🏒 NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Predictions Today: Best Bets to Score for Tuesday, May 12
Last Updated: May 12, 2026 9:56 AM EDT • 3 minute read Google News Link
Tuesday features two critical second-round NHL playoff games: Sabres vs. Canadiens Game 4 and Ducks vs. Golden Knights Game 5.
My NHL anytime goal scorer predictions today target Nick Suzuki alongside two Vegas forwards to light the lamp. Combining all three NHL goal scorer picks gives us a parlay at +3263 odds.
🏒 NHL anytime goal scorer predictions today: May 12
See all of our experts' NHL picks based on the latest NHL odds.; picks rated on a 1-to-5 star confidence scale based on betting value.
| 💰 Anytime Goal Scorer | ⚖️ Bet size | 🧠 Why I'm making this bet |
|---|---|---|
| Nick Suzuki, Canadiens (+195 via bet365) | 0.2u -> 0.39u | Most consistent Canadiens star in series vs. Sabres. |
| Pavel Dorofeyev, Golden Knights (+185 via bet365) | 0.2u -> 0.37u | Tallied a high-danger shot in six of last seven playoff games. |
| Brett Howden, Golden Knights (+300 via bet365) | 0.2u -> 0.6u | Tied for postseason lead with seven goals. |
Total wagered: 0.60 units | Max profit: 1.36 units
📃 Affiliate disclosure
Sportsbook Review may receive a commission if you sign up through our links. Not intended for use in MA. Bonuses not applicable in Ontario. 21+ only. (Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)
🥅 Best anytime goal scorer pick today
Nick Suzuki (+195) vs. Sabres
Nick Suzuki has been the most consistent forward among Montreal's stars both throughout the playoffs and in this series versus the Sabres. He's finished with at least three shots on goal in four straight games and has scored in two of his last three outings.
The Canadiens' offense has caught fire against Buffalo, scoring 11 goals across Games 2 and 3. I expect that success to continue for Montreal in Game 4, and the team's captain is the most likely skater to contribute with a goal tonight.
I bet this at +195 odds, but there's value paying up to +180.
🔥 More NHL goal scorer picks
Pavel Dorofeyev (+185) vs. Ducks
Pavel Dorofeyev broke through with his first goal of the series in Game 4, a score on the man advantage for the power-play specialist.
But the Golden Knights forward has been generating solid scoring chances throughout this matchup. He's tallied a high-danger shot in six of his previous seven playoff games. That's why I'm backing Dorofeyev to score again versus the Ducks tonight at bet365's +185 odds.
Brett Howden (+300) vs. Ducks
It's incredible that I'm even targeting Brett Howden, a player who scored 12 goals during the regular season. But that's a testament to how strong his postseason has been.
Howden is tied for the playoff lead with seven goals and has scored in six of his last seven games entering Tuesday. Nearly all of his goals have been assisted by the red-hot Mitch Marner, an offensive combination that's driving Vegas right now. Our Gary Pearson targets a Marner assist as part of his best NHL player props today.
Given his recent play, Howden is certainly worth a wager at bet365's market-best +300 odds, but there's value up to +275.
🚀 Best NHL goal scorer parlay
Combining all three of my goal scorer picks for Tuesday gives us +3263 odds at bet365, the leading price among the best sports betting apps. The long odds demonstrate how difficult this will be to nail, so I'm only wagering 0.1 units.
💵 NHL goal scorer parlay picks
- Nick Suzuki (+195)
- Pavel Dorofeyev (+185)
- Brett Howden (+300)
Best odds: +3263 via bet365 (0.1u -> 3.3u)
💵 My betting record for NHL picks
All NHL picks, including SGPs, have been tracked since April 16.
| Bet type | Record | Net profit | ROI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 22-16-2 | +4.48 units ✅ | 21.18% ✅ |
| Goal scorer picks | 9-18 | -0.7 units ❌ | -12.63% ❌ |
💡 How I'm betting NHL goal scorer picks today
Follow all of our NHL analysis and expert predictions this season.
Goal scorer picks can be difficult, as represented by the plus-money odds. It's important not to get carried away with your bet sizes. That's why I'm wagering my standard 0.2 units on each.
Nailing two of three predictions would result in a profitable night, while winning all three would bring home nearly 1.5 units in profit. Bankroll management is crucial in sports betting, so be smart with yours.
Liam Fox