Who is most overrated QB in NFL?

[stevenash]

Peyton Manning, Drew Breese, Eli Manning, Ben Roethlisberger, Aaron Rodgers, Joe Flacco all won Super Bowls more recently than Tom Brady.

Ya, I respect everything Brady has done across the years, I was never a fan, doesn't mean I am saying he sucks, does not, just don't like him is all.

Brady will see Canton, first round easily, but looking at it level headed, will probably never sniff a Super Bowl game again, he's getting old real fast, and Patriots have gone from an elite team, to a better than average team in less than two years, and might need four years to get back to the elite tier again.

What I just said also applies to both Eli Manning and his New York Giants too.

[cutter341975]

Aaron Rodgers

[Speedy88]

Matt Ryan and RG3.

[cutter341975]

Aaron Rodgers

[Stevedore]

Matt Ryan
Jay Cutler

[cutter341975]

Id say....the cutest ones are always overated..and there are some cute ones.

u for real dude?

[SteveRyan]

I love this thread.

Every QB in the NFL has been mentioned. I guess they are all over-rated then.

To me, the most over-rated QB BY FAR is Tony Romo.

People have been trying for years to categorize this guy as an elite QB; but what has he really done??

2006 season - He fumbled the snap against Seattle and lost the NFC Wild Card Playoff.
2007 season - Lost the division playoff game to the Giants
2008 season - Lost to Philly in the playoffs 44-6 with 3 turnovers (Sound familiar?)
2009 season - Was sacked 6 times with 3 fumbles and lost to the Vikings 34-3 in an NFC divisional game.
2010 season - Replaced by John Kitna because he broke his clavicle.
2011 season - Missed the playoffs after losing in week 16 to the Giants 31-14
2012 season - Missed the playoffs again.

[imadegen]

Mark Sanchez.

[dmncnlou]

Luck. Guy has no arm strength. He can't make all the throws.

[Stevedore]

Luck. Guy has no arm strength. He can't make all the throws.

[Goat Milk]

Ya, I respect everything Brady has done across the years, I was never a fan, doesn't mean I am saying he sucks, does not, just don't like him is all.

Brady will see Canton, first round easily, but looking at it level headed, will probably never sniff a Super Bowl game again, he's getting old real fast, and Patriots have gone from an elite team, to a better than average team in less than two years, and might need four years to get back to the elite tier again.

What I just said also applies to both Eli Manning and his New York Giants too.

Eli Manning not even in the same league as Brady. Just look at the numbers and resume. Peyton not even in same league as Brady either. Manning only had 1 season in his whole career with single digit interceptions... That's pathetic. Manning only plays for stats. That's why he can't do shit in the postseason when it matters.

He choked last year against Baltimore. Needed 2 kickoff return tds to stay ahead in that game.

[stevenash]

To me, the most over-rated QB BY FAR is Tony Romo.

People have been trying for years to categorize this guy as an elite QB; but what has he really done??

He's not elite, a very, very good regular season QB

59-42 regular season record as a starter says so
2:1 TD to INT ratio says so
96.1 QB rate (which is very high) says so

He is what he is, a really good regular season QB
Not overrated, not underrated.

[stevenash]

Eli Manning not even in the same league as Brady. Just look at the numbers and resume. Peyton not even in same league as Brady either. Manning only had 1 season in his whole career with single digit interceptions... That's pathetic. Manning only plays for stats. That's why he can't do shit in the postseason when it matters.

He choked last year against Baltimore. Needed 2 kickoff return tds to stay ahead in that game.

Why don't you reread my post again, then comment.

Not comparing Eli and Brady

I am saying Eli and the Giants, like Brady and the Pats will probably never see another Super Bowl
I am saying Eli is getting old fast, like Brady is getting old fast.
I am saying Eli and Brady are both on downsides of terrific careers.

YEEESH

[cutter341975]

the guys with the biggest penis.

WHAT does THAT have to do with QB??

[greenhippo]

Can we please keep this sports related guys?

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Manning's brother
/thread

[Big Bear]

Collin Kaepernick

This guys throwing motion makes me cringe.

its almost as akward looking as Tim Tebows

[GunShard]

Matt Ryan and Colin Kaepernick.

[Hot Jerry]

M A N N I N G - by mile - in mile high !!

[tony_come]

Peyton manning

[thechaoz]

Matt Ryan and Colin Kaepernick.

Kaep is rated, not overrated

I'd say flacco

[Parligod]

Matt Ryan is a good one, as is Cutler. His backup QB did solid I kind of think they should've passed on Cutler to save some money. Also hate to say it but Kaepernick until he learns to go through his progressions and not automatically throw to somebody no matter what - that alone is the key reason he had 2 interceptions in the 4th vs. Seattle.

Last one - Wilson doesn't impress me yet. He's pure game manager and no impressive games. He could've been called on intentional grounding 3x vs. 49ers and got lucky he only had one called against him. I'll be more impressed when I see him push the offense when offense is needed. Seattle rarely needs to call on him for big drives.

[Big Bear]

Ryan?
Rivers?
Cutler?

My guess is MATT RYAN

Ryan Tannenhill, Matt Ryan, or Christian Ponder.

[thechaoz]

Rg3..people are on to romo now.. Wanning exposed when they play a real d

Bumping another sharp post. You guys catching on yet? I know my shit

[packerd_00]

You cannot be overrated if you are constantly getting criticism so Tony Romo, Phillip Rivers, Jay Cutler, Christian Ponder, and Matt Ryan.

Matthew Stafford is my most overrated QB.

I agree on Stafford,wholeheartedly

[manny24]

Aaron Rodgers

if he didn't eat his corn-on-the-cob the loooooong way you wouldn't say that

best skinripper QB in the league right now