Well, Looks Like It's Time To Amend Our College Football "Playoff" System.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Eddy Munny
    Benched
    • 08-13-13
    • 15769

    #1
    Well, Looks Like It's Time To Amend Our College Football "Playoff" System.
    Assuming Baylor and FSU hold on for the win, you'll have six legitimate teams deserving of a top 4 ranking. Obviously somebody is going to get snubbed... which is what these "playoffs" were designed to avoid.

    Although it's an improvement over the former system, it's a misnomer to even call it the playoffs when we all know it's really just one additional game. Now you have the committee's nightmare scenario unfolding, where FSU may narrowly escape once again, Baylor and TCU continue to look dominant, and Ohio St. absolutely smokes Wisconsin with what is essentially a third string quarterback.

    Although this format keeps college football abuzz with intrigue, you probably need a six team eight team playoff to put the kibosh on this nonsense. Then, nobody gets left out. If you're the unfortunate team who finishes ninth in the poll, tough cookies... you gotta draw the line somewhere.
  • BigDofBA
    SBR Posting Legend
    • 09-30-09
    • 19313

    #2
    Agreed. Way better than the BCS but it needs to be 8 teams.

    Make the power conferences champions get an auto bid so you can win your way in. Then have three at large spots.

    The Big 12 should get left out BC they don't have a championship game. This "sharing" conference titles thing is crap.
    Comment
    • Eddy Munny
      Benched
      • 08-13-13
      • 15769

      #3
      The problem with an eight team playoff is that it's probably over-inclusive and somewhat diminishes the value of the regular season, i.e. this year's Mississippi St./Ole Miss game doesn't quite carry as much drama if the Bulldogs sneak into an eight team playoff format.

      On the other hand, I believe most years you will have 5-6 teams that have a legitimate claim to be included in the playoffs... so perhaps have a play-in game, a la the NCAA hoops tournament? Or maybe even a six-team playoff with the top two seeds receiving byes.
      Comment
      • teecee
        SBR Hall of Famer
        • 09-18-09
        • 6308

        #4
        I have said im for an 8-team playoff, but it's probably better for the ncaa to have a playoff with a couple less spots than they need than a couple more. Controversy creates interest.
        Comment
        Search
        Collapse
        SBR Contests
        Collapse
        Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
        Collapse
        Working...