Who is most overrated QB in NFL?

[Deuce]

Ryan?
Rivers?
Cutler?

My guess is MATT RYAN

[lakerboy]

RG3

[t-wizzle]

Matt Ryan is up there. No arm strength and not very mobile.

[Carseller4]

Missing the obvious.

Tony Romo

[Deuce]

RG3

Good submission. It does appear he is washed up.

[bubblebuttluv]

Joe Flacco

And by that I mean ESPN tries to rate him highly because he won a Super Bowl and had artificial numbers in the playoffs (Boldin had to make circus catches all the time every game) so he is overrated.

Ryan may very well be second.

[pavyracer]

Josh Freeman

[t-wizzle]

Joe Flacco

And by that I mean ESPN tries to rate him highly because he won a Super Bowl and had artificial numbers in the playoffs (Boldin had to make circus catches all the time every game) so he is overrated.

Ryan may very well be second.

Flacco is most underrated. Big arm and did pretty damn good in crunchtime last year. I want a guy who can play with that kind of poise in the big moments.

[bubblebuttluv]

Flacco is most underrated. Big arm and did pretty damn good in crunchtime last year. I want a guy who can play with that kind of poise in the big moments.

Most underrated? come on, guy.

If we are going most underrated, it would have to be either Russell Wilson or Andrew Luck.

People try to shit on Wilson every week and all he does is win.

[Deuce]

Joe Flacco

And by that I mean ESPN tries to rate him highly because he won a Super Bowl and had artificial numbers in the playoffs (Boldin had to make circus catches all the time every game) so he is overrated.

Ryan may very well be second.

That reason right there he can't be overrated. Guy won a SB.

[InTheDrink]

RG3

do people think he's good?

[lakerboy]

Good submission. It does appear he is washed up.

Lol. He won't amount to much.

[t-wizzle]

Most underrated? come on, guy.

If we are going most underrated, it would have to be either Russell Wilson or Andrew Luck.

People try to shit on Wilson every week and all he does is win.

You're joking right? Wilson? And Luck? All we ever hear about is Andrew Luck these days. I think Luck is overrated.

[VegasInsider]

Matt Ryan

[lakerboy]

do people think he's good?

Some do. He had good numbers last year. Only threw 5 picks. Lot of hype about him. Let's give him 3 years for his knee to be 100%.

[lakerboy]

You're joking right? Wilson? And Luck? All we ever hear about is Andrew Luck these days. I think Luck is overrated.

Bro stop. Luck is the next great all time qb. He is a winner.

[Ghenghis Kahn]

brady

/thread

[t-wizzle]

Bro stop. Luck is the next great all time qb. He is a winner.

I'm not sold yet.

[bubblebuttluv]

That reason right there he can't be overrated. Guy won a SB.

so did Trent Dilfer.

[Brock Landers]

Cutler

Never won a thing in his life...outside of HS

[ksnooksk]

brady

/thread

WTF?


Obvious answer is Matt Ryan.

[Brock Landers]

When's the last time Tony Romo won a playoff game????

[sneakerhead]

Manning
/thread

[GoCougs!]

Rgiii

[broadway6]

has to be Romo. he needs to win a few playoff games...

[nvrlose37]

Matt Ryan by far. Also throw Mike Vick in there.

Rivers has been playing much better this year to avoid the distinction

[The Kraken]

Some here don't seem to understand what overrated meaNs

Anyone can qualify as overrated at any time regardless of their accolades or stats. Even the best qb could be overrated.

[pulledclear]

V

I

C

K

And its not even close.

[zizoudane10]

V

I

C

K

And its not even close.

This! He never learned to read defenses. Sorry, but that's a fact. Great athlete, but definitely overrated QB.

[Popcorn Trick]

Vick might be a good answer. I don't worry about overrated QB's necessarily, but I seek out terrible QB's like Ponder and Gabbert and attack!

[J_smiff]

I'm not sold yet.

Should probably open your eyes

[J_smiff]

Kaepernick

[manny24]

brady

/thread

reported

[thechaoz]

Rg3..people are on to romo now.. Wanning exposed when they play a real d

[DoYouNotGetIT]

You cannot be overrated if you are constantly getting criticism so Tony Romo, Phillip Rivers, Jay Cutler, Christian Ponder, and Matt Ryan.

Matthew Stafford is my most overrated QB.