Eli Manning = HALL OF FAMER

[BigBlueNYG]

he's earned it

[seaborneq]

He's not through yet. I can see him winning another one or two and making everyone forget who his brother and dad are.

[NYSportsGuy210]

If he retires tomorrow I think he gets in but not as a first ballot. He has two three more productive years and maybe a couple of more post seasons and he will be a lock.

Tom Coughlin right now is a lock too.

[BigBlueNYG]

I'm not saying greatest of all time, but if he continues to put up good numbers he should be in Canton.

[Salmon Steak]

Sucks how he always is living in his brothers shadow. They even said something in the posting game ceremony. He was thinking, "shut the hell up. I just won the superbowl."

[freeVICK]

Eli lock for HOF?

If his career ended right now?

[SBR_John]

Yes, of course. Two very good Super Bowls where he drives his team to a go ahead victory guarantees it, as it should.

[mathdotcom]

Yes now

Once he gets caught on To catch a predator... No

[GamblerSpirit]

Whoever answers "NO" has their own agenda.

[Ernie Mccracken]

Eli leads his team to one of the biggest upsets in NFL history on a last minute drive to get his first super bowl MVP. En route to his second, he goes on the road and beats the team with the best offense ever and again gets Brady in the super bowl.

I know he comes off like an aspergers patient, but the resume is legit.

[Salmon Steak]

He could have 10 years left. The guys is only 31.

[Smoke]

Eli is better than big bro

Needs to avoid neck problems though like pey

[ttwarrior1]

If this was posted when terrell davis won his superbowls people would of said hall of famer???

[beerman2619]

Stats say otherwise son. For all these clowns saying Eli is better then Payton look at the stats. Look at the defense Payton has had to play behind since his time with the colts

Eli is better than big bro

Needs to avoid neck problems though like pey