A superior NFL analyst knows MARINO not a top 20 QB all-time

[Fishhead]

[RonPaul2008]

Marino is the most overrated QB of all time.

[Thunder Gulch]

Marino is the most overrated QB of all time.

Nope, that would be Joe Namath, or currently Eli Manning.

[Fishhead]

Marino is the most overrated QB of all time.

Probably

[ttwarrior1]

how old is this fishhead, must be another 21 year old , marino would win 9 superbowls if playing now

[will2survive]

Joe Namath is the most overrated QB of all time. He's totally lived off of his Broadway Joe lifestyle and guarantee win in Super Bowl III

[lakerboy]

Joe Namath is the most overrated QB of all time. He's totally lived off of his Broadway Joe lifestyle and guarantee win in Super Bowl III

well he guaranteed it and came thru. coming thru was something marino was never know for.


marino was 8-10 in playoff games and will always be remembered by me as the guy who was blown off the field by the jaguars in his last game 62-7

[Domestic]

[ebbearsfb1]

Good catch laker boy... that game was uglllllyyyyy ... blow outcity

[Chi_archie]

I agree that Namath is over-rated

but i'd say you could make a VERY good argument that Bradshaw was and is MORE over-rated

[3PtShooter]

marino and namath top notch NFL QB's just differnt circumstances for both. can tell most of ya never played the game

[Fishhead]

Bad leader with two flat tires.................could go on and on.

Not top 20 material

[Chi_archie]

greatest QB's came from Pennsylvania that we should all be able to agree upon

[seaborneq]

Physically marino is up there with the all time greats. Mentally, he is no better than jake Plummer, Neil o'donnell, and Brett farve.

[Chi_archie]

interesting quip seaborne

what is it to you that separates the physically great but mentally weak from the physically great AND mentally great?


going beyond that...

would you rather have a Dan Marino physically great mentally weak or proverbial physically weak (as a qb) but mentally great TIM TEBOW?

[Hotdiggity11]

Probably punched a hole through a wall when Brees broke his passing record.

[DOMINATER]

Hey fishead long time want to give you some coins. Just tried will do so tomorrow

[Mr Handicapable]

Marino was one of the greatest pure passers in NFL history. How else do you hold a record like that for almost 30 years? He didn't win that much in the playoffs because he was on a $HIT TEAM? They never gave him a running game or much of a defense. In fact Mark Clayton & Duper weren't anything special either? Most of you guys are action junkies and know absolutely nothing about the NFL.

[oiler]

everybody has his or her opinion but nobody will agree 100 per cent but he was one of the best in his time just that he had aloy of shitty teams he played on

[kmarinouofm]

Marino doesn't dumpster dive for his next meal ... So he is already doing better then most here

[seaborneq]

interesting quip seaborne

what is it to you that separates the physically great but mentally weak from the physically great AND mentally great?


going beyond that...

would you rather have a Dan Marino physically great mentally weak or proverbial physically weak (as a qb) but mentally great TIM TEBOW?

Give me the physical freak in marino anyday, over the mentally tough tebow any and every time. Tebow will win one big game marino will win 100 little ones

[jjgold]

He was very good

What heart him was his legs a little and no defense

[PAULYPOKER]

Fish you need to stick to pushing the button on them slot machines,you sure you and brah bull are not related?

[Fishhead]

Again, NO WHEELS and NO LEADERSHIP................automatic out of the TOP 2O material.


Love how people want to talk about him being a great passer, YES HE WAS, ONE IF NOT THE VERY BEST................this alone does not make you a top five QB.

[yisman]

Love how people want to talk about him being a great passer, YES HE WAS, ONE IF NOT THE VERY BEST................this alone does not make you a top five QB.

FISHHEAD, first you say top 20, now you say top five.

Whether he's top 5 is debatable. Whether he's top 20 is not.

You're all over the place here. Take one position and stick with it.

I bet if you polled your staff they'd agree that you've lost your marbles.

[kmarinouofm]

He was very good

What heart him was his legs a little and no defense

How about never having a True #1 wide receiver ?

or how about always having a middle of the pack running game?

Put Marino on the New Orleans Saints this year.. and he wins 3 super bowls..

FISHHEAD, first you say top 20, now you say top five.

Whether he's top 5 is debatable. Whether he's top 20 is not.

You're all over the place here. Take one position and stick with it.

I bet if you polled your staff they'd agree that you've lost your marbles.

Yeah he has no wheels.. However that was only late in his career.. after he blew out his knees playing for a team that never surrounded him with the talent he deserved...

not a leader? really? how the F would you really know that? U spend a lot of time in the locker room with him?

There is ZERO DOUBT... that MARINO is a TOP 20 QB... if you dont believe so .. that is fine... I dont believe half the shit i see on this forum anyway.. so why should i "believe" you actually "believe" this...

[yisman]

I think you quoted the wrong post.

[Fishhead]

FISHHEAD, first you say top 20, now you say top five.

Whether he's top 5 is debatable. Whether he's top 20 is not.

You're all over the place here. Take one position and stick with it.

I bet if you polled your staff they'd agree that you've lost your marbles.

That alone does not make you a TOP 20 qb...................quoted TOP FIVE because many here believe that should be an absolute given.

Not top 20 in my book

[mathdotcom]

I miss Webber's QB demonstrations in that office of his.

(Deuce could never catch a pass in them)

[yisman]

That alone does not make you a TOP 20 qb...................

Well then you should've said so. Big difference between top 20 and top 5.

[kmarinouofm]

I think you quoted the wrong post.

i sorta did... but i was meaning to agree with you.. fish is all over the place on this one

[Fishhead]

Many feel that MARINO was a better QB than Brett Favre.................not me.


Think many have the same sentiments as I do.



All in all, everyone has their subjective reasonings..............no right or wrong answers.


Hundreds rate MARINO best of alltime...........hundreds more will not put him in their top 20, or even top 40 for that matter.

With his great arm, I personally would have to find a spot somewhere in the TOP 40 for him............but certainly not higher than 20.

[RonPaul2008]

Steve Young, now that's one of the top QB's ever.

[Mr Handicapable]

Many feel that MARINO was a better QB than Brett Favre.................not me.


Think many have the same sentiments as I do.



All in all, everyone has their subjective reasonings..............no right or wrong answers.


Hundreds rate MARINO best of alltime...........hundreds more will not put him in their top 20, or even top 40 for that matter.

With his great arm, I personally would have to find a spot somewhere in the TOP 40 for him............but certainly not higher than 20.

Favre played with alot of great players over his career while Marino did not. Favre's 1st Vikings team with Peterson (great O-line) and everyone in their prime was one of the most talented teams I've seen in the last 10 years. Marino never had anything to work with remotely close to that. Warren Moon made a bunch of Pro-Bowls but racism kept him in the CFL til he was almost 30. Just way too many variables to compare QBs imo. I do know that Marino never made half the dumba$$ int's that Favre did.

[Mr Handicapable]

Steve Young, now that's one of the top QB's ever.

How did he do with Tampa? Look it up.....he was HORRIBLE. Big shocker here....he was a stud with the 49ers. Marino was a superstar ala Peyton Manning with average talent at best.