HELP Should I make this trade?

dudekid · 10-16-12, 11:17 AM

i dont think so, i feel like that leaves you too short at WR...plus, nicks has a great matchup this week and is finally getting healthy....besides, do you really think forte is that big of an upgrade over mendenhall? i see both putting up similar numbers if they stay healthy

Lazy-Man · 10-16-12, 11:32 AM

Thanks. You think I should make adjustments with my team or just leave it. I'm 4-2 now and projected to win by 42 points this week. I know projections mean sh!t but do I hold still

Lazy-Man · 10-16-12, 11:33 AM

Also am I giving up too much to get Brandon Marshall?

Receive Brandon Marshall, Chi WR
Receive Ravens D/ST, Bal D/ST from
Send Rashard Mendenhall, Pit RB
Send Nate Washington, Ten WR
Send Cardinals D/ST, Ari D/ST
Send Shonn Greene, NYJ RB

Points given for response~

veeds1690 · 10-16-12, 12:31 PM

Yes, you can't give up two of your RB's here for basically just Marshall. Ravens DST goes down in value after losing Webb and Lewis. Don't do this trade.

dudekid · 10-16-12, 01:59 PM

hm....on the flip side, im not so sure...marshall is a BEAST, and heres what your lineup would ultimately look like:

eli
marshall/andre (if its 2WR, nicks here if its 3wr)
rice/spiller
nicks (if its flex, if you use nicks at WR, you could put britt or add someone, maybe ask him for one other flex guy in return?)
rudolph

thats a pretty stacked lineup man, and marshall has a cake schedule coming up (i have him too)

it would be great to strengthen your wrs, since your best guy is andre who we know isnt having a good year even by like WR2 standards...

spiller and rice are going to get points for you at rb...what is your league like? 3 WR, or 2 WR and a flex? knowing that would really make me lean one way or another towards the trade

also, as much as you do lose a bit with the DEF...cards D is starting to scare me, i have them too...they have not been so good as of late, and now kolb is out and they have no run game so the D is going to probably be on the field a lot....that could help, but if they get tired out, then they will start to give up more points and patrick peterson hasnt been all that great really...and anyway with a defense you could stream them based on matchups so i wouldnt worry too much about that

Lazy-Man · 10-16-12, 02:30 PM

Yeah my line up would be stack. but i also lose a lot of depth so if one of my players get injured I am screwed. Since Andre isn't doing so good, I was going to offer Andre/Greene for Percy Harvin. Should I make that move?

ttwarrior1 · 10-16-12, 03:37 PM

let me guess your offering them these trades and not proposed to u

dudekid · 10-16-12, 03:38 PM

i mean...i like harvin, but honestly i like marshall more....i guess it depends on how much you value mendenhall....i was looking to trade for him but hes banged up pretty bad and the steelers o-line is decimated...is there anyone you could get for depth off waivers? if so, i'd do the marshall trade

**HELP** Should I make this trade?

HELP Should I make this trade?