fantasy baseball trade help

[freeVICK]

got this offer today

me giving: gaby sanchez, tommy hanson

getting: kevin youkilis

12 team mix league

heres my team
c: john buck
1b: votto
2b: pedroia
ss: yunel escobar (furcal on dl)
3b: mark reynolds
IF: dunn
LF: cargo
cf: rasmus, crisp
rf: justin upton
of: jason bay

SP's: josh johnson, hamels, hanson, marcum, pineda, delarosa



im seriously thinking about taking the trade. i may be getting the short end of the stick, but as you can see im good at SP so i can afford to give up hanson. i already have votto and dunn at 1b, so im also willing to give up sanchez. i could really use youk at 3b and bench strikeout king reynolds.

what do you think?

[freeVICK]

common guys help me out

[Jasonal_98]

That's a tough one. I'm always hesitant to give up good young pitching. If that's the best deal you can make and you think it's right for your team, go for it. I can tell you, though, Youk has been nothing but frustrating to me as an owner this year!

[tat1980]

Even though you are deep I would not do it. Injuries ect. Hanson can be a #1 still very young as well as getting G. Sanchez young as well with a decent bat. Youk is a good player but aging fast. Is this a keeper league?

[MexicanStallion]

I would possibly do it. I don't love it, but I like it. It's pricey, but it's a nice upgrade in batting average from Reynolds to Youk. I think Sanchez will have a nice year and could drive in a similar number like Youk, but Dunn shouldn't suck forever?

[MexicanStallion]

That's a tough one. I'm always hesitant to give up good young pitching. If that's the best deal you can make and you think it's right for your team, go for it. I can tell you, though, Youk has been nothing but frustrating to me as an owner this year!

I hope he frustrates you for at least one more week.

[freeVICK]

That's a tough one. I'm always hesitant to give up good young pitching. If that's the best deal you can make and you think it's right for your team, go for it. I can tell you, though, Youk has been nothing but frustrating to me as an owner this year!

no doubt, im in the same boat with pedey. but youk is a career 300 hitter im sure he will pounce back. which is why i wanna buy now

hopefully i would be selling sanchez high... hard to tell if that guy is really that good, or just overachieving early

[freeVICK]

Even though you are deep I would not do it. Injuries ect. Hanson can be a #1 still very young as well as getting G. Sanchez young as well with a decent bat. Youk is a good player but aging fast. Is this a keeper league?

no, not a keeper

[freeVICK]

I would possibly do it. I don't live it, but I like it. It's pricey, but it's a nice upgrade in batting average from Reynolds to Youk. I think Sanchez will have a nice year and could drive in a similar number like Youk, but Dunn shouldn't suck forever?

lol i hope not. dunn, reynolds, cargo are absolutely killing my team. thought i would be cleaning up in the HR department, but im not even close