My new top 10 QB of all time list

[ttwarrior1]

1. Peyton Manning
2 Joe Montana
3 John Elway
4 Dan Marino
5. Johny U
6. Brett Favre
7 Terry Bradshaw
8 Steve Young
9 Fran Tarkentan
10 Eli Manning

Auto disqualifed
Tom Brady

[lakerboy]

Anyone who puts manning first is an idiot

[Vegas39]

Manning over Montana

[nyplayer33]

Brady is top 3 easily...he won many road games where the ball was not inflated etc. Who cares,,.they all cheat somehow. Red aureback used to have boston garden too hot or too cold in the visiting lockerrooms for the basketaball games.

[jtoler]

Brady is 37th on my list

[nyplayer33]

Eli Manning..lol..wtf!!! R u insane..many think he won't even be a hof....warren moon has a much better arm then he did

[Kermit]

Jesus Christ..

[OckertCR]

Peyton Manning

this site is unreal

[texhooper]

don't respond to this.

[Slanina]

Do you watch Football?

[SteveKerrsJunk]

He just said his top 10, he never specified "best," just his personal favorites I'm guessing and he wanted to take a shot at the guy who will be in Dublin in the HOF.

[str]

Otto Graham and Sammy Baugh must be right behind Eli.

[GunShard]

#1 Joe Montana

[STAX]

1. Tom Brady
2. Joe Montana
3. John Elway
4. Peyton Manning
5. Johnny Unitas
6. Otto Graham
7. Dan Marino
8. Roger Staubach
9. Steve Young
10. Aaron Rodgers
11. Brett Favre
12. Terry Bradshaw
13. Drew Brees
14. Dan Foutz
15. Fran Tarkenton
16. Sammy Baugh
17. Warren Moon
18. Troy Aikman
19. Bart Starr
20. Ben Rothlisberger
21. Kurt Warner
22. Joe Namath
23. Eli Manning
24. Bob Greise
25. Jim Kelly

[KiDBaZkiT]

Lol Gayton Manning???? guy isnt hardly top 5 current. Id take Rodgers, Brady, Breese, Roethlisberger over him in a sec.

[KiDBaZkiT]

^even get dumber just talking about WOMANning.

[Bcatswin]

Trent Dilfer

[Bandit]

1. Tom Brady
2. Joe Montana
3. John Elway
4. Peyton Manning
5. Johnny Unitas
6. Otto Graham
7. Dan Marino
8. Roger Staubach
9. Steve Young
10. Aaron Rodgers
11. Brett Favre
12. Terry Bradshaw
13. Drew Brees
14. Dan Foutz
15. Fran Tarkenton
16. Sammy Baugh
17. Warren Moon
18. Troy Aikman
19. Bart Starr
20. Ben Rothlisberger
21. Kurt Warner
22. Joe Namath
23. Eli Manning
24. Bob Greise
25. Jim Kelly

Interesting list Stax.
Looking over the QB's I liked Foutz a lot. Cannon for an arm and fawkin tough as nails.
Bradshaw, I'd switch him up with Aikman.

Best of the bunch below Favre imho would be Rothlisberger.
Good list though. Brady at #1, yep

[STAX]

One of the most underrated QBs ever was Roger Staubach. He missed his first 4 years (age 22-26) from the NFL because of being in the Navy. He was 27 years old his rookie season, and did not play an entire season at QB until he was 31. In 11 years as Dallas QB he won the NFC 5 times, won the Super Bowl twice, and retired as the 2nd rated passer in NFL history (behind Otto Graham). He actually only played 8 full seasons, reaching 4 Super BOwls and winning 2. His career record as a starter 96-35, including 11-6 in the playoffs. Both Super losses were to the Dynasty Steelers and the Steel Curtain by a total of 8 points (21-17 and 35-31).

[sweethook]

no way john elway is even in top 20 . and terry bradshaw should be top 5

[STAX]

no way john elway is even in top 20 . and terry bradshaw should be top 5

You cant be serious... Elway is in everyone's top 3. Basically 90% of people's top 3 are Montana, Elway, and Brady. its just the order that varies.

Mount Rushmore of QBs:

Brady
Montana
Elway

pick between: Unitas or Graham for the 4th, Peyton could be the 4th if he gets another ring

[htown1]

Manning by far the most overrated QB ever. Guy played in the same division with the Jaguars, Titans, and an expansion team in the Texans that didn't have a .500 year until 6 years in.Year after year Manning was guaranteed minimum 4 wins in the division. Luck will keep winning that division for the next 10+ years barring injury as well.

