Why do MLB GMs miss cheap players with high potential?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • donkdown
    Restricted User
    • 07-09-09
    • 4423

    #1
    Why do MLB GMs miss cheap players with high potential?
    It always amazes me how baseball GMs are willing to throw away multiple millions of dollars per year on a crappy middle infielder or no-name middle reliever, yet won't pony up the major league minimum for "sleeper" players with a lot of potential.

    Let's take Jonny Gomes, for example.

    This guy is a pure power hitter, and is 29 years old, which is the prime of most baseball careers.

    In just 281 at-bats with the Reds last year, he crushed 20 home runs and batted .267.

    Fluke? No. From 2005-2007, he hit 21, 20, and 17 home runs, respectively for Tampa Bay -- again with limited (350ish) at-bats.

    Now, Gomes has his faults. He sucks in the outfield, and his lifetime batting average is under .250. But the guy has a lot of power and drives in runs, and he was showing a lot of life in the second half of 2009.

    I wasn't expecting to see him ink a huge deal, but can you believe that not one MLB GM wanted to sign him? He couldn't get signed to a single club for the minimum.

    Finally, he accepted a minor-league contract from the Reds, who promoted him after a good spring.

    How's he doing this year? In 193 AB, he's hitting .306, with 9 HRs and is 4th in the NL with 48 RBIs. While the batting average is a surprise, the rest of the numbers aren't. If anything, he's actually hitting fewer home runs than expected.

    I just don't get it. With all the offense-challenged teams out there, how does every single club overlook a guy like Gomes, who would have been thrilled to sign for the Major League minimum?

    Can someone explain how this happens?
  • TWEETS
    SBR MVP
    • 10-22-08
    • 2114

    #2
    With his past stats, he wasnt good enough to fit into anyones starting lineup. New scenery and all of sudden he remembers how to play, no pressure makes it a little easier. Happens everyday.
    Comment
    • donkdown
      Restricted User
      • 07-09-09
      • 4423

      #3
      He couldnt fit into Pirates lineup?? He wasn't even signed is the point..
      Comment
      • mathdotcom
        SBR Posting Legend
        • 03-24-08
        • 11689

        #4
        donk

        you're missing all the GMs that do go with players who have potential and they fizzle out and disappear. Eventually one is going to find a diamond in the rough and is called a genius.
        Comment
        • Chi_archie
          SBR Aristocracy
          • 07-22-08
          • 63172

          #5
          premium on defense in the league over the past few years, combined with OBP issues and a huge Strike Out issue, GM's didn't want to take a chance on a guy that was gonna be 30 and hadn't gotten a full season under his belt is my guess
          Comment
          • Chi_archie
            SBR Aristocracy
            • 07-22-08
            • 63172

            #6
            guy also had some a serious heart attack at the age of 23
            Comment
            • ROYAJA8
              SBR MVP
              • 10-23-09
              • 2069

              #7
              Let the sorry players get paid i say.
              Comment
              • donkdown
                Restricted User
                • 07-09-09
                • 4423

                #8
                Really He had a heart attack??
                Comment
                • Chi_archie
                  SBR Aristocracy
                  • 07-22-08
                  • 63172

                  #9
                  Comment
                  Search
                  Collapse
                  SBR Contests
                  Collapse
                  Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                  Collapse
                  Working...