Which side would you rather have in this trade?

Speedy88 · 10-22-12, 07:22 PM

Give me team A all day. Only downside of A is the downgrade at TE. Pitta isn't even startable anymore, but if you can scoop a solid TE off the Waiver Wire, team A will be fine.

Major upgrade at QB, and major upgrade at WR in my opinion. Marshall, DThomas, and Roddy are all studs. And AJ has the capability of becoming a stud, but he can be hit or miss nowadays. Only downside of taking Team A is the downgrade at TE, and a bit of a downgrade from Shady to Charles.

But with all those WR's, I'd just ship off Andre Johnson for a solid TE like Gates.

dlunc3 · 10-22-12, 08:15 PM

Agreed... tho like you said, the upgrade at TE is huge. Stafford/Mccoy is most likely equal to Ryan/Charles... So, what it comes down to is.. are those 4 wrs more of an upgrade over Nicks, Welker and Wayne to make the #1 tight end in football not worth it?

Im trying decide on which lineup i would chose come playoff time

Speedy88 · 10-22-12, 10:38 PM

Originally posted by dlunc3

Agreed... tho like you said, the upgrade at TE is huge. Stafford/Mccoy is most likely equal to Ryan/Charles... So, what it comes down to is.. are those 4 wrs more of an upgrade over Nicks, Welker and Wayne to make the #1 tight end in football not worth it?

Im trying decide on which lineup i would chose come playoff time

In my opinion, Marshall, Thomas, and Roddy are all top 10 WR's. Marshall and Roddy might be top 5. I think Nicks, Welker and Wayne all fall outside of the top 10. Just my two cents.

mcduggly · 10-22-12, 10:47 PM

Originally posted by Speedy88

In my opinion, Marshall, Thomas, and Roddy are all top 10 WR's. Marshall and Roddy might be top 5. I think Nicks, Welker and Wayne all fall outside of the top 10. Just my two cents.

Thomas a top 10 receiver? Woah.

Speedy88 · 10-22-12, 10:55 PM

Originally posted by mcduggly

Thomas a top 10 receiver? Woah.

Your probably right. He's more in that 2nd tier group with Nicks and Wayne. I'd still rather have DThomas than Nicks, Welker, or Wayne.

Jericholic · 10-22-12, 11:03 PM

A for sure, much rather have that side.

mcduggly · 10-22-12, 11:09 PM

Originally posted by Speedy88

Your probably right. He's more in that 2nd tier group with Nicks and Wayne. I'd still rather have DThomas than Nicks, Welker, or Wayne.

I don't know, I think Wayne and Welker are pretty decent and are big parts of their respective offenses.

Grits n' Gravy · 10-23-12, 04:07 AM

I'd take b. Charles and Andre are injuries waiting to happen and Pitta is a crapshoot.

jwater · 10-23-12, 07:57 AM

Matt Ryan has been a top 3 QB this year

EmpireMaker · 10-23-12, 08:40 AM

A for sure, Ryan is a much much better QB option than Stafford this year

dlunc3 · 10-23-12, 10:27 AM

Originally posted by EmpireMaker

A for sure, Ryan is a much much better QB option than Stafford this year

Will this last though? Playoff time is all that matters, and their schedules are similar. They may be a push once playoffs come, or no?

me-first · 10-23-12, 11:48 AM

i would go A, but a case could be made for taking B..

soccerzyko · 10-24-12, 08:44 AM

I'd go with A, even though theres a huge downgrade in TE.
You could probably find a spot starter with a good matchup at the TE slot every week.

dlunc3 · 10-24-12, 02:20 PM

Seems like everyone is on board with team A.. Well, since week 2, I have made 5 trades which has resulted in me having team B instead

dlunc3 · 10-24-12, 10:49 PM

just updated the deal though... got back Charles and Roddy... gave away nicks, matthews and leshoure... this seems like a pretty solid deal imo