Who's more Overrated Manning, Brady or Brees?

[k13]

Put these Clowns on the Browns and they never win anything EVER.

Why does Brees shit his pants on the road so bad against crap competition all the time?

I'd almost rather have Alex Smith.....

[broadway6]

I'm sure u rather have Kaepeenick too.

[tto827]

Alex Smith is the definition of only good on a good team.

Peyton had the Colts as a super bowl contender (or close) remove him and the team won 2 games.... I'd say he can do it himself.

Brady... who is catching balls for him besides Gronk this year, might as well be some little middle schoolers.

Rams D is good and owns Brees.

I'll take any of these three over anyone but Aaron Rodgers.

[El Nino]

Brees. His stats are inflated from blowouts at home. Mediocre road QB.

[You mad bro]

Kaepernick

[sneakerhead]

Brees

[Ghenghis Kahn]

i'm glad you didn't mention aaron rodgers.

he is the true mvp

[Coach Potato]

lol how much did u have on the saints? cmon man still plenty of time left lol

[InTheDrink]

apparently op thinks there is one good qb in the nfl

[HockeyRocks]

Manning by a large margin over either Brees or Brady..

[k13]

lol how much did u have on the saints? cmon man still plenty of time left lol

Nothing.

I have Brees in a big fantasy playoff game.

[k13]

i'm glad you didn't mention aaron rodgers.

he is the true mvp

I'd rather have Rodgers too...

[jjgold]

K13 you lost a bet and now going nuts

All great

[ZIPPER HEAD]

Brady and Bree'sBree's

[easyliving]

Brady has been winning for years with a bunch of nobodies and average defenses. When he has a good receiver (ex. Moss) guy puts over the top numbers. When was the last time Brady had a deep ball thread? I'd question your sports IQ for calling one of the best if not the best QB of all time overrated.

[easyliving]

K13 you lost a bet and now going nuts

All great

sums it up. Posters always looking for someone to attack after being on the wrong side of a bet.

[k13]

3 points against the pathetic Rams....

Its a dome, what excuse can you have?

This fucken clown was 2nd in MVP odds....

[thebestthereis]

there is 5 guys burgers which i heard is pretty good, then there is three guys overrated thread once you get buried by one or more of them in the same week. that's what this is.

[Deol]

Doesn't STL always get-up for divisional home games? Im going up against Brees and Graham and am loving it!!!

[ChiLLx]

Brees is the ultimate state padder. How many times do the Saints throw garbarge time TDs at home when they're already up 28-10. And the final ends up being 42-10.

This guy sucks in any remotely hostile road venue. Only year they went to the Super Bowl they had two dome HOME games in a row. Every other year in the playoffs he chokes as hard as Manning.

I'm not sure why this guy always gets a pass.

[frostno98]

Dude your just a f...king idiot just because you lost your bet taking all of them this week. None of them are over rated, those 3 QB's probably covered more games in their NFL career. Get off the crack pipe already.

[ThaTopMoron]

Put these Clowns on the Browns and they never win anything EVER.

Why does Brees shit his pants on the road so bad against crap competition all the time?

I'd almost rather have Alex Smith.....

Brees

easiest question in history

folded like a pansy without Payton last year

[ChiLLx]

Look at Brees down 18 late, game is over down 3 scores, still tossing it into the endzone to pad the stat meter

[Luckycharms2012]

Brees

[thunderous]

from what i just saw I would have to say Tony Romo....lol

[Kermit]

Neither they are elite quarterbacks.

[k13]

This Packers comeback makes up for all these Clowns.
Nice job Brees.


Brady > Manning > Brees


Really interesting if this clown shows something in Carolina.
Panthers only -3 is a decent sign.

[k13]

Alex Smith 23 td's 6 int's 91 qb rating
Tom Brady 23 td's 10 int's 88.1 qb rating

K.C. has more wins too....

