help on a big multiplayer trade

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • dudekid
    SBR MVP
    • 12-08-09
    • 3200

    #1
    help on a big multiplayer trade
    hello all...

    this trade is in the works right now, wanted some opinions

    i give:
    reggie wayne
    frank gore
    either ahmad bradshaw or willis mcgahee, my choice

    i get:
    demariyus thomas
    torrey smith
    pierre thomas or bjge, my choice

    my current lineup:
    qb- vick
    3wr- wayne, cruz, garcon
    2rb- forte, gore
    flex- joique bell or ahmad bradshaw
    te- martellus bennett
  • BigSpoon
    SBR MVP
    • 11-04-10
    • 4113

    #2
    Demaryius is a beast but I'm not feeling it to be honest, RB depth is so important. Not sure the WR's upgrades are worth giving up that RB depth for.
    Comment
    • jds07v
      SBR MVP
      • 10-19-09
      • 1335

      #3
      PPR or no? Pierre has more value in a PPR.
      Comment
      • Speedy88
        SBR Posting Legend
        • 03-19-11
        • 11717

        #4
        Tough trade. I think it really comes down to your opinion on Gore. It would leave you kind of thin at RB, and you'd be forced to start Joquie Bell, BJGE/Pierre Thomas. You would upgrade big time at the WR position.

        Personally, I'd probably decline. If anything were to happen to Forte you'd be in huge trouble. I just don't think you can get by starting BJGE, Pierre Thomas, or Bell at RB.

        Good luck with whatever you decide to go with.
        Comment
        • dudekid
          SBR MVP
          • 12-08-09
          • 3200

          #5
          yeah i agree with you guys for the most part...it all comes down to the upside of the WRs vs the stability of the RBs...also will be tough when forte is on bye if i dont have gore. its non ppr, i think if this was a ppr this trade would be a no brainer for me
          Comment
          • EmpireMaker
            SBR Posting Legend
            • 06-18-09
            • 15580

            #6
            I don't like this trade at all giving up starting RB's for receivers is generally a bad idea
            Comment
            • Andy117
              SBR Hall of Famer
              • 02-07-10
              • 9511

              #7
              I'd pass or try to rework the deal into something smaller.
              Comment
              • peacebyinches
                SBR MVP
                • 02-13-10
                • 1112

                #8
                yeah, all things considered you are kind of forced to keep gore, I have no problems personally starting WRs at the flex spot, but if you give up gore your left with nothing but second string RBs (as long as Reggie Bush comes back healthy). Now... if Bush has a season ending injury or something, your golden, but thats the only real way you wouldnt be screwed at RB
                Comment
                • flocko76
                  SBR MVP
                  • 10-01-10
                  • 1447

                  #9
                  whats the rest of your bench look like? does it need to be a 3 player trade? why not just a 2 player trade?
                  Comment
                  SBR Contests
                  Collapse
                  Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                  Collapse
                  Working...