Top 5 Divisions in Boxing

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ian
    SBR Hall of Famer
    • 11-09-09
    • 6100

    #1
    Top 5 Divisions in Boxing
    In this thread I'm going to run down what I feel are the top 5 divisions in boxing. I'm going to do a write-up on one division at a time counting down from 5, and I'll throw in a rant on the worst division in boxing somewhere along the way. So to start off, here's #5.

    #5) Bantamweight (118 lbs.). The little guys deserve a lot more attention than they get. Not only does the Bantamweight division feature excellent boxing, but the guys at the top are action fighters who rarely disappoint the crowd and are all very evenly matched with each other. There's a pretty steep drop off in talent after the top tier, but within that top tier you get fight of the year candidates multiple times a year.

    The best of the bantams includes Japanese southpaw Hozumi Hasegawa; the only man in boxing with a straight left hand that rivals Manny Pacquaio's. His power is not limited to that one punch, but he throws it so hard and with such precision that when he connects he often sends opponents flying back horizontally across the ring (and on one occasion through the ring ropes). In his last fight he was upset by Fernando Montiel, an offensive minded veteran who compensates for a lack of speed with 1 punch KO power and highly intelligent in-ring tactics. Now that he has a belt, it remains to be seen whether Montiel will fight the other top bantams or whether he will hide out in Mexico collecting paychecks for defending his title against unqualified opponents.

    The rest of the best are Yohnny Perez, a slick boxer who will slug it out toe-to-toe when he has to. Perez had an absolute war with irrepressible brawler Joseph "King Kong" Agbeko last fall, and there's talk of a rematch in the works. Agbeko's biggest win came last summer against Vic Darchinyan, who was making his first appearance at bantamweight after collecting 3 of the 4 major belts in the super flyweight division. After returning to Super Fly for a year, Darchinyan is back at bantamweight and should fight for a major belt before the end of the year. The newest member of the crew is undefeated 24 year old Abner Mares, who recently fought the aforementioned Yohnny Perez to a draw.
  • Cookie Monster
    SBR MVP
    • 12-05-08
    • 2251

    #2
    Good roundup of the division. You forgot to mention two very good fighters, Nehomar Cermeño and Anselmo Moreno. Moreno won a controversial split decision to Cermeño, and a rematch is scheduled on august.

    Besides them, the best contender is Eric Morel, who has been scheduled many times to fight Montiel, but the fight has been postponed for injuries and monetary reasons. And last, Gerry Peñalosa is a dangerous veteran who still may have a few good fights left.
    Comment
    • Ian
      SBR Hall of Famer
      • 11-09-09
      • 6100

      #3
      Thanks for the compliment. The write-ups are, of course, completely subjective, and I left out the two Panamanians because in my eyes they just aren't very good in terms of either talent or entertainment value. I can't see either of them being much better than a 2: 1 dog against the guys I mentioned. Cermeno is the one I'm especially looking forward to fading. His stance is super wide, his jab seems totally ineffective, and his offense usually consists of bull-charging his opponent with haymakers. I think a guy like Hasegawa would break him in half. Of course, people can feel free to disagree... part of the reason I started the thread was to get some boxing talk going on around here.

      I agree with you that Morel and Penalosa are still good fighters. At 37 Penalosa will have to pack it in soon, though, and Morel is getting up there too. Morel also will always have to deal with fan negativity from his prison sentence for sexual assault a few years ago.

      I should have the next write-up done tomorrow.
      Comment
      • Cookie Monster
        SBR MVP
        • 12-05-08
        • 2251

        #4
        Cermeño is an interesting case. He was nobody until chosen to fight Cristian Mijares. I am sure the promoter chose Cermeño because he looked fairly easy to Mijares in his hometown comeback. But surprisingly Cermeño won a split decision, and then dominated Mijares in the rematch. Later Cermeño looked good KOing Alejandro Valdez in a difficult fight. And the loss vs. Moreno is generally accepted as a bad decision.

