tough trade offer

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • dudekid
    SBR MVP
    • 12-08-09
    • 3200

    #1
    tough trade offer
    ok guys i need help on a tough trade offer...this kid is usually the worst with trading (offers nothing but expects the world) but he made me, what i think, is a solid offer

    he trades:
    reggie bush/steve smith

    i trade:
    benjarvus/brandon marshall


    my lineup:
    qb-romo/luck
    3wr- andre j/marshall/mike wallace
    2rb- benson/benjarvus
    flex- miles austin

    i feel like i am deep enough at WR, so i could make this trade, still have WR options, but improve from benjarvus to bush...what do you guys think? who is the better back, and who would you rather have for wr?
  • dudekid
    SBR MVP
    • 12-08-09
    • 3200

    #2
    **i should also add, there is a 3rd part to both trades, he is giving davone bess for my andre roberts...but to me those guys dont really affect the trade at all, they are about equal, and i wont be starting either roberts or bess much if at all
    Comment
    • dlunc3
      SBR Hall of Famer
      • 10-31-09
      • 9129

      #3
      I think it is an ok deal For you… But Before accepting, I would try to counter offer… I would try to trade Miles Austin or even mike Wallace instead of Brandon Marshall..

      On the other hand, I do think you may be able to get a better player than Bush for some of the depth that you have... have you tried making any other offers yet Around the league?


      So all in all, I do like this trade, but think you have a lot more opportunities out there that could be better with the depth that you have on your team... I love Marshall, so I would try to trade one of your other receivers if possible
      Comment
      • dudekid
        SBR MVP
        • 12-08-09
        • 3200

        #4
        you are dead on my man! i love marshall too i have a "marshall mancrush" lol...i countered with austin in place of marshall, i will see what he says
        Comment
        • BIGDAY
          SBR Aristocracy
          • 02-17-10
          • 48245

          #5
          Ya man, I think he's getting a slightly better deal but that's just my 2c
          Comment
          • presley177
            SBR Wise Guy
            • 01-22-06
            • 936

            #6
            I like your end better with bush however if he accepts Austin instead of Marshall you win big!
            Comment
            • Straight Cash
              SBR MVP
              • 11-20-09
              • 2202

              #7
              I like the guys that you currently have more than the ones you'd be getting. Just my 2 cents.
              Comment
              • dudekid
                SBR MVP
                • 12-08-09
                • 3200

                #8
                thanks for all the input guys, much appreciated...what about if i did miles austin/bjge for bush/smith...do you think thats better for my side?
                Comment
                SBR Contests
                Collapse
                Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                Collapse
                Working...