[Rangers901]

Brady has been winning for years with a bunch of nobodies and average defenses. When he has a good receiver (ex. Moss) guy puts over the top numbers. When was the last time Brady had a deep ball thread? I'd question your sports IQ for calling one of the best if not the best QB of all time overrated.

Enough of this foolishness. Brady winning for years with nobodies? That statement shows your lack of knowledge.

The Pats win 3 SB's with top 3 defences and Brady as a game manager. Once he loses those top 3 defences, and he's forced to be more, guess how many rings the Pats have?

Notice how since not having a top 3 defence, the Pats win in the regular season but always lose in the playoffs, why? Because they're finally forced to face good competition rather than the garbage dump of a division they play in. Any decent team would make the playoffs every year in that division.

The argument that Brady does it with nobodies has sailed, it's gone. Up until this year everyone says he does it with nobodies, then when he actually has a team full of nobodies like this year, we see how great he truly is.

The Brady love may be one of the most media driven hyped bullshit ever. We are talking about check down Tom, Mr. I throw a slant route 95% of the time. I would bet my entire existence that no QB in the last 10 seasons has more YAC than Brady, and it won't be close.

Do people know what Brady's completion percentage on passes over 15 yards? It's downright pitiful.

We judge QB's by rings, and that's simply wrong. Football requires a 52 man roster, not 1. Without a top 3 defence, Brady has done absolutely nothing but get outplayed by the likes of Plummer, Eli Manning, Sanchez, etc. in the playoffs.

I can't wait until Brady is done, another average Joe comes in, starts putting up numbers, and then people will realize he was just an average Joe placed into a great system.

Patriots lose Brady, enter Matt Cassell, Mr. I haven't started a game since high school, they go 11-5.
Colts lose Manning, enter numerous mediocre QB's, they go 2-14.

Some people are lazy to do research, and some choose not to see what's true. There's a lot more I've done regarding this subject. I'm not a Brady hater, I'm a realist, and reality is, those 3 rings make Brady appear to be something he isn't, because had Bledsoe still been the starter, it would have been the same result.

[TheMoneyShot]

Brees. They are all good QB's. But if you think about it... if a defense is set in... I mean... RED HOT. Locked in... I don't think you could shut down Tom Brady. You clearly can shutdown Manning and Brees. I've yet to ever see a defense totally dismantle Brady.

[Rangers901]

Brees. They are all good QB's. But if you think about it... if a defense is set in... I mean... RED HOT. Locked in... I don't think you could shut down Tom Brady. You clearly can shutdown Manning and Brees. I've yet to ever see a defense totally dismantle Brady.

Well, you do realize the hardest pass to defend is the slant route, and Brady throws it about 95% of the time. And that's ridiculous, you do realize that since not having a top 3 defence he's been outplayed by almost every QB he's faced in the playoffs.

[sneakerhead]

Well, you do realize the hardest pass to defend is the slant route, and Brady throws it about 95% of the time. And that's ridiculous, you do realize that since not having a top 3 defence he's been outplayed by almost every QB he's faced in the playoffs.

Lol where did you get that 95% figure from? Would love to see your source

[Ghenghis Kahn]

Brees. They are all good QB's. But if you think about it... if a defense is set in... I mean... RED HOT. Locked in... I don't think you could shut down Tom Brady. You clearly can shutdown Manning and Brees. I've yet to ever see a defense totally dismantle Brady.

c'mon pal, only way brady won his rings was from that shitty tuck rule and the other one from spy gate.

you're forgetting billadick's famous quote, "if you're not cheating, you're trying."

only way the pats and brady can win.

not sure why people think he is an unstoppable qb.

you're forgetting the giants that barely made the playoffs beat them not once but twice in the super bowl.

how quickly we forget...

[greenhippo]

Only one of those guys have a losing playoff record.

[cockblocker]

Doesn't STL always get-up for divisional home games? Im going up against Brees and Graham and am loving it!!!

They are not in the same division.