        So, he was beating easy opponents, and in the last 4 fights he has been very good. Maybe his skills are not so great, but he could be very difficult for anyone.
        Comment
        • GaryDN
          SBR Sharp
          • 05-08-10
          • 452

          #5
          Where are the heavy weights ? Two Russians and that's it???
          Comment
          • Ian
            SBR Hall of Famer
            • 11-09-09
            • 6100

            #6
            #4) Featherweight (126 lbs.) In a tough division Juan Manuel Lopez, Chris John, and Yuriorkis Gamboa are a cut above the rest. “JuanMa” Lopez is hugely popular, especially in his native Puerto Rico, and it's no surprise why. Sporting KO power in both hands and a tough chin, Lopez is a fighting champion, defending his title several times a year. After demolishing credible challenger Bernabe Concepcion last weekend, JuanMa will be back in the ring in mid-September, taking on powerful veteran Rafael Marquez. Famous in boxing circles for his wars with Israel Vazquez, at age 35 Marquez is probably now a half step behind the cream of the division, but there is probably no better example in the sport of a fighter with a “puncher's chance.” Boxing fans should do themselves a favor and watch this bout; it has Hagler vs. Hearns potential.


            While an entertaining fighter himself, 43-0-2 Chris John excels on speed and grace rather than raw power. A huge star in his native Indonesia, John prefers to fight from the outside, using footwork and agility to dodge punches while peppering his opponent with a blinding assault of jabs and an effective right hook.


            The final member of the Big 3, Yuriorkis Gamboa won an Olympic gold medal for Cuba in 2004 and has embarked on a path of destruction through the featherweight division since defecting to the US in December '06. In April '09 he gained his first world title belt, and he'll defend it for the 4th time in September in a unification bout against outclassed WBC title holder Elio Rojas.


            While there is a dropoff in talent after the top guys, there is a very viable 2nd class of featherweights. The best of the rest include the aforementioned Rafael Marquez and Panamanian veteran Celestino Caballero. Fans should also keep an eye out for Guillermo Rigondeaux, another Cuban defector and Olympic gold medalist who is probably only 3 or 4 fights away from a title shot himself.
            Comment
            • Grits n' Gravy
              Restricted User
              • 06-10-10
              • 13024

              #7
              Nice write ups. JMM is going to pick the battle worn Marquez apart though.
              Comment
              • Cookie Monster
                SBR MVP
                • 12-05-08
                • 2251

                #8
                Good recap. It is an intriguing division, as most top guys have clear flaws.

                Chris John is clearly the class of the pack. His boxing skills and speed makes him the most difficult fighter to beat in the division. However, his lack of power makes him candidate to get the short side of a disputed decision (as already happened vs. Rocky Juarez).

                Juanma Lopez has impressive power, but his chin and stamina are suspect. In his last fight he was dropped and hurt by Concepcion, and barely squeaked by Mtagwa. Until now, he has survived in part because the opposition has been a class or two below him. The next fight vs. Rafael Marquez is a big step up on class, and there he will show if he belongs to the top on the division.

                Yuriorkis Gamboa has an amateur pedigree, and his style shows it. In his first fights he was dropped a few times, but always came back to KO the opponent. He has shown good things, but is still untested at the top level. His next fight vs. Elio Rojas looks interesting.

                Celestino Caballero is not a step below Juanma and Yuriorkis. He is vastly underrated, I think he could beat anyone in the division. He is a tall and lanky boxer like Paul Williams, and like him, he does not use his reach advantage to fight from the outside. He has looked great in his last fights, excepting a fight vs Mathebula, where he was drained to make weight. He wants Juanma badly, but I doubt he will have a chance to fight him, at least while Juanma is unbeaten.

                Rafael Marquez is a question mark. A few years ago he would be on top of the division, now he may be at the slightly below of the top contenders. Still, if he survives the first rounds vs. Juanma, he may very well beat him, and return to the top.

