ray rice, trent richardson, mccoy or lynch or charles???

[Timmay]

What do you think?

[mjag21]

i like charles out of those 4... had lynch last year, always injured although did play well... was difficult with so many 4 o'clock games in case he misses. richardson and mccoy both new offenses like charles, but both will like th throw more and just prefer charles to rice.

[Speedy88]

I'd be weary of Lynch and Rice this year. Both have stud back ups (Pierce backing up Rice, and rookie Christine Michael backing up Lynch). Not that they won't get a lot of carries, but I think they will lose some snaps to their back ups. Charles, McCoy and Trent will get used a lot in their offenses.

If you don't worry about Charles foot injury a couple weeks ago, I'd go with him. I'd probably rank it: Charles, Trent, LeSean, Lynch, Rice.

[C-Gold]

Trent Richardson

1,000 yards and 10 TD last year is his floor.

1200-1500, 12-15 TD is more likely.

Plus he has the most natural talent of any of those guys and he will get 300+ carries. Let's say he gets 300 carries exactly @ 4.5 ypc. That's 1350 yards. Say he gets 13 or 14 touchdowns. That's worth it.

Him getting picked 10th or so is stupid. I'd take him #3.

[Timmay]

Yea, I don't know. I grabbed Spiller. Was this a bad idea? Is he injury prone? I literally only grabbed him because the league gave out 1 pt for 25 yard returns and I think Spiller might do a couple of them LOL. Who knows.