Understand the trend. . .

[WinningSince86]

They all have sucked or extremely overrated:

Cam Newton
Donovan McNabb
Akili Smith
Warren Moon
Randal Cunningham
Dante Cullpeper
Mike Vick
Byron Leftwich
Charlie Batch
Spurgen Wynn
Jamarcus Russell
EJ Manuel
Thaddeus Lewis
Teddy Bridgewater
Seneca Wallace
Tarvaris Jackson
Josh Freeman
Terrell Pryor
Aaron Brooks
Marcus Vick
Rodney Pete
Steve McNair
Jason Campbell
Kordel Stewart


Majority of African american are not good quarterbacks. Always overrated.

Thoughts?

[SamDiamond]

Cunningham and Moon were good QBs.

[WinningSince86]

Good but overrated and never won.

[SamDiamond]

Good but overrated and never won.

Dan Marino never won.

Jim Kelly never won.

Fran Tarkenton never won.

Dan Fouts never won.

Great QBs sometimes just don't win a Super Bowl.

[WinningSince86]

Ya didn't have IT factor.

Lol.

This is just in relevance to all the black qbs that are always picked high, wasted on, and overrated.

[GunShard]

Doug Williams was the black quarterback to win a super bowl.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doug_Williams_%28American_football%29

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_XXII

[paco]

Doug Williams was the black quarterback to win a super bowl.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doug_Williams_%28American_football%29

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_XXII

Who led them there before getting injured?

[DrunkHorseplayer]

Jay Schroeder.

[Riceboi]

Russell Wilson? But he's mixed I guess.

[jtoler]

Half of those guys were good or average, make a list with white qbs.

[TiredPro]

African Americans ?? Call them what they are.......Black or Negroes.

[Renegades]

Warren Moon is the only one worth a lick.

A GM should never and I mean never, draft a black QB to be the franchise QB

[jtoler]

OP is a clown obviously you dont know any of those guys on that list. Im willing to bet you simply went to google and typed "black NFL quarterbacks".

[WinningSince86]

I know every single qb.

[jtoler]

Could ask about alot of those on list but how does Warren Moon suck or is overrated? Robbed of 6 years having to play in Canada, while there not only played in Grey Cup first 5 years, but won it his first 5 years in CFL. 7th on all-time list for NFL qb yardage despite missing 6 years to CFL, 1990 NFL Offensive Player of the Year, 9-time Pro Bowler, 2006 NFL Hall of Fame inductee.

[WinningSince86]

Whatever. Warren Moon. Overrated. He isn't even a top 50 qb.

[GT21Megatron]

They all have sucked or extremely overrated:

Cam Newton
Donovan McNabb
Akili Smith
Warren Moon
Randal Cunningham
Dante Cullpeper
Mike Vick
Byron Leftwich
Charlie Batch
Spurgen Wynn
Jamarcus Russell
EJ Manuel
Thaddeus Lewis
Teddy Bridgewater
Seneca Wallace
Tarvaris Jackson
Josh Freeman
Terrell Pryor
Aaron Brooks
Marcus Vick
Rodney Pete
Steve McNair
Jason Campbell
Kordel Stewart


Majority of African american are not good quarterbacks. Always overrated.

Thoughts?

What about RG-Me?

Tony Carter
Rodney Pete
Andre Ware

[WinningSince86]

Oh ya.

Rg is number one.

Just copy paste and keep adding.

Can't believe I forgot that bum.

[GT21Megatron]

Oh ya.

Rg is number one.

Just copy paste and keep adding.

Can't believe I forgot that bum.

Tony Carter
Andre Ware
Rodney Pete

[jtoler]

I forgot, he instrumented The Comeback, a game I was watching with my dad, my dad fell asleep at halftime, I watched the entire game, when he woke up I told him the Oilers won, he was like whatever knock it off, then he saw the highlights and couldnt believe it.