                The other contenders are a steep drop off after the top 5. Orlando Salido, Elio Rojas, Daniel Ponce de Leon, Steven Luevano, Antonio Escalante, Jhonny Gonzalez and the untested orientals Chonlatarn Piriyapinyo and Ryol Li Lee.
                Comment
                • Ian
                  SBR Hall of Famer
                  • 11-09-09
                  • 6100

                  #9
                  Thanks for the feedback, CM. I agree with you big time on JuanMa's stamina... perhaps he's draining too much weight. I'm not as worried about his chin as a lot of fans; he looked off balance when Concepcion knocked him down and he was up on a 1 count. I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt. As a fan I like Caballero, the way he broke down Steve Molitor was impressive, but I'm not as big on him as you are. At 34 he's starting to get old, he has a tendency to walk right into punches, and I'm not impressed with his competition (especially Leal) after the SD win over Mathebula. Regardless, I'd love to see him get in the ring with any of the top featherweights. Caballero vs. John would be fantastic imo.
                  Comment
                  • Ian
                    SBR Hall of Famer
                    • 11-09-09
                    • 6100

                    #10
                    The Worst Division in Boxing) Minimumweight (105 lbs.) I'm taking a break from the countdown here to call out the dumbest division in boxing. Different alphabet groups call the division different names: minimumweight, strawweight, or mini flyweight; but I call it garbage. The division exists for no reason other than to add more money to the coffers of the so called sanctioning bodies.

                    The main problem with the division is the obvious one, the weight limit is too small. Boxers in the division need to severely dehydrate themselves to come in under the limit. This is evidenced by the fact that, unlike in every other division, fighters never come in at a pound or more under the weight limit... midgets don't even walk around at 105 pounds. So few fighters can even make such a small weight that minimumweight is the least populous division, only one division doesn't have double the number of boxers.

                    The problems with the division are exacerbated by the fact that the 2nd least populous division, junior flyweight, has a weight limit of only 107 pounds. The difference between the two weight classes is lunch, but because they are separated the best small fighters never get in the ring with each other. There are good fighters at those weights, WBO Jr. Flyweight champ Ivan Calderon and WBA Minimumweight champ Roman Gonzalez could put on a highly entertaining main event, but fans will never see it. With 8 major belts between the two most sparsely populated divisions in boxing, the best fighters continually defend their belts against unworthy mandatory challengers (with the alphabet groups getting a cut of the profits). If the divisions were combined the best fighters would be forced to get in the ring with each other, but it would mean less money for the WBA/WBC/IBF/WBO.

                    Combining the divisions would eliminate the health risks associated with minimumweights sweating off an extra two pounds, and it would for the first time give fans a reason to care about fights between sub 108 pound boxers. Until hell freezes over and the sanctioning bodies start to care about their fighters and fans, the minimumweight division will be the worst division in boxing... and junior flyweight will be the second worst.
                    Comment
                    • Cookie Monster
                      SBR MVP
                      • 12-05-08
                      • 2251

                      #11
                      Last time I checked, Jr. Flyweight limit was 108 pounds, not 107
                      Still, points well taken. The best minimumweight in history, Ricardo Lopez cleaned up the division easily. He had his last few fights at 108, and he was not as effective. Still, he was one of the best textbook boxers of all times, stained only by the low quality of the opposition (he fought all the best fighters on his division, the problem was the lack of quality minimumweights).
                      Comment
                      • phillybadboy
                        SBR Hall of Famer
                        • 12-11-09
                        • 9383

                        #12
                        140 pound division lots of guys all the same age, between 24 and 30, good age
                        Comment
                        • Cookie Monster
                          SBR MVP
                          • 12-05-08
                          • 2251

                          #13
                          On the other hand, I just love the way the little guys fight. As there are not much KO power, they are not afraid of exchanging punches all the way. Fights like Gonzalez-Sorjaturong and Sithchatchawal - Monshipour are impossible in the heavier weights.
                          Comment
                          • phillybadboy
                            SBR Hall of Famer
                            • 12-11-09
                            • 9383

                            #14
                            140 lbs division,guys thhat can fight at 140,mayweather, pacquiao, judah,alexander,ortiz,bradley,malinaggi, khan,maidana,urango,koltelnik, this division is loaded
                            Comment
                            Search
                            Collapse
                            SBR Contests
                            Collapse
                            Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                            Collapse
                            Working...