend that high of a draft pick on a player you start him every week, unless he gets injured.

Not because of draft position but manning is a never bench

[Otters27]

Manning should have a big day here. No way he lets the Broncos lose to Oakland after the NE loss

[EmpireMaker]

outdated fantasy logic here... you never factor in where you drafted a player in any decision you make, period.

Your first round picks need to produce for you, there should be virtually no case where you start a waiver wire, middle of the road QB over your first rounder.

[Wrigley]

You never bench Peyton