[GT21Megatron]

Pat White
Marcus Vick
Dennis Dixon

[WinningSince86]

I named guys off my head.

Over Warren Moon talk. I would never take him as a franchise quarterblack.

[slacker00]

Cam is 31-24-3 ATS in the NFL. Let's not overreact to one game.

[I/O]

Trent Dilfer

[jjgold]

2 reasons

inability to read defenses in nfl
inaccurate arms

[lakerboy]

Mcnair was pretty good.

[I/O]

in case someone starts a thread about virgins, I got a head start...

Tim Tebow

[kidcudi92]

[House]

I can make a list 3 miles long with sorry ass white QBs .... keeping it real ..

[tb1984]

They all have sucked or extremely overrated:

Cam Newton
Donovan McNabb
Akili Smith
Warren Moon
Randal Cunningham
Dante Cullpeper
Mike Vick
Byron Leftwich
Charlie Batch
Spurgen Wynn
Jamarcus Russell
EJ Manuel
Thaddeus Lewis
Teddy Bridgewater
Seneca Wallace
Tarvaris Jackson
Josh Freeman
Terrell Pryor
Aaron Brooks
Marcus Vick
Rodney Pete
Steve McNair
Jason Campbell
Kordel Stewart


I'm not racist, but Majority of African american are not good quarterbacks. Always overrated.

Thoughts?

You're missing a cliche.

[blackHIPPY]

ok, now lets list all the shitty white quarterbacks..

[edawg]

It is because they are put at QB at the high school level being the best athlete and it continues to college level. In the NFL everyones a stud and they can't adjust. Has nothing to do with race if you put Edelman at QB you would get the same results.

[RickyRoma]

lol this thread seems kind of racist lol i mean there are some good QBs that are black smfh come on now

[Dollars2Donuts]

Straight up, the OP may be being a dikk about IT, but he is almost right.

Warren Moon of course was a terrific QB, to say that he wasn't just proves that you are either stupid or you just never watched him run a game. He was a leader, he was accurate and he could read defenses. Now, did he ever win the SB? No. But, he never had a atacked team around him and in those days there were some pretty fantastic teams out there (Niners anyone?).

Now, the rest of the bunch I happen to agree with. Cunningham was ok and fun to watch scramble around, but even at his best he was never a top 15 QB in the league. In my opinion McNabb was always a system guy and was an average guy at best, McNair was very overrated, RGIII will never have another year like his rookie year and will be out of the league by 30 (I predicted this after his first season) and Mike Vick....well Mike Vick was close and exciting, but he would never have led a team to the promised land.

I honestly believe different people, races, sexes and people from different cultures and backgrounds are better at certain things. Is the aveeage black male a better athlete than the average white or Hispanic male? I think so. Are men better at sports than women? Yes...and that isn't just in sports where you need to be big and fast. How about billiards? Women should be able to compete with men in an even level there, and it won't happen. There are a million examples of this and I could literally keep naming them all night, but I digress.

Is it a stretch to think that a white male may think in a more strategic way, especially under pressure, than a black male? I don't see why not. It certainly isn't a racist thing. It certainly isn't an 'intelligence' thing or an 'education' thing. I believe that, while it cannot be proven, this may be the ultimate truth....and I don't see anything wrong with it.

Anyway, I prefer to look at people that bring this stuff up in a neutral light, for even if they are doing it to stir shit up, they may just end up starting a healthy conversation.


Cheers

[I/O]

I know this is "big picture" thinking and doesn't go over well for the A/D/D youth of the forum....

It's a little more than BLACK and WHITE

I get the cultural differences (strengths AND weaknesses). I'm gonna go ahead and say many of the black qb's, ESPECIALLY the more athletic, do not have the same expectations or go through the same game planning as white qb's. Many just can't do what white qb's can, and vice versa. But a great number of them, if trained and drilled from childhood in the same game plan as any great white qb, could do the same thing.