Who is most overrated QB in NFL?

[15805]

RGIII
Ryan
Vick

But after today I don't think they'll be overated anymore, even there fan clubs realize they are not too good.

[DoYouNotGetIT]

RGIII
Ryan
Vick

But after today I don't think they'll be overated anymore, even there fan clubs realize they are not too good.

I don't remember anyone raving about Ryan or Vick this year.

[Maverick22]

Tom Brady might be the most over rated. I would personally add in Eli Manning and Andrew Luck.

[Maverick22]

Joe Flacco too.

[DoYouNotGetIT]

Tom Brady might be the most over rated. I would personally add in Eli Manning and Andrew Luck.

Joe Flacco too.

Eli Manning, I cannot go there since he won 2 Super Bowls. I see the argument, but the 2012 postseason run was spectacular QB play. Not saying the argument cannot be made. 2008 Super Win they had a awful receiving core. They had Plaxico Burress who was still great and Amani Toomer who was old and was done with football. I remember when Philadelphia got Steve Smith and they hyped him up as a great WR. Literally he shouldn't have been in the NFL and between Philli and St Louis in two seasons he got 250 yards. Then had to retire in 2013.


Joe Flacco is underrated or rated just right. Most people say he is a mediocre QB. Ravens might have a horrible team until 2017, because that contract is constructed in a way that he has to be their starter until 2017.

If you are constantly criticized you are not overrated.

[Fidel_CashFlow]

yeah Eli Manning winning those Super Bowls eliminates his name from the list completely.

Has never been considered one of the best overall quarterbacks anyways.

Not sure how the "overrated" tag could relate to him

[DoYouNotGetIT]

yeah Eli Manning winning those Super Bowls eliminates his name from the list completely.

Has never been considered one of the best overall quarterbacks anyways.

Not sure how the "overrated" tag could relate to him

The people against that argument would argue he is a mediocre regular season QB. I completely disagree with this, but that is what they will say.

Give me Eli Manning over Peyton Manning. Eli Manning will win me a Super Bowl and Peyton Manning won't unless he plays against Rex Grossman.

I am taking Brees then Eli Manning then Brady if going to build a team to win a Super Bowl.

If I was a GM who wanted to keep my job Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, and Brees.

[EmpireMaker]

Eli Manning, Joe Flacco , Rivers

[tony_come]

Carson Palmer

[JMobile]

Rivers. The guy is taking San Diego for a troll ride

[Ropmac]

Big Ben (?)

... For real: Ryan, Rivers and Palmer.

[The Kraken]

Agree with Rivers but he has a shitty team around him so maybe that's why he's losing.

My darkhorse is Russell Wilson. Guy has the best RB in the NFL behind him and probably the best defense to back him up. He gets a ton of credit because his team wins but a lot of those wins go to Lynch and the D. Not him.

Now with that said, he's not terrible, maybe even he's good but he's certainly overrated because of how well the Seahawks have done lately.

[cutter341975]

Aaron Rodgers..overrated.

[Hot Jerry]

Vick the prick from Philly and his older brother from Denver Payton - lol !! Both worthless by my humble opinion !! Payton and the Broncos will be out of playoffs in first or the second round !!

[nexus13]

He would indeed be on top of the list

[Deuce]

Pretty sure we covered all 32 QB's. Great work.

[ZetaPsi808]

Pretty sure we covered all 32 QB's. Great work.

[Hot Jerry]

Pretty sure we covered all 32 QB's. Great work.

-- LOL - good one !!

[cutter341975]

Aaron Rodgers

[ThaTopMoron]

right now???

R.Wilson

[cutter341975]

Aaron Rodgers

[Marigold HD]

Vick

Freeman

[Goat Milk]

Rivers

[RonPaul2008]

Kaepernick

The fact that you even say that means he is now underrated. They are missing Crabtree and Manningham and they are still winning. I'll take Kaepernick over any NFC QB except Rodgers and Brees.

[slacker00]

Tom Brady is NFL's best QB, Ben Roethlisberger says

[RonPaul2008]

Tom Brady is NFL's best QB, Ben Roethlisberger says

Career wise, yes. This year, however, Rodgers is the best QB in the NFL.

[Big Bear]

Ryan?
Rivers?
Cutler?

My guess is MATT RYAN

Eli Manning.

End of thread.

[konck]

Geno Jets fans saw him a the guy ....even Tebow is better the guy is a human turnover toilet

[cutter341975]

Aaron Rodgers

[cutter341975]

Freeman...as in Josh..haha wtf??---hes actually rated??

[KiDBaZkiT]

Anyone who says Romo is overrated do us all a favor and walk across the freeway. Romo is known for choking. ESPN analyst rip him for not winning big games and former Cowboys do as well in the media. Nobody thinks he is Top tier talent. NFL network, any radio program says he can't win the big game and rightfully so.

You know who's \*\*\*\*\*\* ass name I didn't read TOM BRADY!!!
What has he done since they got busted cheating??? Lost 2 Superbowls cuz they didn't have tape a the other teams signals and couldn't even throw up 20 pts in a Superbowl you got two weeks to prepare for??? Fukkin joke. Love how they went 16-0 blew the doors off the whole league then when it mattered most, a 17-14 loss to Eli Manning. The magnitude of Brady's losing seconds only Jim Kelley. Last year's AFC championship, LMAO. The 3 rings Belichecks cheating got pretty boy mean nothing to me.

[stevenash]

Missing the obvious.

Tony Romo

NOT THIS SEASON

18 TD passes, third most in the NFL
2216 passing yardage, top 5
Only thrown 5 picks, and has a 101 rating.

He's a top 5 QB this season so far behind Peyton, Rivers (who is having a career year),Brees, Rodgers.
Brady is have a down season.

Romo is a very, very good regular season QB, that has unexplained strange things happen to him in the playoffs, but Romo ain't overrated, nor underrated, he's not an elite, but he's solid.

This coming from a lifelong G-Man fan too.

[KiDBaZkiT]

Peyton Manning, Drew Breese, Eli Manning, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers, Joe Flacco all won Super Bowls more recently than Tom Brady.

[cutter341975]

hmmmm...Romo...right where he needs to be..not over..not under--- Brady..somewhere in the top 10.---like 7-8

[cutter341975]

Aaron Rodgers