Need trade help quick!!

[dlunc3]

This is a 1/2 ppr league... You have to start 1 rb and 2 wr.. and then we have 2 flex spots.

I have:

RBs: Charles, Matthews, Lehsore

WRs: Marshall, Roddy, Andre, D. Thomas, Amendola


I am being offered:

Lesean Mccoy + Antonio Brown

for

Charles, Leshore + Roddy


Should I do it? There are a lot of trades out there.. so I need to make a decision asap... thanks

[veeds1690]

Absolutely not. McCoy has been ineffective so far and Wallace has been great for Pitt. Charles is coming off a huge week, Leshoure is the primary back in DET, and Roddy is always reliable.

[dudekid]

see if hed take leshoure and roddy....def not all 3, no need to give up charles for basically nothing

[dlunc3]

only reason im considering it is because guys like leshoure and demaryius thomas do me no good if they are on my bench... i would be trading depth for a better starting lineup...

instead of:

matthews
charles
Andre
Marshall
Roddy

with DThomas, Leshoure, Amandola on my bench... I would have..



matthews
mccoy
andre
marshall
dthomas

with Brown and amandola on my bench..

the deal definitely helps my starting lineup... but no doubt hurts my depth..

[dlunc3]

How about this:

Would you trade:

Charles, Leshoure, Roddy, Dthomas, Amendola
for
Mccoy and Calvin ???


would be a sick starting lineup of ryan, matthews, mccoy, calvin, andre, marshall, and pita

only depth would be boldin and mendenhall possibly at some point..

[Andy117]

No way, looks like a lousy deal for you.

[veeds1690]

I think your team is fine how it is. Depth is not a bad thing and your starting lineup is still good. If you feel compelled to make a trade, maybe try Matthews Leshoure Roddy Thomas for Mccoy and Calvin

[dlunc3]

yea thats not a bad idea... i keep going back and forth on who i feel is more valuable.. Matthews or Charles?

[Speedy88]

I'll say this. I'd keep the depth. Andre, Mathews, and Charles are all injury prone.

[GamblerSpirit]

dlunc you're an Eagles fan, why not overpay to get him? Do it! Do it!

[will2survive]

you have the better players. no decision to be made

[MexicanStallion]

I would pass on the trade. I don't see it being a huge upgrade.

[dlunc3]

I made the trade with a few modifications...

I got: Antonio Brown and Lesean Mccoy

I gave: Roddy, Charles, Amendola + Mendenhall

Thoughts?

[GamblerSpirit]

I made the trade with a few modifications...

I got: Antonio Brown and Lesean Mccoy

I gave: Roddy, Charles, Amendola + Mendenhall

Thoughts?

Better. Nice choice.

[EmpireMaker]

No Way that is an awful trade, your team is already very solid.

[ramones951]

Fairly even

I've been a Charles believer since preseason but I'm also a fan of A Brown

Trying to get Shady in one of my leagues as well

Amendola and Mendenhall are expendable

As long as Julio Jones is healthy and continues to get most of the attention from Matt Ryan I think you made out pretty well