And lets not forget in his early years Manning was known as a choker in the playoffs and year after year he was 1 and done, despite a very solid running game and he always had solid Wide Receivers to throw to.Nothing impressive about his regular season numbers. 15-20 years down the road nobody in Indiana will remember Manning's name and Luck will be twice as good as Manning. Luck won a playoff game in his 2nd year, and will be winning multiple super bowls. Go look up how long it took Manning to win his first playoff game. Manning doesn't even belong in the top 10 of all time discussion.

[Ted Sheckler]

You cant be serious... Elway is in everyone's top 3. Basically 90% of people's top 3 are Montana, Elway, and Brady. its just the order that varies.

Mount Rushmore of QBs:

Brady
Montana
Elway

pick between: Unitas or Graham for the 4th, Peyton could be the 4th if he gets another ring

Is Lebron on the mount rushmore of NBA players? Or is he off the list until he gets another ring?

[DiggityDaggityDo]

TT, this was your top ten list last year:

http://www.sportsbookreview.com/foru...-all-time.html

1 Peyton Manning
2 Joe Montana
3 John Elway
4 Dan Marino
5 Bret Favre
6 Johny Unitas
7 Bart Starr
8 Tom Brady
9 Otto Graham
10 Steve Young


Just missed
Troy Aikman, Terry Bradshaw, Sammy Baugh, Roger Staubach

And this is your current list:

1. Peyton Manning2 Joe Montana
3 John Elway
4 Dan Marino
5. Johny U
6. Brett Favre
7 Terry Bradshaw
8 Steve Young
9 Fran Tarkentan
10 Eli Manning


Auto disqualifed
Tom Brady

Why did Unitas jump ahead of Favre?

Why did Bart Starr fall off your list?

Same thing with Otto Graham. Where is he?

What did Bradshaw and Tarkentan do in the last year that they made the list and bumped out Starr or Graham?

[STAX]

Is Lebron on the mount rushmore of NBA players? Or is he off the list until he gets another ring?

firmly on the list

[Ted Sheckler]

firmly on the list

Already? Duncan/Jordan/Kobe/Shaq all have more points and more RINGS...HOw in the world could you say Lebron is "firmly on there" and say Peyton is not on the list unless he gets one more.

Rings don't matter in the NBA, but matter in the NFL? makes no sense.

[htown1]

Is Lebron on the mount rushmore of NBA players? Or is he off the list until he gets another ring?

Lebron is Jason Kidd with alot more athleticism and a lot blacker. Average Jump shooter who has great IQ and creates for others. Jason Kidd was probably a better rebounder though.

[Ted Sheckler]

Lebron is Jason Kidd with alot more athleticism and a lot blacker. Average Jump shooter who has great IQ and creates for others. Jason Kidd was probably a better rebounder though.

Thanks for the comparison, never seen either of them play, but I just flipped on youtube highlights and definitely see the similarities.

[htown1]

Thanks for the comparison, never seen either of them play, but I just flipped on youtube highlights and definitely see the similarities.

Kidd at his prime was as good as anyone. Not only was he a great passer and leader, he was also a very good rebounder often leading his team in rebounding despite being a guard. Also what people forget about him was that he was an outstanding defender as well. People often knock him for his poor shooting however he improved his shooting as his career progressed and he ranks top 5 in all time 3 pointers made. People say what made him such a good passer was that he didn't trust himself to shoot and would rather create for other players. Without a doubt 1 of the 5 best Point Guards to ever play the game. Not surprised he is having success as a coach as well.

[ttwarrior1]

brady is dq, sorry

[thechaoz]

Manning lol..you are high

[KingHutch]

Some explain how Manning is even top 5? Dudes only SB win is against Rex Grossman, complete choke job that gets his receivers killed year in year out. Regular season statpiling doesn't mean shit when you totally meltdown in the playoffs against quality defenses.

[greenhippo]

Elway

[greenhippo]

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/778095-john-elway-why-hes-the-most-overrated-athlete-of-all-time

Elway

[htown1]

Some explain how Manning is even top 5? Dudes only SB win is against Rex Grossman, complete choke job that gets his receivers killed year in year out. Regular season statpiling doesn't mean shit when you totally meltdown in the playoffs against quality defenses.

can't wait till ELI wins another SuperBowl this year and Peyton isn't even considered the greatest Manning ever.